If state Rep. David Levdansky, D-Forward, is re-elected in the 39th Legislative District, he promises to do the same job for constituents that he's done for the past 20 years.

That's precisely why his challenger, Republican Brad Grantz, of Elizabeth Township, said he was running to unseat the incumbent.

Grantz, 23, a 2003 graduate of Carnegie Mellon University who is currently unemployed after being laid off from a sales job with an industrial equipment company, said he was "tired of business as usual" in Harrisburg and tired of "career politicians" such as Levdansky who don't make good on promises to bring jobs to the area or to lower property taxes.

Both Levdansky and Grantz said jobs and taxes were key issues to voters in the district, which includes Clairton, Forward, South Park, Elizabetth Borough, Jefferson Hills, West Elizabeth and part of Elizabeth Township in Allegheny County, plus Nottingham, Union, Finleyville, New Eagle and part of Carroll in Washington County.

Advertise with us

"Someone needs to be showing leadership and saying 'this isn't right,"' said Grantz, who has pledged to donate half of his $67,000 legislative salary to the district during his first term if he is elected.

Grantz, who said he had knocked on more than 4,000 doors, said he frequently heard people complain about the burden of their real estate taxes and saw people his age leave the area because they couldn't find jobs.

He said he believed there should be term limits on legislators and has vowed to serve no more than five terms if elected.

Levdansky, 50, who was first elected to the Legislature in 1984, takes exception to Grantz's charges because he believes the Legislature has taken recent significant action to address both economic development and real estate taxes.

The incumbent said he would like to go door to door in the district but couldn't because his legislative work keeps him busy and a herniated disc in his back that is compressed onto his sciatic nerve is limiting his mobility.

Advertise with us

Levdansky said recent legislation that he supported included Act 72, which allows slots proceeds to be used to lower local real estate taxes and allows voters the choice of shifting part of their tax burden from real estate taxes to either earned income tax or personal income tax.

Grantz said he supported the Stop Taxing Our Property proposal created by late night talk show host Bob Logue and supported by a contingent of the Legislature known as the Commonwealth Caucus.

The STOP plan calls for the elimination of county, school district and municipal real estate taxes on primary residences and farmsteads. They would remain on commercial properties and second homes.

That revenue would be replaced with an increase to the state's 6 percent sales tax, personal income tax and the real estate transfer tax.

Grantz said he thought a quick and dramatic change in the state's tax system was necessary to stop the record number of foreclosures in Allegheny County in the past year and to prevent senior citizens from having to choose between buying their medication or paying their property taxes.

Advertise with us

The STOP plan would solve the problem of high property taxes, which are used mainly to pay for schools, by shifting to the other types of taxes.

But Grantz wants to go further. He wants to see the state change the way the tax funds are distributed to school districts so that the present disparity between wealthy districts and poor districts is eliminated.

Grantz would like to see smaller struggling school districts merged with nearby larger, healthier districts. "The way we fund education now is wrong," Grantz said.

To help create jobs, Levdansky said, he supported Gov. Ed Rendell's $1.1 billion economic stimulus plan, which calls for the sale of bonds that will supply low-interest loans and grants for job creation. Jobs are expected to be created in agriculture, tourism, high technology and the cleanup of industrial brownfields, or abandoned industrial sites.

Grantz said he believed the way to create jobs is "to encourage entrepreneurship, to create incentives for small businesses to start."

Advertise with us

Responding to Grantz's suggestion that Levdansky has been in office too long, the legislator said his seniority in the Legislature was the reason he is the Democratic chair of the of the House Finance Committee, which oversees tax codes and all revenue bills, and is the second ranking Democrat on the House Energy and Environmental Resources Committee.

His longevity, he said, has allowed him to develop relationships with other legislators and staff members of the various state departments that help him work for the good of his district. "A lot of what goes on in government is based on experience and relationships, and you can only build that with tenure and longevity," Levdansky said.

Those relationships have helped him bring millions of dollars for community development projects to the district during his decades in office, Levdansky said.

Levdansky said Grantz's lack of experience would hamper his effectiveness as a legislator.

Levdansky said Grantz had little work experience other than nine months as a sales representative for an industrial equipment company, doesn't own a home, lives with his parents and doesn't pay property taxes.

Advertise with us

Grantz, who received a bachelor's degree in business administration from Carnegie Mellon in August 2003 and served as the editor of the school's newspaper in 2002, said he was tired of hearing that he is too young to run for office and pointed out that Levdansky was 29 when he first ran for the Legislature.

But Levdansky winces at the comparison, noting that when he first ran, he was seven years older and held two bachelor's degrees from Penn State in political science and labor studies, and a master's degree in economics from Notre Dame.

In addition, he said, he had worked for four years as an economic analyst and organizer for labor unions, including the United Steelworkers, the AFL-CIO and the Airline Pilots Association.

"I had a lot of exposure to real life issues and problems that people deal with. My whole motivation in life has been to improve the standard of living for middle and working class people," Levdansky said.

Grantz criticized Levdansky for not introducing much legislation during his tenure.

Advertise with us

Levdansky said he wrote the state "motor voter law" which allows drivers to register to vote or change registration, wrote the section of the governor's annual budget that identifies tax loopholes and wrote the municipal and citizens protection provisions of Acts 101 and 108, which are parts of the Pennsylvania Municipal Solid Waste Act.

Levdansky said he wrote the section of the governor's economic stimulus package that deals with tax increment financing.

Of the 50 percent of his salary Grantz plans to donate to the district, $15,000 would be used for a Community Development Corp. for the communities of West Elizabeth, Finleyville and New Eagle. The rest would be used for scholarship funds.

Levdansky said he had also given away part of his salary without publicly announcing it.

After the last legislative pay raise, which was approved as a monthly unvouchered expense because legislators are not permitted to give themselves raises during the session they are serving, he said, he donated the raise -- about $18,000 over an 18-month period -- to charitable, community and volunteer groups in his district.

Again, this year, the Legislature got a cost-of-living increase that equals about $100 a month, and Levdansky said he was donating his to various churches throughout the district.