A state House primary in Pittsburgh's South Hills has become the focus of intrigue and unusual attention from senior politicians across the Commonwealth.

Rep. Michael Diven, D-Brookline, is being challenged by Rich Nerone, a businessman and former unsuccessful candidate for Pittsburgh City Council and Allegheny County recorder of deeds. With rare exceptions, legislative incumbents in the state cruise to re-election. Diven, a maverick in Harrisburg and within his party's local organization, has managed to irritate enough senior Democrats, however, that the leaders of the Democratic caucus in Harrisburg have taken the unprecedented step of lining up against him.

"Mike Veon and Bill DeWeese have served, collectively, almost 50 years in the General Assembly, and this is the first time we have decided incontrovertibly not to support one of our incumbents," said Rep. DeWeese, D-Greene, the House minority leader. Veon, D-Beaver, is DeWeese's longtime ally at the head of the Harrisburg caucus.

But Diven, the son of the legendary political figure and sometime street fighter Joey Diven, has friends as well as enemies among statewide politicians. Their intervention in the 22nd District race has added one more layer to the complex maneuvering over what would normally be a little-noticed local contest.

Advertise with us

Diven is not the only incumbent facing opposition among the relatively few contested House seats in the region on the April 27 ballot.

In the 38th District in the Mon Valley, Rep. Ken Ruffing, D-West Mifflin, has two opponents: Mike Ducker, a corrections officer and member of Baldwin Borough council, and Jamie Colecchi of Glassport, a former staff member to U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Swissvale. There are also a handful of other contested House primaries in surrounding counties. But none of these has attracted the unusual attention like the Diven race.

The former City Council member was first elected to the House in 2000, and from his back-bench perch took an interest in a variety of urban and school funding issues. He truculently proclaimed his determination not to follow a to-get-along-go-along path with a widely distributed e-mail after the 2001 redistricting process, in which he denounced the Democratic House hierarchy as "cowards, men who are not leaders; rather thugs that will exploit any angle to protect their own selfish agendas."

Diven ended his missive with the advice, "I welcome all your feedback, but remember, I'm 6'5", 280 lbs. and a former Golden Gloves fighter, so don't let your mouth write checks your body can't cash."

Diven continued his independent ways in the new administration of Gov. Ed Rendell. He was one of the few Democrats, and the only one from Allegheny County, to oppose the administration on its initial budget vote last year. He similarly strayed from the party line on subsequent budget and gambling votes.

Advertise with us

"I think the people of my district like the fact that I'm someone who is independent and willing to stand up for their interests," Diven said.

That may be true for many of them -- even his opponents acknowledge that he is the favorite in the primary -- but it's clearly not a universal sentiment. Among his less-admiring constituents are state Sen. Jack Wagner, D-Beechview, a candidate for auditor general, and his brother, Pete Wagner, the influential Democratic chairman of the city's 18th Ward. Diven has a history of clashes with the Wagners. He supported one of Sen. Wagner's rivals for the auditor general nomination before that candidate withdrew from the race. The Wagners, in turn, supported Anthony Coghill, a businessman who, with their support, easily defeated Diven in the endorsement vote of the district's Democratic Committee members earlier this year.

That's when Diven called in some chips. Among his longtime political allies is Lt. Gov. Catherine Baker Knoll, for whom he worked as an adviser and chauffeur in her successful run for the state's second spot. Prompted by her intervention, Rep. Bob Brady, chairman of the Philadelphia Democratic Party, reportedly approached Sen. Wagner and urged him, in the interests of party unity, to urge Coghill to get out of the race.

In an interview, Sen. Wagner acknowledged that he had had discussions with Brady on a variety of topics but denied that he had done anything to pressure Coghill to withdraw. Coghill says his decision to drop from the race, despite a commanding win in the Democratic endorsement vote, was his own. Wagner, insists that he has taken little interest in the House contest, noting that his own statewide campaign was consuming all of his political energy.

In any case, to the delight of DeWeese, Coghill's departure did not mean smooth sailing for Diven. With little early notice, since he skipped the party's initial endorsement vote, Nerone emerged as another challenger.

Advertise with us

"Nerone and I had conversations along with a variety of other figures including Mr. Coghill," DeWeese said of Nerone's decision to run. "Potentially, some of our conversations may have been a galvanizing influence."

DeWeese did not deny personal animus in his decision to back the challenger, but he said that the more important motivation was based on Diven's votes against Rendell's key legislative initiatives.

"His singular and obtuse behavior is outright self-indulgence," DeWeese said. "Mr. Diven spit in the governor's face when he decided to vote against his budget supplications."

The Insider, a Harrisburg-based political newsletter, reported this week that Diven has since made peace with Rendell, promising to be a more loyal supporter of the governor's agenda. Diven could not immediately be reached to comment on that account.

Diven contended that with Coghill's departure, he would inherit the Democratic Party's offical support since he was the runner-up in the party election. But Tom Flaherty, the party chairman, decided that a new vote should be held. Diven protested, but was rebuffed in a legal challenge to Flaherty's decision. It was not the first time that those two Democrats had clashed in court. Diven has also unsuccessfully challenged party rules that dictate a secret ballot for endorsement votes.

Advertise with us

DeWeese defended his unusual intervention, contending that Diven was receiving fund-raising help from the House's Republican speaker, Rep. John Perzel, R-Phila., as a reward for some of his votes against the caucus line.

Nerone cited Diven's support for Perzel on Philadelphia issues as one area of criticism, while arguing that the incumbent, in his years on council and in the Legislature, should have been a more effective voice for city funding issues.

Diven defended his record, claiming a leadership role on urban issues including measures to restore blighted neighborhoods and fight graffiti. He professed to be amused but unconcerned by the unusual attention to his race.

"Things are going well," Diven said. "I'm very confident."

Among the other contested races in the primaries in the region is the 16th District, which is dominated by Beaver County communities but includes a sliver of Allegheny County along the Ohio River. The Democratic candidates there are John Cermak, of Harmony; Sam Kovolenko, of Ambridge; Brain M. Padgett, of Economy; Dennis C. Baker, of Baden; and Sean Ramaley, of Economy.

Advertise with us

In that district's GOP primary, Ted Kerr, of Franklin Park, is running against Pat Geho, of Baden. The seat's incumbent, Rep. Susan Laughlin, is not seeking re-election.

There is another crowded field in the 60th District, which includes parts of Armstrong and Indiana counties. The Democratic candidates there are Barry M. Crytzer, of Rayburn; Jodi Sysyn Myers, of Kittanning; and Marc Vincent Taiani, of Spring Church. Republican contenders there are Jeff Pyle, of Ford City; Dan Warner of Manor; Rebekah Snyder-Starr, of West Kittanning; and Ronald Covone of South Buffalo.

Two Democratic incumbents in Washington County seats face primary challengers. Rep. Victor Lescovitz, of Smith, is opposed by Jesse White, of Cecil, in the 46th District, and Rep. Peter J. Daley, of California, faces Randy Barli, of Coal Center, in the 49th District.