The Ohio Clean Water Fund — which solicited $149,000 in donations while claiming the fund was in partnership with a food bank to support East Palestine residents — settled their lawsuit with the Ohio attorney general on Thursday.

The lawsuit was filed in April after Second Harvest Food Bank of the Mahoning Valley contacted the attorney general, Dave Yost, and said the food bank never gave the water fund permission to solicit donations on their behalf.

“We received phone calls from people throughout the country that were being solicited through texts to verify whether it was true that we were collaborating with these individuals,” said Michael Iberis, executive director of the food bank in Youngstown, Ohio. “That’s how we were tipped off.”

Food bank officials knew the water fund’s founder, Michael Peppel, Mr. Iberis said. The water fund gave Second Harvest $10,000 prior to the lawsuit after the food bank confronted Mr. Peppel about the donations.

Advertise with us

Under the settlement, Mr. Peppel will have to pay a $25,000 civil penalty, and is permanently banned from being a part of operating or soliciting for any charity in Ohio.

“These scammers preyed on generous donors to try to line their own pockets, but ultimately were stopped and shut down,” said Mr. Yost, in a press release.

The Ohio Clean Water Fund’s main fundraiser, WAMA Strategies, was also involved in the settlement. WAMA’s owners, Isaiah Wartman and Luke Mahoney, were ordered to pay $22,077.48 to Second Harvest and $3,000 to the Ohio Attorney General to cover investigative costs and fees, according to the settlement. The company is also banned from working with any charity in Ohio for four years.

“This settlement means the cost incurred by the state to investigate and prosecute does not come out of the food bank’s pockets,” Mr. Yost said.

The Water Fund and Mr. Yost had previously come to a settlement agreement in June in Columbiana County Common Pleas Court.

Advertise with us

Under the agreement, the water fund was to pay $116,904.88 to the food bank and $15,000 in civil penalties, and fully dissolve the company. Later, financial documents showed Mr. Peppel and WAMA had raised more than what they had claimed — which was $141,000.

The settlement on Thursday was “precisely the outcome we were looking for,” Mr. Yost said, in a press release.

Second Harvest Food Bank plans on donating “every dollar” to East Palestine recovery efforts once they receive the funds.

“We have a vested interest in this because our director of development lives in East Palestine,” said Mr. Iberis. “So, we’ll be working with schools, the community and with other social service organizations there to support them.”

Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com