QUECREEK, Pa. — Forty-one Amish and Mennonite travelers of all ages listened intensely as Vicky Weimer told the story of the Quecreek Mine rescue.
“Death is knocking at the door,” she said of the rising water that reached the coal miners’ shoulders as they huddled in the cramped darkness. They were trapped 240 feet below a dairy farm in Somerset County 20 years ago today after boring into an adjacent flooded mine.
A little girl with blond pigtails called out, “Mama,” and started to cry. A woman in a white bonnet sat the girl in her lap, but kept her eyes fixed on Ms. Weimer.
Quecreek after 20 years
Ms. Weimer’s presentation came July 16 at the start of commemorative events for the 20th anniversary of the Quecreek Mine rescue. People still come to see the site and hear the story of how all nine trapped miners were saved four days later, but the visitor center doesn’t host the number of tours it did before the pandemic. And as the coal industry dies out in the region, Quecreek is struggling to resonate with younger generations.
The heroism of the rescue has long attracted visitors from across the country.

Bill Arnold is executive director of the Quecreek Rescue Mine Foundation. He was also the first local to join the rescue the night of July 24, 2002, because the miners were trapped below his family’s dairy farm.
Read More
“I ended up actually turning the first earth in the rescue,” he said, “digging with my backhoe to make sure that we weren't going to hit an active gas line with a drill rig and cause another disaster.”
Thanks to the swift aid of people like Mr. Arnold in collaboration with local firefighters, state police, EMS personnel, federal and state officials and mine rescue specialists, a steel cage was sent down through a drilled hole in the ground to bring the miners to the surface July 28.
Like a pilgrimage to the site of a miracle, thousands of visitors inundated Quecreek the weeks after the rescue, Mr. Arnold said.

In response to the tremendous show of public interest and support, the Arnold family sought to develop the site into a permanent monument looked after by the Quecreek Mine Rescue Foundation, which they founded in 2003.
“This never was a ‘build it and they will come’ scenario,” Mr. Arnold said. “This is a ‘build it because they are coming’ scenario.”
With the site relatively close to the nation’s capital, Gettysburg and Fallingwater, tours came from across the nation, making a stop at Quecreek to lighten the mood after visiting the Flight 93 Memorial, also in Somerset County, where one of the four hijacked planes crashed on September 11 the year before.
Though visitors largely come from east of the Mississippi River and as far south as Georgia, Quecreek has had tours from California. In the last two years, they’ve had 10-12 motorcoaches from Indiana, which Mr. Arnold expects to be their largest growing source of visitors.
“This never was a ‘build it and they will come’ scenario. This is a ‘build it because they are coming’ scenario.”
Before COVID, Mr. Arnold said Quecreek saw at least 100 motorcoaches a year, each bringing 50 people.
Darlene June, who is Ms. Weimer’s cousin from Acosta, Somerset County, works the visitor center counter. She estimated that between a third and half of those motorcoaches were Amish and Mennonite tours.
Over the years since the rescue, Bishop Eli Weaver, who led an Amish Church in Dundee, Ohio, had brought numerous motorcoaches.
Figuring the bishop had done his fair share of barn raising, Mr. Arnold asked him one day “if he had ever done a visitor center-raising.”
For three years, vans of Amish and Mennonites would come for two days at a time to work on the visitor center. Mr. Arnold said that they donated 90% of the building’s labor. They completed the building in 2015.
Ms. Weimer, who started giving tours in 2015, noted that word of mouth in the tight-knit Amish community kept them coming.
But the miracle of the rescue brings them as well, as it had for Ms. Weimer.
The morning after the miners had been trapped in the mine, Ms. Weimer began to weep inexplicably as she was cleaning her church. After hearing the news, she felt it was a sign.
“I came here because it was such an amazing story,” she said.
Born again at the age of 8, Ms. Weimer is Pentecostal and it shows in the way she recounts the rescue.
With Romans 5:8 on the slide show, she told how being trapped in the mine inspired a religious awakening in many of the survivors.
After Ms. Weimer finished her presentation, a short man in a plain white shirt with a long beard asked her if there was much coal mining in Somerset today.
Robert Miller had taken a bus with his wife and nine children to see Sight & Sound, a Lancaster-based Bible story theater company, the day before and stopped by Quecreek before the bus would return to Millersburg, Ohio.
Reflecting on the abbreviated tour, he muttered in a Pennsylvania Dutch accent, “It was very thoughtful and interesting – a lot to be thankful for.”

While the Amish and Mennonites still come, the pandemic continues to hamper tours.
Tours dropped off when the state closed non-essential facilities, including Quecreek.
Even when they were permitted to reopen because the Quecreek visitor center could accommodate socially distanced groups, Mr. Arnold explained many motorcoaches canceled their tours because other stops along the way couldn’t accommodate them.
Because admissions fees mostly fund the foundation’s operating expenses, Mr. Arnold tried everything he could to keep the lights on.
There were “six months when I didn’t receive a paycheck,” he said, then another three this past winter. “When you don’t have an income, I was dipping into my own pocket to pay phone expenses.”
Mr. Arnold expects that increased awareness due to the 20th anniversary will bring more people to Quecreek.
“Hopefully, by the end of the year, we’re full steam,” he said.
But low pandemic numbers might be stickier than expected.
Ms. Weimer, who’s given tours since 2015, called Sight & Sound to find out if they saw a decline in tours as well. They had, in part because local restaurants and motels no longer had the staff to accommodate such large groups.
"These [mining] folks are worthy of our support and fondness because the industry they built and the families they supported against great economic odds had a lot to do with the success of Somerset County over the years."
But one sign is encouraging.
Examining their merchandise sales, the gift shop had taken in $10,460 in 2018, $583 in 2020, and $9,716 in 2022 – just $744 short of their pre-pandemic levels. Ms. Weimer couldn’t wait to tell Mr. Arnold.
While the Quecreek center may be able to recover from the pandemic, the decline of coal mining in Pennsylvania means it may have less salience in the next generation, meaning the center may have to tell not only the story of the rescue but of mining itself.
During last weekend’s events in advance of the anniversary former governor Mark Schweiker said, “These [mining] folks are worthy of our support and fondness because the industry they built and the families they supported against great economic odds had a lot to do with the success of Somerset County over the years.”
But he added, “The industry is in decline,” given that Pennsylvania soft coal production and jobs have been decreasing for some time now. “That there will be some remarkable uptick is unlikely.”
Coal mining is an industry where sons followed their fathers into the mines. Not so much with the survivors.
John Unger returned to the coal industry after his rescue. Though he primarily worked in loading and hauling coal outside the mine, he went inside when it was needed.
Asked last weekend whether his adult children entered the mines after him, he yelled out, “Oh God no!”
He clarified, “My son would never go there.” Even if his father wasn’t trapped in the Quecreek Mine, Mr. Unger said, “He never wanted to go anyways.” His son works in printing instead.

Another survivor, Blaine Mayhugh, said his father-in-law who mined for 30 years helped him get into the industry.
But Mr. Mayhugh never encouraged his kids to mine. He tells younger guys interested in mining, “You can make a decent living at it, … just it's dangerous and it's a lot of wear and tear on the body.”
Not only is the family tradition of coal mining fading, but there just is not much coal left to mine.
The bituminous coal reserves of southwest Pennsylvania are depleted, leaving behind hills of junk coal and leftover rocks that 20-somethings ride on with their dirt bikes.
“You can make hill climbs out of it,” said Willi Buss, a 25 year-old who works part-time for Mr. Arnold on his dairy farm.
A 22 year-old landscaper, Connor Singo also works on the farm. His father helped build the drill bits used in a 2010 Chilean mine rescue, working for the same company Center Rock that built the bits for Quecreek.
“I don’t know anyone my age who does deep mining,” he said. “There just isn’t the coal here that there used to be.”
Asked about the events for the Quecreek anniversary, Nash Frazier, who rides with Mr. Singo and Mr. Buss, said, “If we weren’t involved with Bill, we probably wouldn’t be here.”
“It’s not going to bring the 20-year-olds,” he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.