This story was updated Sunday, April 10 at 7:15 p.m.

The fallout from Allegheny County Council’s rejection of board nominations made by County Executive Rich Fitzgerald is apparently not over.

Council will hear a motion at next week’s meeting to censure one of their own after a verbal altercation following a March meeting where council denied the appointments.

The motion, sponsored by President Pat Catena, seeks to censure Councilman Tom Duerr for “conduct detrimental to county council,” according to the motion.

Advertise with us

Following the March 22 meeting Mr. Duerr, allegedly “accosted” Councilman John Palmiere “in a hostile tone of voice,” the motion said.

The motion goes on to explain that Mr. Duerr said to Mr. Palmiere: “I always knew you were a [expletive] coward” in regards to “one or more votes” that Mr. Palmiere had cast during the meeting.

Despite being recommended by the Committee on Appointment Review, three of Mr. Fitzgerald’s nominations were denied when the vote went to full council — two of which were to serve on the Alcosan board and one was for a position on the Jail Oversight Board.

Mr. Palmiere had voted against all three of the county executive’s nominations at the meeting, while Mr. Duerr was in favor of them.

The day after the meeting, Mr. Duerr released a statement on Twitter saying that “these were the least transparent votes” taken during his time on council and called them “personal and vindictive.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Duerr and Mr. Palmiere are both Democrats, as is Mr. Fitzgerald.

Mr. Catena said that this incident occurred “immediately after” the meeting had ended and the livestream had cut off. In reviewing the archived livestream, the incident was not shown.

He then said that he was made aware of the situation by Mr. Palmiere as well as two other council members who say they saw the event take place.

“As president I have a responsibility obviously to assure that basically any rude or disrespectful behavior won’t be tolerated in County Council,” Mr. Catena said Friday afternoon. “Honestly, I understand there might be disagreements on issues from time to time among council members, but personal attacks have no place in the process, and I’m not going to tolerate them.”

The motion demands that Mr. Duerr issue an apology to Mr.  Palmiere “on the record no later than the April 26, 2022 regular meeting of council” and to “refrain from any such public behavior at all times in the future.”

Advertise with us

Because this motion is being presented as new business, Mr. Catena plans to send it straight to committee where it can be discussed rather than having open discussion during Tuesday’s meeting.

Censuring a member of council “doesn’t happen very often,” Mr. Catena said, but he felt he had a “responsibility” to go forward with it.

On Sunday, Mr. Duerr released a statement stating that he had reached out to Mr. Palmiere to apologize “for offending him with the sharpness of the words I chose to use.”

“While I was, and continue to be, extremely upset about the conduct surrounding many of my colleagues’ votes at that meeting, I clearly should have been more selective with my words during our interaction, and for that I am sorry,” the statement said.

Mr. Duerr went on to say that he will not apologize for “the sentiment” behind his comments and that the constituents deserve a “fair and transparent process.”

Advertise with us

“By not giving that to them, these members are neglecting their elected duty and responsibility as County Councilmembers, and I will never apologize for holding our members, regardless of party, accountable for making sure fairness and transparency are a part of each and every vote we take,” Mr. Duerr’s statement said.

In regards to the blocked nominations, Mr. Fitzgerald has also submitted a new recommendation to the council for a member to serve on the Alcosan board.

This time around, the recommendation is a member of council, Paul Klein. Mr. Klein has served on the council since 2015 and voted to approve two of Mr. Fitzgerald’s previous appointment recommendations at the March 22 meeting.

Mr. Klein voted in favor of the Alcosan nominees but against the oversight board nomination.

“It’s more important than ever that the ALCOSAN board consists of individuals who have the best interests of the public in mind and whose interest in guiding this project to completion remains focused on the goals of the Clean Water Plan,” Mr. Fitzgerald said in a statement Friday. “It is for that reason that I am nominating your colleague, Council Member Paul Klein.”

Advertise with us

The recommendation has been added to Tuesday’s agenda and from there will be sent to the appointment review committee, chaired by Councilwoman Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, for its consideration.

If it is affirmatively recommended it will return to full council for a vote. If approved Mr. Klein will fill the seat that had been occupied by County Treasurer John Weinstein. The term will last through Dec. 31, 2023.

Mr. Klein did not return requests for comment.

County council will meet at 5 p.m. Tuesday, April 12 in the Gold Room of the Allegheny County Courthouse. Meetings are also livestreamed via the council’s website. 

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com