Ten years ago, the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh was planning to close four branches and merge two more because due to a nearly $2 million drop in state funding.

Today, those branches are open, many six and some seven days a week, for longer hours, with more robust staffing and services. That’s one result of the money raised each year since 2013 from a property tax increase that Pittsburgh voters approved in 2011. The first year the yield was $3.9 million. This fiscal year it is $4.5 million.

“We have increased support to neighborhood libraries as a result,” said CLP president and director Mary Frances Cooper. “To support children after school, job seekers, maker spaces for teens, music recording and film making. We have learned that adults want to do that as well and we are expanding those programs.”

“Libraries need to be supported as the essential service they are,” she said. “What’s important to us is impact.”

Advertise with us

But not all library impact is created equal. The difference in some cases hinges on local support, or lack of it.

The Allegheny County Library Association is provided a state allocation of $3.7 million and Regional Asset District funding (city and county) of $6.3 million each year. It distributes $1.3 million of the state money to the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, which gets its own RAD funds — $22.3 million. The rest of the total allocation is distributed among 45 libraries outside the city, said Marilyn Jenkins, executive director of the Allegheny County Library Association.

Table gaming revenue provides a pot between $500,000 and $600,000 a year for all the libraries except the Carnegie system, which gets its own — $690,000

With 19 branches, the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh operates on about $31 million a year.

Other than a handful of municipalities that passed property tax referendums to fund libraries, there is no tax for libraries outside the city of Pittsburgh, she said.

Advertise with us

“There is also no state mandate on local support,” she said. “In some other states, Iowa, for instance, every municipality has to pay to support a library.”

If a municipality doesn’t have a library, it has to support the one nearby, she said.

One thing that makes everything equal in Allegheny County is the electronic information network operated by the library association and paid for by RAD money. Anyone in the county can check out the holdings of every library in the county and have something delivered to their home library, Ms. Cooper said.

Local support key

The recession of 2008-09 forced the state to cut its allocations. The Carnegie system got $3.3 million, down from the usual $5 million, Ms. Cooper said.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh City Council  responded to the Carnegie’s distress signals with an emergency $600,000 to keep the Beechview, West End, Hazelwood and Lawrenceville branches open, and prevent the Carrick and Knoxville branches from having to merge.

Two years later, Pittsburgh voters passed a tax increase for their Carnegie libraries.

A jump in state funds is expected this year, which should bring an added $300,000 to the Carnegie system, Ms. Cooper said.

But it’s local support that often makes the biggest difference, Ms. Jenkins said.

Monroeville and Mt. Lebanon get the largest part of their budgets from their municipalities. Mt. Lebanon owns and maintains the library’s building besides contributing $1.3 million, or 70% of the library’s budget, said Robyn Vittek, the library’s director.

Advertise with us

Nicole Henline, director of the Monroeville Public Library, said Monroeville provides $1.2 million, or 75% of the library’s budget.

“We’ve always been a place for everybody but what we offer has changed,” she said. “We have hands-on opportunities for people to connect, participate in a club, join a discussion. We have job training, help with taxes, computer training. We do a lot of one-on-one and small classes. We have a makerlab with laser cutters, robotics and circuitry, CD printer and scanner, sewing machines. It’s a growing thing.”

At a time when libraries have become lifelines for many people, all libraries, even the ones in wealthy areas, have to raise funds. All are doing more, some with less.

One stark example is the Sto-Rox Public Library in McKees Rocks, which operates on $109,500 a year, not counting the occasional grant money and revenue from people using the copying machine.

“We used to have fines [for late returns], but people couldn’t pay them so now we are a fine-free library,” Cindy Haines, executive director of Focus on Renewal, the non-profit that runs the library.

Advertise with us

The library has not received an allocation from McKees Rocks Borough for several years, and said she did not make a request for one this year.

Neighboring Stowe does kick in. Township manager Nick Martini said the library’s request for 2019 was $2,000 and that’s what Stowe approved. He said the township gives the same amount, “usually yearly.”

The largest chunk to the Sto-Rox Library is $81,000 from RAD. The state gives $19,000 and another $7,000 comes from table gaming revenue.

“Anything else we need to keep the doors open we have to find,” said Aurora Smith, Focus on Renewal’s finance director.

“Sometimes, we get a foundation that helps us raise our level,” Ms. Haines said. “We get some grants and private donations, small amounts. Every penny counts.”

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.