When Bishop Dorsey McConnell talks to children about Jesus and the Easter story, he likes to invoke a bit of Fred Rogers.
“When I was a boy and I would see scary things in the news, my mother would say , ‘Look for the helpers. You will always find people who are helping,’” Mr. Rogers famously said.
Bishop McConnell, who serves as bishop of The Diocese of Pittsburgh of the Episcopal Church in Southwestern Pennsylvania, encourages children to “look for the helpers” when they are sad and afraid. Jesus will send them, he said.
But that isn’t the beginning of his lesson about Easter. That lesson starts with the gruesome detail that Jesus has been brutally killed on the cross. The bishop skirts around the graphic details, but encourages children to “sit” with the story. In other words, he asks his young audience to think about how it makes them feel and how they can reconcile a story of violence with a God who promotes peace.
“Adults have a way of wanting to jump to our happy place, so we say ‘Oh gosh, yes, he was on the cross, but let’s talk about Easter and let’s go on an Easter egg hunt and what about the bunny?’ And that does not do a kid any good,” he said.
“Children know and they want an adult who understands ... who can say this is sad and scary and we need to stay with it for a bit and then find out what love grows from this very sad and scary place.”
For children today, however, violent stories are not restricted to those in the Bible. They see violence in movies, video games, news channels and, for some, in their own communities.
Studies from as far back as the 1980s have shown the portrayal of violence in the media that children consume may make them less sensitive to the pain and suffering of others, more fearful of the world and more likely to behave in aggressive or harmful ways, according to a report from the American Psychological Association.
For Bishop McConnell, that is even more incentive to address the violence that children learn in the Bible and especially during Easter Week, so that they don’t become immune to human suffering in the world — as long as teachers, parents and church leadership stress that the story doesn’t stop there.
He isn’t alone in that thinking.
“When I work with kids, I like to talk about how the violence in the story is real, but it’s not the end of the story,” said Liddy Barlow, executive minister of Christian Associates of Southwest Pennsylvania. “In the same way, Christians believe that the violence in our world is real, but it’s not the end of the story.”
Her ecumenical organization promotes unity and is headquartered on North Highland Avenue in Pittsburgh.
Violence has always been there, Rev. Barlow noted, whether in a child’s imagination, through fairy tales and stories of zombies and vampires, in history and even in a child’s family, school or neighborhood.
“Rather than this being a contemporary question, I think this is something we’ve wrestled with for centuries. How do we reconcile this idea that God is a God of love with the fact that our world is violent and that people suffer terribly?” Rev. Barlow said.
The Rev. Brian Evans, pastor of First English Evangelical Lutheran Church on Grant Street, Downtown, teaches seventh- and eighth-graders. He said he often hears similar questions about the “nature of God — Is this a God of love or a God of violence?”
For Rev. Evans, the story ultimately exemplifies God taking away our sins, and our violence, and taking it upon himself. But, that concept is difficult for children and adults alike, he said.
“The story of Christ’s sacrifice is a violent one and previously, in prior years, we had not been so exposed to real violence,” Rev. Evans said. “I think if anything it may resonate more, like with violence, why does God take away our sins in such a violent way and then we look to the violence and say ‘well this is why.’ It’s because we are so inherently violent as humanity.”
In the United States, the violent crime rate spiked in the 1990s and has continued to fall since, according to a 2017 Pew Research Center analysis. The same report found that American public perception of crime rates does not often align with the data, meaning people often believe crime has increased even if it has not.
In the City of Pittsburgh, there were about 1,500 violent crimes reported in 2018, a decrease from the 2,000 reported in 2016, according to data from city government.
In his congregation, the Rev. Evans has noticed kids and parents are “more conscious” of violence and death, particularly in the case of school shootings, but said it is important to keep things in context.
“Remember, it’s always been a very violent world,” he said. “In a way this is nothing new except the instruments of killing are much more effective today,’’
Television programs, video games and even news programs offer a “superficial distance” for children that religious stories usually do not, said the Rev. Natalie Hall, canon for evangelism and faith formation at the Episcopal Diocese Church of Pittsburgh. Because of that, the story of Jesus brings up questions of fairness, and those questions cannot be answered in just one conversation, she said.
“I don’t think about having the talk, whether the talk is anything from positive life choices to where do babies come from to why we don’t use four-letter words. Those conversations are better served not as a single talk but as a series of conversations that you turn to again and again,” she said.
“So with my own children and the kids in my congregation, I won’t have a single talk about the violence inherent in the story, a single talk about this is the big stuff for Jesus. What I’ll do is consistently turn to different parts of the story that matter to me and have brief moments of reflection.
“Give us time to reflect on how it is to help our friends, how it is to help people who are suffering, talk about how to look for hope even when things look hopeless.”
Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt @post-gazette.com or 412-263-1565.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.