Detroit police Chief James Craig on Friday disputed Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner’s account of her arrest early Wednesday morning at a Detroit hotel.
Chief Craig said in a press conference that body camera footage of the event shows officers behaved appropriately and used “tremendous restraint” during the encounter with Ms. Wagner and her husband, Khari Mosley, around 12:17 a.m. at the Westin Book Cadillac Detroit hotel.
Police are seeking to file assault and battery charges against Ms. Wagner in connection to the incident; the Wayne County Prosecutor’s office is reviewing the case to determine how to proceed.
Ms. Wagner’s attorney claimed Thursday that police unnecessarily threw Ms. Wagner, 41, to the ground, and said she was a victim in the incident. Chief Craig said the officer responded physically only after Ms. Wagner blocked an elevator and “put her hand on him.”
“She was taken to the ground,” he said, “but there was a reason for that.”
The incident began after Ms. Wagner and her husband returned to the hotel after attending a symphony concert in Detroit. Ms. Wagner went to bed, her attorney said, and Mr. Mosley left the room. He ended up in the hotel bar, Chief Craig said.
Read More
Police officers were called to the hotel for a report of a “disorderly person, someone under the influence of alcohol, creating a disturbance,” the chief said. He said Mr. Mosley had fallen asleep at some point and was also banging on a door. He was not sure if that was the front door of the hotel or another door.
Mr. Mosley had forgotten the key card for his room. The hotel’s front desk staff would not issue him a new card because his name was not on the reservation and did not match his wife’s last name, the chief said. That matched the account of Ms. Wagner’s attorney, Heather Heidelbaugh.
When officers arrived, Mr. Mosley put his hands in the air, Chief Craig said.
“He had his hands in the air saying, ‘Hands up, don’t shoot;’ he referenced his education in comparison to the security guards’ at the hotel,” Chief Craig said. “He used some profanity towards the officers.”
The chief said he reviewed officers’ body-worn cameras and could see that Mr. Mosley had “some level of intoxication.”
Chief Craig said the officers escorted Mr. Mosley to his and Ms. Wagner’s hotel room and arrived to find the door ajar.
“The officers were concerned there was something wrong in the room he was supposed to be in,” Chief Craig said, and so continued to investigate. He said they made contact with Ms. Wagner, who he said also appeared to have “some level of intoxication.” He said the body-worn camera shows Ms. Wagner several times “placing her hands on the officers, not in a very aggressive way but she was at least pushing and touching six or seven times.”
Ms. Wagner told the officers it was OK for Mr. Mosley to be in the room, he said.
“The officers didn’t know if there was some sort of physical encounter between her and the gentleman,” Chief Craig said, adding there was no evidence of that. “They were trying to make a determination as to the circumstances. They took their time and were methodical.”
Ms. Wagner was not arrested at that point, he said. The officers then left, he said, but were forced to return after hotel security heard banging noises in the hotel room.
“The hotel made a decision based on some loud banging that he could not stay at the hotel,” Chief Craig said. “The officers returned and respectfully said, ‘We’re going to have to escort your husband out.'”
At that point, officers handcuffed Mr. Mosley out of concern for their safety, he said.
“He was still quite agitated,” the chief said.
The group moved into the hotel hallway, at which point Chief Craig said Ms. Wagner, who told officers she was recording the encounter, blocked a hotel elevator door and refused to move.
Chelsa Wagner's altercation with Detroit police
She then “put her hand” on the officer, who “took her to the ground,” Chief Craig said.
“You can hear in the video, ‘Be careful,'” he said. “It almost seemed as if [the officer] was trying to break her fall.”
Ms. Wagner’s attorney said Thursday that Ms. Wagner did not block the door to the elevator, and said Ms. Wagner never moved aggressively toward the officer. She said the officer reached into the elevator, pulled Ms. Wagner out and threw her to the ground.
Ms. Wagner was then handcuffed and arrested.
Although Chief Craig previously said he was considering releasing the officers’ body-worn camera footage, he said Friday he would not do that yet, citing the potential criminal case against Ms. Wagner.
The chief noted that Ms. Wagner towards the end of the encounter told officers she was the “highest-ranking political official in the county where she serves.” He said it did not seem like she said that in order to try to get out of trouble.
The county's highest-ranking official is Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald.
Police have requested that Ms. Wagner be charged with assault and battery, and are continuing the investigation, the chief said.
“We feel that the officers’ actions were appropriate, they were measured and they treated both with professionalism,” Chief Craig said.
A decision was not expected to be made Friday on criminal charges, assistant prosecutor Maria Miller said. She confirmed the office has received a warrant request from Detroit police.
“No further information will be released until a charging decision is made,” Ms. Miller said in a statement Friday.
Ms. Heidelbaugh wrote late Friday that she listened to the chief's press conference, and added that she has "no formal information to review from the authorities in Detroit, as no charges have been filed." She also noted that contrary to the chief's earlier statements to Detroit media, he now "admits that 'she was taken to the ground.'"
She added that the controller "looks forward to addressing the facts in full" but did not say when.
The attorney said that Ms. Wagner spent the morning seeing a doctor and was spending the afternoon with her sons.
Ms. Wagner declined to comment Friday. Mr. Mosley, 42, pleaded guilty to driving under the influence in 2011, and was sentenced to four 4 days in jail.
Brad Korinski, chief legal counsel for the controller’s office, said that Ms. Wagner was not at work Friday.
"I think she's doing as well as anyone thrown into a detention center without having shoes," Mr. Korinski said. "She has been dealing with physical pain from what happened, and emotional pain too.”
Mr. Korinski added that the controller’s office is not involved in the investigation into the altercation.
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter. Lacretia Wimbley contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.