Two Franciscan priests who failed to protect children from a serial sexual predator in the Johnstown area and elsewhere have been convicted, sentenced to probation and fined after agreeing not to challenge a criminal prosecution, Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro announced Friday.

The Revs. Robert D’Aversa, 70, and Anthony Criscitelli, 63,  were both supervisors of the late Brother Stephen Baker, who committed suicide in 2013 amid public accusations that he molested scores of teens at Bishop McCort Catholic High School in Johnstown and in other settings.

They each entered no-contest pleas Friday in the Blair County Court House to endangering the welfare of children, a first-degree misdemeanor. Under the plea, they did not admit guilt but accepted the sentence based on the evidence prosecutors planned to present, said Robert Ridge, attorney for Father D’Aversa. He said the reduced charge involved failure to notify Baker’s supervisors at Bishop McCort of a 20-year-old allegation from Minnesota.

The priests originally faced felony charges of endangering the welfare of children and conspiracy.

Advertise with us

Each was sentenced by Blair County Judge Jolene G. Kopriva to five years probation, the maximum possible, and fined $1,000 and costs of prosecution.

The two were at different times supervisors of their Roman Catholic religious order, the Province of the Immaculate Conception, based in Hollidaysburg.

The unexpected pleas came at a scheduled hearing in advance of their scheduled trial later in May.

“These defendants knew the abuser was a serious threat to children — but they allowed him to engage with children and have access to them as part of his job within their order,” Mr. Shapiro said. “They chose time and time again to prioritize their institution’s reputation over the safety of victims.”

Mr. Shapiro’s office said victims involved in the prosecution were consulted and accepted the resolution of the case with reduced charges.

Advertise with us

Mr. Shapiro said the case shows Pennsylvania law allows for the prosecution of “people in Pennsylvania, not just those who directly abuse children but those who enable it and cover it up.”

Baker abused scores of youths in a long, multi-state career that included work at Bishop McCort Catholic High School in Johnstown, where he taught religion and was a self-styled athletic trainer. Prosecutors planned to present evidence that his supervisors knew he was a risk and yet assigned him to work with children and other settings.

The emotional toll remains severe, however.

One of Baker’s victims, Corey Leech of Cambria County, testified at the Franciscans’ pretrial hearing in Hollidaysburg in 2016. He told in devastating detail how Baker molested students on the school’s athletic training table and in other settings.

Mr. Leech died at 31 a year ago Saturday, May 5, after a long battle with addiction. His family said in his obituary he wanted to spare other children the emotional torment he could not escape from.

Advertise with us

“Let us not forget it was Corey Leech who took the stand and led the charge,” said victim’s advocate Robert Hoatson. “Unfortunately, he didn’t make it, but his efforts were not in vain.”

Barbara Aponte of Poland, Ohio, said she hoped the verdict would bring some solace to the families of victims. She said her son, Luke Bradesku, who died by suicide in 2003 at age 26, had been one of numerous students molested by Baker when the friar taught high school students at John F. Kennedy Catholic School in Warren, Ohio.

“I have a tornado of emotions going on right now,” she said.

“I guess the mother in me was hoping for jail time, but really what is most important is they can’t deny any of this any more. They can’t deny they were aware of what was going on and that they worked in the interest of Brother Steve and not in the interest of our kids,” she said.

“Having to wait this long for justice, every time there is any reference back to this or any case, it’s like you’re slammed back to day one when you find out your son is gone,” she said. “Maybe the other thing this is going to do personally for the families of us victims is let us walk away from this part of the pain.”

Advertise with us

The friars were indicted following a 2016 grand jury investigation that yielded two related reports, one citing coverup of sexual abuse by priests in the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown and the other focused on the Franciscans. Charges were dropped against a third Franciscan supervisor.

A similar grand jury investigating six other dioceses, including Pittsburgh’s, completed its term in April and is expected to report soon. Mr. Shapiro declined to comment on that probe.

Father D’Aversa held the title of minister provincial from 1994 to 2002, while Father Criscitelli’s term was from 2002 to 2010.

Baker taught at Bishop McCort High School from 1992 to 2000, when Father D’Aversa removed Baker after receiving a credible allegation. While he and Father Criscitelli put some restrictions on Baker after that, prosecutors said they continued to allow Baker to work with youths in school and retreat settings.

James Kraus, attorney for Father Criscitelli, said his client became supervisor after Baker was removed from the high school and did restrict his ministry. A trial would have centered on whether those steps were adequate.

Advertise with us

He said the priests entered the pleas to bring closure. In court, "They expressed sorrow and grief for all the victims of Stephen Baker," he said.

Fathers Criscitelli and D’Aversa are believed to be the first U.S. religious-order superiors convicted not for abuse but over failures in supervision of an abuser.

A Missouri Catholic bishop was convicted of a misdemeanor in 2012 for failing to report suspected abuse by a priest, while a Philadelphia priest had his 2012 conviction overturned after serving part of a prison sentence.

Boston lawyer Mitchell Garabedian, who represented 86 of Baker’s victims in settlements with the church, said while the lack of prison time is disappointing, “at least in this instance, the law recognized these two Franciscan friars are criminals and should be regarded as such.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.