A state Superior Court panel ruled Thursday that a Cambria County man's constitutional rights were violated when a lower court sentenced him to two weeks of incarceration because he was late making payments to the court.
In 2016, Gregory Mauk fell behind on an order to pay restitution, court costs and fines he owed after pleading guilty in a 2010 theft case. He was given two payment deadlines over two months, but in that time he went to the hospital with pancreatitis and missed one of the deadlines. By his next time before the judge, he was caught up.
But in February 2017, he was jailed anyway by Cambria County Common Pleas Judge Tamara Bernstein — along with 53 other people with outstanding fines.
“[T]he procedural shortcuts for costs-and-fines hearings that occurred in the court of common pleas were constitutionally ‘disastrous,’ ” wrote Superior Court Judge Deborah Kunselman in an opinion released Thursday.
Mr. Mauk's case was highlighted in a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette story in February that examined cases in Pennsylvania in which low-income individuals were jailed for failure to make court payments.
He spent 11 days in jail and was released following the intervention of the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania.
Judge Kunselman, along with fellow Superior Court Judges Mary Jane Bowes and Judith Olson, heard the case in January in Pittsburgh.
Attorneys from the ACLU argued that the trial court violated Mr. Mauk's constitutional rights because he and the other defendants were denied the opportunity for a hearing, an attorney or bail.
“This high-speed sentencing violates the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment,” Judge Kunselman wrote.
“Moreover,” the panel wrote, “we note that the proceedings in the trial court disregarded the Pennsylvania Rules of Criminal Procedure, which provide that ‘[a] court shall not commit the defendant to prison for failure to pay a fine or costs unless it appears after hearing that the defendant is financially able to pay the fine or costs.’ ”
Cambria County’s president judge, Norman A. Krumenacker III, could not be reached Thursday for comment.
Mr. Mauk, 50, a painter, still owes roughly $4,000 and makes monthly $150 payments, he said.
“For a judge to just be able to throw you in jail and mess with your livelihood is crazy to me, and any of those people have absolutely no recourse. You can't sue a judge. Who is there to sue?”
Additionally, a bill introduced in the state Senate in response to the Post-Gazette’s reporting on the issue of jailing people too poor to pay court fines and costs passed the state Senate judiciary committee this week.
Senate Bill 1126, introduced by state Sen. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Jefferson Hills, would mandate that existing training for magisterial district judges include “instruction on options available to indigent defendants for failure to pay court costs, fines, restitution or fees in summary cases.”
A companion bill, Senate Bill 1036, introduced by state Sen. Stewart J. Greenleaf, R-Montgomery, requires new payment determination hearings when defendants go into default and provides the option of community service as an alternative sentence for traffic offenses.
In the Post-Gazette's prior reporting, magisterial district judges said they jail people for being too poor to pay court costs and fines due to the lack of other sentencing options.
In February, District Judge Richard King, president of the Allegheny County Special Courts Association, said, “One of the biggest problems is that we can't give community service for traffic violations.”
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise. Christopher Huffaker: chuffaker@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1724, or on Twitter @huffakingit.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.