A New Jersey optometrist who ran 11 area Pearle Vision centers and ripped off insurance with bogus claims — and kept doing it even after he was indicted — will spend 33 months behind bars.

U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon imposed that term Monday on Vincent Gamuzza, 31, who lives in Hazlet, N.J., and had franchise agreements with Pearle Vision through his company, Gamuzza Inc.

Gamuzza pleaded guilty in September to health care fraud.

In court Monday, he and his lawyer said he should never have bought the Pearle Vision stores. He owned an eye clinic in New Jersey and then expanded into Pennsylvania but over-extended himself.

Advertise with us

In asking for probation, he said he had lost two doctors at the centers, so was working all the time and had little office help to prepare bills and do clerical work. As a result, he said, he wasn't in his "right mind" and was under stress that aggravated his long-standing psychiatric problems. He said he became a doctor to treat patients and didn't pay as much attention to billing as he should have.

"I just wanted to help people," he said.

His lawyer, Robert Ridge, said Gamuzza had as much business running the vision centers "as I do doing brain surgery" and got in over his head.

"This is a guy who was broke," he said.

The U.S. attorney's office said Gamuzza carried out a calculated scheme to bill Highmark for medical services he never provided from December 2015 through July of that year. He also billed Davis Vision, Highmark's subsidiary, for eye exams he never performed. The government calculated the total loss, which helps determine a sentencing guideline, at more than $250,000.

Advertise with us

Assistant U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan argued for prison, saying crimes like Gamuzza's only aggravate problems within the health care insurance industry, such as rising premiums.

He also said ordinary patients were affected as well in that they received bills in the mail for services they knew Gamuzza didn't perform. One victim never even met the doctor.

Mr. Olshan said Gamuzza should also be punished for not showing respect for the law. Months after his October 2016 indictment for false billings, he submitted more false bills.

Both sides agreed that Gamuzza has had mental health issues. After his indictment, he indicated to his office staff that he might kill himself.

When he learned that, Assistant U.S. Attorney Robert Cessar had federal agents take him into custody the day after the charges were filed to keep him from harming himself.

Advertise with us

But Judge Bissoon said Gamuzza's psychiatric condition was no excuse for his crimes and said probation would be "most inappropriate."

In addition to the prison time, she ordered him to pay $99,000 in restitution. She said she will recommend that he be allowed to serve his term at Ft. Dix in New Jersey.