United Lutheran Seminary’s board has fired its first president, and several trustees have resigned, amid controversy over revelations that the long-time advocate for gays and others in ministry had years ago worked for an organization opposed to homosexuality years ago before renouncing those view.

Trustees at the seminary, which has campuses in Gettysburg and Philadelphia, made the decision on Wednesday to fire the Rev. Theresa Latini, who took the reins last year when the school was formed by the merger of historic Lutheran seminaries in the two cities.

Rev. Latini had, beginning in 1996, worked for about five years with a Presbyterian-affiliated group called OnebyOne, which supported that denomination’s former ban on non-celibate gay clergy and whose programs asserted that at least some gay people could and should change their orientation to heterosexual.

She eventually quit, calling those views hurtful, and became a forceful advocate for people’s rights to ordination and marriage regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity. The seminaries are affiliated with the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, which in recent years has begun ordaining gay clergy and allowed same-sex marriage rites in local congregations.

Advertise with us

While she never denied that part of her work history, she didn’t provide that information to the search committee that interviewed her. Before she was hired, she did tell the chairperson of the seminary trustees, who investigated and received positive recommendations from those she had worked with on such issues.

When the news did spread among the seminaries, many said they should have been told this up front. Several board members resigned in the days before Wednesday’s meeting, and more did so afterward.

“We recognize that this decision will not satisfy many of our constituencies, but our responsibility as a Board is to make decisions that we believe will best strengthen and sustain” the seminary, the board said in a statement. “...We have reached the conclusion that ending our relationship with Dr. Latini will be the most positive approach to our process of healing and to the health and well-being of ULS.”

But Rev. Latini said she was disappointed with the news and said the decision reflects the “long-standing, historic divisions” between the two often-rival seminaries.

“I had been eager to help this newly-combined organization to flourish,” she said. She said that due to “a politically-based whisper campaign against me and other members of the Board, it became clear that certain parts of the organization were not going to stand behind me and that I could not be effective as president. I have been scapegoated by an historically divided institution resistant to unification, and have been given little chance to respond to the accusations against me."

Advertise with us

The issue resonates in Western Pennsylvania, as many Evangelical Lutheran Church in America pastors are alums of the seminaries in Gettysburg and Philadelphia.

Local Bishop Jim Dunlop of the Lower Susquehanna Synod was acting president of the seminary and pledged to “listen with an open mind and heart to the stories and perspectives of all the seminary stakeholders, including LGBTQIA+ members, our African American members and any others who feel as if their voices are not heard.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.