A couple of years down the road, the 180-mile drive along Pennsylvania’s stretch of Interstate 79, north to south, could be a dream for slots lovers or blackjack players.
With three existing casinos and two proposed mini-casinos all potentially just a brief sidetrip from an I-79 exit, anyone thirsting for an occasional taste of gambling could get it almost as conveniently as a cup of coffee or burger — about every 30 to 60 minutes.
Put this new Western Pennsylvania Casino Corridor together with another mini-casino planned farther east in Westmoreland County and the existing little resort casino in Fayette County, and it will be hard for anyone in the region to complain about driving time to a gambling hall.
Whether that’s a good thing or bad thing depends on one’s point of view, but it’s becoming the norm across the country, with Pennsylvania — in its desperation to solve a budget crunch — helping lead the way. Four mini-casinos auctioned by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board have already brought $120 million to the state, and a potential six more could be added at a minimum bid of $7.5 million each, to join 12 existing casinos and one under development in Philadelphia.
“Western Pennsylvania’s becoming more populated with casinos than most markets, but it’s just a sign of the times,” said Joe Weinert, a casino industry analyst for Spectrum Gaming Group in New Jersey. “In a relatively short timeline, we’ve become the United States of Casinos, with more than 1,000 in 42 states.”
The first casino on this side of the state, Presque Isle Downs & Casino in Erie County, opened almost exactly 11 years ago. It was followed within months by the Meadows Racetrack & Casino in Washington County; two years later by the Rivers Casino on Pittsburgh’s North Shore; and in 2013 by the Lady Luck Casino at Nemacolin Woodlands in Fayette County.
Read More

Those four existing operations collectively contain more than 7,800 slot machines and 260 table games such as blackjack, roulette and craps. Their gross annual gambling revenue (the more positive way of describing what are in fact the losses left behind by patrons)? About $742 million.
Now three anticipated mini-casinos loom as regional competition, with up to 750 slot machines and 30 to 40 table games each:
• One that Stadium Casino LLC, also developer of the major casino being built in Philadephia, placed a winning $40.1 million bid to place east of Greensburg, at a site still to be determined. (The casino operators are allowed six months to submit plans for a specific location that must be within 15 miles of whatever geographic point they initially identify.)
• One that the operator of the Mount Airy Casino Resort in the Poconos bid $21.2 million to place most likely in Lawrence County, within 15 miles of a centerpoint east of New Castle.
• A mini-casino proposed in Mercer County by Sands Bethworks Gaming, owner of the existing casino in Bethlehem and part of the Las Vegas Sands Corp. gambling giant. Its $9.9 million bid was initially accepted by the gaming board on Feb. 21, then rejected because the geographic zone it identified for the development encroached upon Mount Airy’s own protected territory.
The gaming board holds another mini-casino auction Wednesday, and it seems likely that Las Vegas Sands will put in another Mercer County bid, slightly altering its potential development area. That’s what officials of the gaming company told Randy Seitz, president of the Penn-Northwest Development Corp., a leader among among a group of Mercer County officials who have been lobbying for a mini-casino and received a visit from Sands officials in January.
“They shared with us they had been studying Mercer County and the nearby Ohio market [containing potential gamblers who might cross the state border] for months,” said Mr. Seitz, who confirmed in a phone call with Sands officials after the Feb. 21 bidding snafu that it had not dimmed their interest. While other casino operators potentially could outbid Sands Wednesday for a location around Mercer or anywhere else in the state, Mr. Seitz has heard of no others with local interest.
If three mini-casinos to be developed over the next year or two do add another 2,000-plus slot machines and 100 or so table games to Western Pennsylvania, the question arises of whether a region with stagnant population and relative lack of economic vibrancy can support them.
“The pie is only so big,” observed Denis Rudd, a Robert Morris University professor of hospitality and tourism management, raising concerns about how much disposable income people have, how many are interested in using it for gambling and whether they might do so to the harm of the rest of the local economy.
Mr. Weinert and other gaming industry analysts have suggested that despite its four existing casinos, Western Pennsylvania is much less saturated with them than the eastern side of the state, making the west a better target for mini-casinos. And local officials, with an eye on potential economic development and tax revenue tied to gambling rather than worries about cannibalization of other businesses, have been nothing but supportive.
“I’m assuming both companies [eyeing the Mercer-Lawrence area] have done a sufficient amount of studying to determine that it was in their best interests to make the bids they have made,” said Lawrence County Commissioner Dan Vogler, who points to restaurant-hotel development around the Meadows as an example of what a casino can bring.
The smaller size and, likely, fewer amenities of mini-casinos could diminish their ability to have broad economic impact. The biggest difference they could make is by attracting nearby residents who are accustomed to only occasional trips to the Rivers or Meadows due to the length of the drive, said Sarah Tanford, an associate professor of hospitality management at the University of Nevada Las Vegas International Gaming Institute.
“If there’s more supply, it’s going to generate more demand, and the other thing you will increase is frequency,” said Ms. Tanford, who formerly worked in such market forecasting for Harrah’s Entertainment. “Having something closer to people in their locales will increase their propensity to gamble.”
That is certainly what companies like Sands, Mount Airy and Stadium Casino are counting on, although neither they nor the existing local casinos are inclined to discuss the topic during this highly competitive, confidential period of mini-auction bidding.
“We’re going to wait for the dust to settle before we weigh in on what impact these [mini-casinos] might have. ... We need to first find out the exact locations and size and scope of these proposed facilities,” said Eric Schippers, spokesman for Penn National Gaming, which has an agreement to purchase the Meadows from its current owner, in addition to operating a slots-only racetrack casino in the Youngstown, Ohio area. The latter could be affected by competition from either a Lawrence or Mercer county mini-casino.
Representatives of the Rivers have repeatedly declined requests to discuss the potential new competition. Meanwhile, there has been no indication that the Pittsburgh casino has been interested in bidding for a satellite casino itself, including as a defensive tactic to thwart the operators from across the state wanting to encroach upon its market.
“Probably the fear is they’d be cannibalizing their own business” if the Rivers operated its own Western Pennsylvania mini-casino, Ms. Tanford speculated. “In a regional market, people want to get a foothold, and once they’ve gotten it they don’t necessarily want to put up another casino that could dilute their existing business.”
That’s not to say the Rivers, Meadows or another operator among existing casinos still without a winning mini-casino bid — if you already have one, you can’t bid for another yet — couldn’t still bid for another location on this side of the state, such as Johnstown, Altoona, State College or Somerset. That will only be determined by the six additional silent auctions over the next three months.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.