Members of the Mennonite Church USA had sought for years to resolve disagreements about the role of LGBT people.

Or at least, they searched for a way to agree to disagree.

They couldn’t find it, and the nation’s largest Mennonite body began 2018 as the latest Protestant denomination to lose a significant share of conservative churches.

The Lancaster Mennonite Conference — the largest regional group in the Mennonite Church USA and based in the historic Mennonite territory in Eastern Pennsylvania — officially broke with the national denomination as of Jan. 1.

Advertise with us

And in Western Pennsylvania and around the country, some individual congregations are also leaving the denomination — some affiliating with the Lancaster conference, others with different Mennonite groups.

The denomination has lost about a quarter of its churches and members since 2015 with the departure of Lancaster, a couple of smaller conferences and individual congregations. It now has reports having 625 congregations and 69,223 members.

The Lancaster conference began the separation process in 2015, when the denomination’s national convention passed a resolution calling for “grace, love and forbearance” toward those with different views on sexuality. Many of those departing the denomination felt it should have opposed same-sex unions rather than remain neutral.

Ervin Stutzman, executive director of Mennonite Church USA, said in a statement Friday that while the split was expected, it remains painful.

“The official separation does not mean that all of our relationships with Lancaster conference will end,” he added, with Mennonites continuing to cooperate in such areas as disaster relief and other humanitarian work.

Advertise with us

“Although we are now separate structural bodies, we all remain part of the body of Christ,” he said. “Thus, we pray for Lancaster conference in carrying out the ministry to which they feel called by God.”

A half-dozen congregations recently withdrew from the Allegheny Mennonite Conference, most of them joining the Lancaster group. They comprised about one-third of the congregations in the conference, which includes parts of Western Pennsylvania, Maryland and West Virginia.

The Allegheny conference long has had controversy over an LGBT-affirming congregation in Maryland. In recent years, it has sought to live with differences.

“We’re calling it place-based ministry,” said conference minister David Mishler. Congregations can decide “how to deal with this or any other issue in their neighborhood.”

He added: “There’s lots of sadness about the division. Mennonites are notorious for parting ways when they can’t figure out how to move forward.”

Advertise with us

Blough Mennonite Church, a 2-century-old congregation in Hollsopple, Somerset County, with about 50 in regular attendance, was among those leaving the Allegheny for the Lancaster conference.

“It was a long process,” Pastor Eric Lasure said. “It was one we didn’t take lightly because we are one of the oldest congregations in the Allegheny conference. We have relatives that are still in the Allegheny conference, so it was difficult. However, they had made some decisions in the conference that we didn’t feel were biblically correct.”

Pittsburgh Mennonite Church in Swissvale has an “open-and-affirming” approach to LGBT people at all levels of church leadership, Pastor Dave Swanson said. The church, with about 150 regular participants, is one of two conference churches in Allegheny County, along with a small immigrant fellowship.

Pastor Swanson said the congregation draws inspiration from the biblical book of Acts, in which the church embraced people of different ethnic and other groups that previously had been excluded.

“You have all these theologically despised people who are brought into the story,” he said.

Advertise with us

Like others on all sides, he laments “that the way we’ve been church hasn’t been enough to keep us together. It’s cause for a lot of questions of how and to what degree do we belong to one another as people of faith, as Christians, as Anabaptists, as Mennonites.”

Other Protestants have asked the same questions.

In recent years, after the nation’s largest Presbyterian, Lutheran and Episcopal denominations endorsed the ordination of openly gay and lesbian clergy, some conservatives left for new or existing denominations.

And tensions over sexuality are also affecting the Mennonites’ cousins in the “peace church” tradition, such as Quaker and Brethren groups, said Scott Holland, a professor of theology and culture at Bethany Theological Seminary in Richmond, Ind., which is affiliated with the Church of the Brethren and is in partnership with the Quaker-affiliated Earlham School of Religion.

“Some have made clean breaks. Others are in processes of discernment, dialogue, debate,” said Mr. Holland, a member of Pittsburgh Mennonite Church.

Advertise with us

Mennonites are spiritual descendants of the 16th-century European Protestant reformer Menno Simons.

Like other “Anabaptists,” a name derived from their opposition to infant baptism, they rejected military service and a state church, and they continue to practice nonviolent peacemaking as a core value.

Also, like fellow Anabaptists such as the Amish, many Mennonites migrated to the United States and are significantly concentrated in Eastern Pennsylvania and parts of Ohio and Indiana.

Mennonite groups range from highly separatist — marked by conservative clothing and limited use of technology — to more assimilated into modern society, including those in the Mennonite Church USA. Scholars estimate there are nearly 300,000 U.S. Mennonites of all stripes.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.