A Pennsylvania State Police trooper acting within the scope of his employment is immune from suit under the doctrine of sovereign immunity, even if his actions cause intentional harm, the state’s Commonwealth Court has ruled.

A unanimous three-judge panel found Tuesday that the doctrine made irrelevant the details of an incident in which Shiretta Justice was allegedly injured by Trooper Joseph Lombardo during an altercation following a traffic stop.

Because Trooper Lombardo was acting within the scope of his employment and authorized in his behavior, he was protected by sovereign immunity, the court found. As well, the trial court erred in denying the trooper’s motion for judgment despite the verdict in Ms. Justice’s lawsuit against him, the court said in a published opinion.

“Whether his conduct was reasonable or not, intentional or not, tortious or not, carried out for an improper motive or not, are all irrelevant because Trooper Lombardo’s use of force in placing Ms. Justice’s hands behind her back and ‘wrestling’ with her to apply handcuffs was of the same general nature as that authorized or incidental to the conduct authorized, and use of force, in general, by state troopers is not unexpected,” Senior Judge Dan Pellegrini wrote for the court.

Advertise with us

Ms. Justice and Trooper Lombardo provided different accounts of a Nov. 27, 2013, traffic stop on Interstate 76 in Philadelphia, in which he pulled her over and issued her tickets for driving with a suspended license and failing to use a turn signal, Judge Pellegrini said.

The dispute arose as Ms. Justice waited for a friend to give her a ride home from where her vehicle was parked alongside the highway barrier, as Trooper Lombardo requested.

Ms. Justice claimed that the trooper “had a nasty demeanor, jumped on her, twisted her arm behind her back and tried to push her to the ground,” Judge Pellegrini said. She claimed that she suffered a sprained arm, wrist and back due to the allegedly excessive use of force.

Trooper Lombardo, meanwhile, claimed that Ms. Justice was uncooperative and resistant, cursing at him throughout the nearly hour-long incident. He testified that he grabbed her arm only to bring her back to his patrol car and handcuffed her only after she began to resist him, Judge Pellegrini said.

A jury returned a $160,000 verdict in Ms. Justice’s favor on her claims of assault and battery, invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of emotional distress, false arrest, false imprisonment and abuse of process. The Philadelphia County Common Pleas Court denied the trooper’s motion asking that the judge set aside the jury’s verdict and decide in his favor.

Advertise with us

Commonwealth Court reversed the trial court’s decision to deny the trooper’s motion and remanded the case with instructions to enter judgment in favor of Trooper Lombardo.

On appeal, Trooper Lombardo argued that he acted within the scope of his employment and is therefore entitled to sovereign immunity, and Judge Pellegrini agreed.

Trooper Lombardo argued that he was doing exactly what he was employed to do and took action to enforce the state’s Vehicle Code and ensure public safety, while Ms. Justice asserted that his use of force was “completely unacceptable and completely gratuitous, excessive or unreasonably motivated by his personal anger,” Judge Pellegrini said.

But the only question at issue was whether the conduct was authorized by the employer, according to the judge, and the conduct Ms. Justice complained of was of the same general nature as Trooper Lombardo’s authorized conduct.

Trooper Lombardo is directed by the state police to enforce all the laws of the state, to make warrantless arrests, and to use force where necessary to carry out those purposes, “so the use of force by a police officer in carrying out his duties is not unexpected,” Judge Pellegrini said.

Advertise with us

Given the nature of his job, Trooper Lombardo was acting within the scope of his employment and is protected by sovereign immunity, the court found.

Zack Needles: zneedles@alm.com or 215-557-2373. To read more articles like this, visit thelegalintelligencer.com.