Inadequate record keeping by Allegheny County Police makes it difficult to gauge the department’s effectiveness, according to an audit released Thursday by county Controller Chelsa Wagner.

Auditors discovered that the department’s internal record keeping was inconsistent and incomplete — and that records had been kept on paper until 2016, when the department finally switched to an electronic system.

That switch should help to standardize the police department’s record keeping in the future, according the the audit, which suggested the department should work to more quickly adopt new technology going forward.

The audit noted that the department does not track how often it assists other local agencies with cases, making it impossible to determine whether some municipalities are using more than their fair share of county resources. The audit looked at the department’s operations between 2013 and 2016.

Advertise with us

“County taxpayers are paying almost $30 million annually for a police force that is trained, equipped and prepared to improve the safety of all of our communities, but that doesn’t have a clearly defined role in a fragmented, multi-layered system of law enforcement,” Ms. Wagner said in a statement Thursday.

The audit also criticized the county police department’s lack of racial and gender diversity. Of the department’s 212 officers, seven are African-American and 14 are women, police Superintendent Coleman McDonough said Thursday. Census data from 2015 shows that nearly 52 percent of Allegheny County is female and 14.5 percent is black.

He responded to the audit in a two-page letter, which said the department is well on its way to fixing the record-keeping problem through the electronic system and the recent hire of two data analysts. The department will also begin issuing public annual reports, Superintendent McDonough said, another issue raised in the audit.

He added that the department has adjusted its promotional hiring material and testing procedures to try to attract more minority applicants, taking steps such as waiving the application fee and offering test-preparation courses.

“One of the things we have to remember is that this report was compiled over more than a year, and in that time frame we have taken quite a number of steps to start moving forward,” he said.

Advertise with us

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow on Twitter @ShellyBradbury.

Here’s the complete audit report:

8cba868a633e1ba88cec9081468ab9cc2017JunThu15130414969347841f0e3dad99908345f7439f8ffabdffc483cdc79793b90d9619bd7b00565b25e6PolicePerformanceAuditReport (PDF)

8cba868a633e1ba88cec9081468ab9cc2017JunThu15130414969347841f0e3dad99908345f7439f8ffabdffc483cdc79793b90d9619bd7b00565b25e6PolicePerformanceAuditReport (Text)