Homeownership rates are on the rise for people of all races and income levels throughout Allegheny County, according to an annual mortgage lending study by the Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group.

Yet the latest PCRG study suggests the odds of a black working-class person getting rejected for a mortgage loan are two times greater than a white working-class person.

Forty-six percent of mortgage loan applications submitted by African-Americans were denied, according to publicly available data from 2015, the year in which the most recent study was based.

“We are looking at what are the reasons for denial. For the most part, it’s a shortage of cash to close and it has to do with credit,” said Ernie Hogan, executive director of the nonprofit advocacy group based in the Hill District. “We believe part of it is that African-American unemployment rates in the city are still higher than whites, and the income disparity for women and African-Americans to white men are still pretty significant in this city.”

Advertise with us

Home purchase loans in the county were up 24 percent in 2015 compared with a 14 percent increase in 2014. While the number of mortgage loans have gone up across the board, the increase has been primarily in the middle market.

“We are seeing that there is a rise in more low-income people buying homes and they are buying them in middle-income communities,” Mr. Hogan said. “They are not buying them in Homewood. They are buying in neighborhoods like Greenfield or Morningside, East Allegheny and Manchester.

“They are buying in more up-and-coming neighborhoods that are transitional and have a higher middle population,” he said. “We are seeing a real paradigm shift where minorities and low-income people are taking their money and investing in quality of life neighborhoods. They are not investing in neighborhoods where they may have previously grown up or rented.”

The purpose of the Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group report is to monitor the performance of financial institutions seeking to meet their community investments under the Community Reinvestment Act. The federal act encourages banks to make mortgage loans in low- and moderate-income communities where the institutions accept deposits.

In 2015, 488 institutions reported receiving 42,283 residential mortgage applications in Allegheny County — including 5,584 withdrawn by the applicant or closed for incompleteness — resulting in 27,529 approved mortgage loans totaling $4.64 billion in originated loans.

Advertise with us

Dollar Bank emerged in 2015 as the top mortgage lender in Allegheny County with 3,311 loans that year, which added up to $561 million. PNC Financial Services Group originated the second-highest mortgages in the county — 2,966 loans worth $510 million. Howard Hanna Mortgages Services came in at No. 3 with 1,501 loans totaling $298 million.

Wells Fargo Bank, which has no local branches, as well as mortgage companies — which are technically not banks — made the list of top lenders in Allegheny County.

Quicken Loans, an independent online mortgage lender based in Detroit, has no Pittsburgh branch offices yet has captured 4 percent of Allegheny County’s mortgage market. Wells Fargo Bank, which also has no Pittsburgh presence, won 5 percent of Allegheny County’s mortgage market.

These lenders are apparently drawn to the market due to its stable housing environment, Mr. Hogan said, pointing out that this region does not have high escalating real estate markets, but it does have a reputation for steady continuous growth in values.

“It doesn’t surprise us that Dollar Bank has moved to be the No. 1 mortgage lender in Allegheny County,” Mr. Hogan said. “They have a real philosophy and the bank has committed tremendous resources to creating new mortgage products like Mortgages for Mothers and Mortgages for Men.

Advertise with us

“And internally, they are the only bank that I know of that has in-house credit counseling services. They work with individuals who come in the door and are not ready to help them get ready to become homeowners.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.