The text arrived soon after the election results were called. “Dad, I’m terrified.”
The Rev. Douglas Patterson said his daughter, who had recently given birth, was afraid for her child’s future in an America that had elected Republican Donald Trump as its new president.
At a regular noontime service on Wednesday at Smithfield United Church of Christ in Downtown, which has long promoted acceptance for people of diverse races and sexual orientations, Rev. Patterson struggled even to find the words to articulate such fears, alluding to Mr. Trump’s various comments about deportations of immigrants without legal status and blocking Muslims from entering the United States and the Republican platform’s denunciation of same-sex marriage.
“In these deeply divided times, healing has to be done,” he said. “We’re so deeply divided, the division is hard to grasp.”
That’s one thing leaders in various religious communities are voicing, and that clergy are voicing in sermons this weekend.
As starkly as ever, Americans are divided politically by racial and religious identity. This presidential vote underscored, with only minor shifts, the trend in which majorities of white, self-identified Christians coalesce around Republican candidates and the bulk of racial, ethnic, religious and non-religious minorities back the Democrats.
White evangelical Christians showed their legendary Republican loyalty more than ever. They represented more than a quarter of all voters, and 81 percent sided with Mr. Trump, according to exit polls. (Unlike faulty pre-election surveys, exit polls count actual voters.)
Evangelical support came despite issues that divided their leaders, such as Mr. Trump’s multiple marriages, casino profits and the multiple accusations of sexual misconduct against him.
Mr. Trump didn’t say much on the campaign trail about issues such as abortion, gay marriage and religious liberty, which have galvanized evangelicals, conservative Catholics and others. He did say he’d appoint judicial conservatives.
And enough religious conservative leaders made the case for Trump on their own media networks, saying a Trump victory would lead to an anti-abortion Supreme Court and that a win for Democrat Hillary Clinton would lead to the opposite.
Scott Arvay, executive pastor of the Bible Chapel, a large congregation with four campuses ranging from the South Hills to Wilkinsburg, said he’s not surprised that this issue resonated with evangelicals. But he said they need to understand the fears of others.
With the imminent repeal of at least parts of the Affordable Care Act, some are fearing, “Am I going to lose my health insurance?” he said. Others worry, “Am I going to be discriminated against? Am I going to be deported?”
He said it’s an opportunity for Christians to “be people who are kind and good and patient and not to gloat or not to be angry” and for the church to “bring healing to a hurting country.”
Bishop David Zubik of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh said the conciliatory messages of Ms. Clinton and President Barack Obama, and Thursday’s lengthy Obama-Trump meeting at the Oval Office, gave him hope.
He expressed relief that abortion rights would not expand further as seemed likely under a Clinton administration. And Bishop Zubik, the grandson of immigrants, said he hopes that now that Trump is in power, he will have a “more compassionate approach” than what he signaled repeatedly in pre-election statements.
“Some of the things the president-elect said in the campaign were very inappropriate,” Bishop Zubik said. But now, “I have a great deal of hope we’re going to see a whole different approach to those things.”
“We’ve got to give the guy a chance,” he said.
The Rev. Glenn Grayson, pastor of Wesley Center AME Zion Church in the Middle Hill District, called Mr. Trump’s campaign remarks “alarming” and go beyond rhetoric to “who the person is.”
“I was very concerned for his stance on Muslims, on the handicapped, on African Americans, on Mexicans,” as well as Mr. Trump’s earlier false claims questioning Mr. Obama’s citizenship and his boasts of sexual entitlement as a celebrity.
People in Rev. Grayson’s congregation “are numb and in disbelief that a person of such rhetoric can now represent the country,” he said. “You have a man who was endorsed by the KKK. I find that as an African-American in the 21st century extremely scary. ... Children [of immigrants without legal status] woke up crying to the news they might lose a mother or father.”
Mr. Trump’s initial victory speech was gracious, but “I hope it’s not just rhetoric,” said Rev. Grayson. “He has to very quickly reassure Americans and America that we’ve got to come together.”
Safdar Khwaja, president of the Pittsburgh chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, also said many Muslims are nervous but are trying to be hopeful.
“Man by nature is optimistic; otherwise you wouldn’t get out of bed in the morning,” he said. “Some people are depressed. But they’re saying maybe there will be some good unintended consequences,” such as a Trump administration learning that mosques have in fact long been opposing terrorist indoctrination and cooperating with law-enforcement authorities.
Rabbi Aaron Bisno of Rodef Shalom Congregation in Oakland said that while the Jewish vote is not monolithic, most of those he has spoken with expressed “shock and disappointment and hurt with the result” and fear for its impact on various minority groups. (Nationally, the Jewish vote went to Clinton by a 3-1 margin.)
“I’m also aware that where the disabled and immigrants and minorities are readily disparaged, it’s never long before the Jews are also singled out,” he said.
Some Trump supporters, both at rallies and online, have posted virulently anti-Semitic words and images.
“I don’t believe Donald Trump is an anti-Semite,” Rabbi Bisno said, “but today if you look at where anti-Semitism is rearing its head, while it’s on the fringe left, it now attaches to the mainstream of the Republican Party and its standard bearer.”
Rev. Patterson, of Smithfield Church, said it was easy to get complacent about progress toward equality.
“We are an inclusive church, but we can't be satisfied with that. The voice of the church has to become more prophetic,” he said.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.