Five students in Drew Zoldak’s third-period forensics class last year testified Thursday that allegations by police that he called out the victim of institutional sexual assault in front of them are untrue.

After the prosecution rested its case against Mr. Zoldak — who faces a single criminal charge of witness intimidation — defense attorney Alexander Lindsay called a parade of students to the stand, who countered the young woman’s earlier testimony.

The teen, who is not being identified because she was the victim of sexual assault, testified earlier Thursday that she never revealed to any fellow students her relationship with teacher Joseph Ruggieri, who had been arrested two months earlier, but on the Monday following Mr. Zoldak’s absence from school on April 17, 2015, he indicated to the class that she was involved.

A student asked Mr. Zoldak why he had been gone the Friday before, the victim testified, and he answered, “Men in suits from the DA’s office came to my house to interview me.”

Advertise with us

When asked why, the teacher “head-motioned backward, [toward Jason Cooper’s classroom] and he pointed at me and said, ‘Because of her,’” the young woman testified.

But a number of other students in the class disagreed with how the victim described what happened.

“He didn’t really go into detail of it, just that he was talking to investigators, like all the other teachers were doing,” said Alex Pease. “It was just a simple question. Nobody thought much of it.”

Ashley Alpino, another student, gave similar testimony.

“He was asked questions by men in suits, never singled anybody out, never made a direct allegation against anyone else,” she said. “He was telling the truth.”

Advertise with us

“How do you know he was telling the truth?” asked assistant district attorney Alicia Werner.

“Because he has always told the truth before, and he was always open with his students,” Ms. Alpino answered.

As for the claim that Mr. Zoldak pointed at the victim, Mr. Pease said, “It did not happen. He never did that.”

The victim also told police that near the end of class that day, Mr. Zoldak called her to the front of the classroom and asked if she would be OK with a lesson on sexual assault the next week. She told the jury she was so uncomfortable and upset by what happened that day in class that she left school the next period and never returned — missing prom and graduation.

Mr. Pease said Mr. Zoldak never asked the victim about the sexual assault unit. Instead, he testified that all the teacher called the student up for was to give her work she would be missing the next week.

Advertise with us

Several of the students who testified on behalf of Mr. Zoldak gushed about him, characterizing him as their favorite teacher, who was caring, truthful and fair.

Nicholas Meyers, another student who graduated this year, said after the teens in Mr. Zoldak’s class learned of his arrest, they decided to speak to the school resource officer about it.

“We felt we needed to do something because what he was being accused of never happened,” Mr. Meyers said.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.