When he started out a dozen years ago as bishop of Western Pennsylvania’s United Methodists, people kept asking Thomas Bickerton what the theme of his tenure would be. He didn’t know bishops were supposed to have themes, and one day in exasperation he told someone his theme was to “lighten up and have a little fun.”

He elaborated recently: “Who in the world would ever want to associate with a group of people who never have any fun? The way of Jesus is a joy-filled and hope-filled existence. Realize the world is absolutely desperate for” such joy and hope.

As his term in Western Pennsylvania winds down, Bishop Bickerton said he has often seen area Methodists bear that witness.

“We have had a great deal of joy here,” he said. “Our people share the gospel and do it with courage and conviction.”

Advertise with us

Bishop Bickerton has been on an extended farewell tour with the impending end of his term in August. He’s delivered farewell messages this spring to gatherings of each of the 10 districts in the Western Pennsylvania Conference of the United Methodist Church, which stretches across 23 counties from Johnstown to the Ohio border.

This week, he’ll be giving his last address at the annual meeting of the conference, being held at Grove City College.

By church law, no bishop can serve more than 12 years in a conference. When leaders of the Methodists’ Northeastern Jurisdiction meet in July, they’ll elect his successor for Western Pennsylvania, and he’ll be a candidate for another conference in a Northeastern state.

Bishop Bickerton said the past dozen years have been both inspiring and trying in one of the region’s largest Protestant denominations. It had about 900 churches and 190,000 members when he started, numbers that are closer to 830 and 168,000 today, echoing similar declines among Methodists and similar Protestant groups nationwide.

Nearly 9 in 10 Methodist parishes in Western Pennsylvania draw fewer than 100 to a typical worship service, a reflection of its broad small-town footprint.

Advertise with us

“Our churches have continued to struggle,” he said. Yet they are “pockets of Western Pennsylvania where on Sunday morning and Wednesday evening the gospel is being faithfully proclaimed,” he said.

“The challenges that are unique to the small-membership church are very difficult to overcome,” he said. ”What we’ve tried to do is instill a spirit of hopefulness in folks. They are resilient.”

Some parishes have grown dramatically, not just because they’re located in growing communities but because of innovative ministries such as church plants, ethnic ministries and even a country-and-western-themed service.

Bishop Bickerton, who came here from an early career in ministry in his native West Virginia, has felt the need to challenge his flock at times.

“One of the things that will always grieve me is I wish we would have done more furthering conversation around racism and sexism,” he said.

Advertise with us

He said at times he has faced resistance from a congregation when he has assigned a woman or a person of color to be its pastor.

“Sometimes it’s subtle; sometimes it’s blatant,” he said. “We’re making inroads, but we can’t back off of it.”

He applauded the local Methodists’ eagerness to join a formal partnership with Methodists in Zimbabwe, which involves mission trips and other exchanges, and its support for a denomination-wide campaign he led to reduce exposure to malaria in tropical countries.

He is hopeful the denomination can find a way through its current stalemate on questions of sexuality, particularly on its current bans on same-sex marriage and ordaining openly gay and lesbian members. At its legislative General Conference last month, the denomination authorized creation of a commission that would seek a resolution.

“We have this notion that if everybody would think the same way it would work out just fine,” he said. “I'm not advocating an anything-goes approach, but to think we would be successful in getting everybody to embrace the same kind of ministry is just not going to happen.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.