A day before last month's blizzard left hundreds of motorists stranded along a stretch of road under his agency's supervision, the Pennsylvania Turnpike's chief executive attended a Harrisburg briefing where the governor's top meteorologist warned at least 12 to 18 inches of snow would fall along the corridor.
Forecaster Jeff Jumper repeated his projections in three video briefings to state officials the next day, including one monitored by turnpike managers.
"Anything along the track of the turnpike would have been among the hardest hit areas," Mr. Jumper said Thursday, recalling his message.
His account contradicts turnpike officials' claim this week that their storm response was hampered because they relied on a single forecast that understated the severity of the weather event.
That Jan. 22 forecast, which Turnpike Commission Chairman Sean Logan told legislators had called for a "manageable" six to eight inches of snow in south central Pennsylvania, reinforced turnpike managers' decision to send work crews home as their shifts ended at 3 p.m. on that Friday. It also formed the basis for their plan to ban some trucks and reduce speed limits at midnight — which would prove to be too late.
Within hours, jackknifed tractor-trailers had started an 11-mile bottleneck in the toll highway's westbound lanes between Bedford and Somerset that eventually trapped 60 buses, 100 cars, and 400 commercial vehicles in subfreezing weather until the next night.
In his testimony this week, Mr. Logan said it wasn't until later that Friday night — almost two hours after the backup started — that turnpike officials got an updated advisory from AccuWeather Inc., its contracted forecasting service, increasing predictions to a foot or two of snow.
In the wake of the debacle, Mr. Logan and other commission members said they would review its contract with AccuWeather and consider changing its reporting requirements.
But in interviews this week with The Inquirer, Mr. Jumper and other state officials said there had been no doubt about thepotential impact of the impending storm.
Mr. Jumper said he made it clear during the Jan. 21 briefing with agency heads, one attended by Turnpike CEO Mark Compton.
That same day, Gov. Tom Wolf declared a state of emergency. At Mr. Wolf's news conference that day, also attended by Mr. Compton, Mr. Jumper repeated his warning.
"That was the message that I conveyed from the outset, even before we had snowfall totals out, [on] Tuesday and Wednesday," Mr. Jumper, the lead forecaster for the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency, said Thursday. "Turnpike and south had the most significant impacts expected out of this."
He said he arrived at his forecasts in consultation with the National Weather Service, which the morning of the storm had been predicting 12 to 18 inches with the potential for two feet for the Somerset area.
It ultimately got nearly three feet.
PennDot Secretary Leslie Richards, whose agency shares the turnpike's contract with AccuWeather, said she personally reached out to Mr. Jumper early that Friday to make sure his forecast hadn't changed.
"The resounding message was: We were expecting a lot of snow," Ms. Richards recalled. "For us, it meant just one thing: That we want to have all our plows out on the road, 24 hours coverage. We were starting Friday afternoon."
Mr. Compton was out of town and unavailable Thursday, according to turnpike spokesman Carl DeFebo. Asked about the accounts of other state officials who recalled multiple and broad warnings about the storm's potential, Mr. DeFebo issued a written statement attributed to Mr. Logan.
"The PA Turnpike Commission relies on several forecasting sources: AccuWeather is one but we also access National Weather Service (NWS) forecasts via PEMA and the State Meteorologist," it said. "Neither source is weighed over the other; input from both is considered as a whole in decision-making."
In testimony this week, Mr. Logan told the Senate Transportation committee that there had been "a six-and-a-half-hour gap" in forecasts from AccuWeather and that turnpike managers made staffing and preparation decisions based on the regular 3:15 p.m. AccuWeather advisory.
"In that area — New Stanton, Somerset, Bedford — they were calling for six, eight inches," he testified. "Those folks know how to handle that."
AccuWeather CEO Barry Lee Myers has said its predictions the day the storm hit included "blizzard whiteout conditions" where the turnpike jam-up occurred. He also said its meteorologists are available around the clock for their clients.
Ms. Richards, the transportation secretary, said her agency reaches out to AccuWeather forecasters at any hour.
While the turnpike was sending crews home that afternoon, PennDot decided early that day to extend its workers' shifts.
"Once we know we're getting at least six inches of snow, we know we'll be at full complement, extending shifts until the storm ends, regardless of whether updates said we'd get six inches or two feet of snow," said Erin Waters-Trasatt, PennDot deputy press secretary. "For Bedford County, the first 12-hour shift started at noon on Friday."
The turnpike commission has embarked on a lengthy investigation and plans to issue a report after its completion in March.
"Certainly, weather forecasting is being carefully examined during our After-Action Review," Mr. Logan said this week.
Still, his testimony startled James W. Runk, president and chief executive of the Pennsylvania Motor Truck Association, who attended the hearing.
"You would think that the [weather] updates would be maybe hourly or half hourly," Mr. Runk said Thursday. "In retrospect, had they known it was going to be that bad, possibly the best decision would have been to close that portion of it."
Such a decision, however, would have had to have been made hours in advance, if not a day, to reach truckers en route to the state. To make that call, Mr. Runk said, "You have to get good reliable intelligence from the weather people."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.