As a florist for 66 years — starting as a part-timer at age 14 — Herman Heyl knows more people die on and around Christmas and New Year’s Day than at any other time of the year.
“Back then, I’d even have to work on Christmas because people would be laid out [for a funeral] even on Christmas Day,” said Mr. Heyl, owner of his own floral shops in the Pittsburgh area for 59 years. “Undertakers won’t do that now, but there are still more [funerals] after Christmas most years.”
The weeks before Christmas are among the busiest of the year for florists like Mr. Heyl.
But he has long known he would sell more funeral arrangements to friends or family of those who died on or after Christmas — a business reality as well as for many funeral homes, churches and synagogues and hospital emergency rooms that often are busier this time of year.
The fact that more people die on Christmas, as well as the day after Christmas, and New Year’s Day is a long-studied phenomenon. Exactly why it occurs is still not precisely known, though researchers continue to try to pinpoint the cause, examining everything from personal stress, to the levels of staffing in hospitals, to people’s delay in seeking medical treatment.

PG graphic (Click image for larger version)
A 2010 study from one of the world’s experts on death trends, sociology professor David Phillips, of the University of California at San Diego, looked at 57.5 million U.S. death certificates from 1979 to 2004.
It found that more people — 42,325 more — died of natural causes in the two weeks around Christmas and New Years than would normally be expected, even given a normal increase in deaths during winter. It also found significant spikes in dead on arrival deaths at hospitals and emergency room deaths on Dec. 25, Dec. 26 and Jan. 1.
A more recent 2013 study out of England found that emergency room patients admitted on public holidays are significantly more likely to die than other days.
Death cases reported to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office over the last four years show an obvious spike in December and January every year.
Figures on specific days provided by the Allegheny County Health Department also support these trends. Aggregate data on all deaths in the county from 2008 through the end of 2012 shows that while Christmas and New Year’s Day are above the daily average of deaths (185) New Year’s Eve is deadlier, with a combined 240 deaths over those five years, second deadliest to Feb. 10, which had 258 deaths.
The second deadliest week over the year, according to health department figures, is the week after New Year’s, with 1,452 deaths over those five years, second only to the week around Feb. 10, which had 1,493 deaths.
No study has found a definitive reason for this sad tilt to the season.
Whatever the cause, many of those who have to deal with the results of it — from florists and funeral homes, to priests and emergency room managers — have policies built-in to adapt to the reality.
“I don’t know why, but it just seems that January is never really slow” for the funeral business, said Patrick Lanigan, owner of Lanigan Funeral Homes for the last 40 years. “I’ve always thought that folks might hang on for the holidays, and, after something has been anticipated like that and January comes and it’s black at times and the days are short, maybe that’s when they let go.”
Mr. Lanigan and the other three licensed funeral directors who work for him purposely split up the major holidays this time of year — Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Years — so that only one is on vacation at a time.
“We’re always prepared if a family needs us,” he said. “But when a death occurs around the holidays, it’s maybe a little more emotional for those families.”
Scott Beinhauer, whose family has run Beinhauer Family Funeral Homes in the region for 155 years, said his company has a policy similar to Mr. Lanigans, ensuring that their funeral directors are not on vacation at the same time during the holidays.
He said he has long been familiar with the spike in deaths over the holidays, though he has never found a definitive answer to the question of why.
The Rev. Albert Semler, pastor at Good Shepherd Catholic church in Braddock, has worked for 48 years in various parishes in the Pittsburgh area and long understood that more people tend to die on or around the holidays than at other times of the year.
“I just always have thought that the joyful expectation [of the season] or the loneliness that kind of hits them” leading to more deaths around the holidays, he said.
Though Christmas is the busiest time of the year for Christian ministers anyway, the increase in funerals adds to the workload.
Don Yealy, chairman of emergency medicine at UPMC, pulled data from UPMC’s Pittsburgh hospitals and found that mortality rates on the holidays in their emergency rooms have fallen in recent years.
Still, he said, a related phenomenon that many researchers have been trying to dig into of increases in emergency room visits on and just after the holidays is very real.
“Christmas, during the day, is not very busy. But in the evening and the next day is very busy. And the same thing happens on New Years,” he said. “We tend to think on those holidays that people don’t have as many other health care options to visit” because primary care doctors’ offices are closed.
A similar effect is seen on patient volumes during and after Steeler games, he said.
“So, do they postpone care? Or do we make it harder for them to get care?” he asked.
Whatever the reason, he said, “That tells you those are sociological factors that drive health care decisions. We just don’t know all the factors.”
Concerned about the patient volumes over the holidays, he said UPMC has long tried to ensure that the level of care is appropriate, so that — like funeral home directors — emergency room doctors have to pick one of the three holidays this time of year — Thanksgiving, Christmas or New Years — to work.
“We try to make sure there are similar levels of experience” on holidays to non-holiday days, said Dr. Yealy, who will be working Christmas day.
His counterpart at Allegheny Health Network, Tom Campbell, chairman of the emergency department for its hospitals, said the figures on emergency room deaths at AHN are similar to UPMC’s.
But AHN also has a similar policy of encouraging everyone to work a holiday, and, at AHN senior staffers “tend to let the people with young kids stay homes for the holidays” ensuring that more experienced doctors will be working those days.
“It seems to be part of our culture,” he said. “Our more senior doctors like myself, us old guys, tend to work on holidays because we don’t have the little kids.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2579 or on Twitter @SeanDHamill.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.