Two days after Judge Lester G. Nauhaus refused to recuse himself from the criminal sentencing of a former Allegheny County councilman, he wrote to the president judge that he had to step down from the case for health reasons.
In his Dec. 11 letter, the senior judge told Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, “I can think of no legal reason to recuse myself.” Still, Judge Nauhaus said, he wanted off.
“His health is more important than his obligation to the case,” Judge Manning said Thursday in explaining why he had asked criminal division administrative Judge David R. Cashman to either handle the case or reassign it.
Judge Cashman kept it and sentenced Charles McCullough on Thursday to serve 2½ to 5 years in prison to be followed by three years of probation on convictions of theft and misapplication of funds. He will be eligible for release after about 24 months. The judge did grant a motion by the defense to allow Mr. McCullough to remain free for 30 days pending the commencement of appeals. Another court date is set for Jan. 22.
After sentencing, Mr. McCullough, 60, and family members lingered in the courtroom, consoling one another.
“I’m sure he and and his family are quite crushed,” said his new defense attorney, David Pollock, who had expected Judge Nauhaus to preside at the hearing.
“I was surprised. There was no order to the effect that Judge Cashman would be the one imposing the sentence,” he said. “I saw Judge Nauhaus here today, and so when Judge Cashman came out, I really wasn’t sure what to make of it. I can't imagine what the illness was that kept him from doing the sentencing.”
As for the penalty, Mr. Pollock said, “I thought the sentence seemed heavy-handed for an individual who’s had 60 years of exemplary record and little indication that anything like this would ever happen again.”
Sentencing guidelines called for possible probation in the mitigated range and up to nine months’ incarceration in the aggravated range. Judge Cashman had strong words for the defendant, who was found guilty of writing checks from the account of Shirley H. Jordan.
Ms. Jordan, who has since died, was worth $14 million and had dementia when he possessed power of attorney over her affairs and was a co-trustee of her trust fund in 2006 and 2007. The money from those checks was returned shortly after the checks were written and the allegations against Mr. McCullough became public.
“Mr. McCullough, your action in this particular case is an egregious breach of trust that was given you. You acknowledged you had a legal and moral obligation to act in her best interest and not to benefit yourself,” Judge Cashman said. “[Y]our actions were fueled by ego and self-interest. There is no other explanation for your actions other than you viewed Mrs. Jordan’s assets as your own private bank to fund your political aspirations.”
Ten of Mr. McCullough’s friends and colleagues testified as character witnesses about his reputation for integrity and service in the community.
“He showed up one meeting like an angel from heaven, told us he was a lawyer and wanted to help us in our struggle against UPMC,” said Virginia Eskridge, who met Mr. McCullough during the fight to save Braddock Hospital. “He’s wonderful and did it all for nothing.”
When it was his turn to speak, Mr. McCullough apologized to the court “for any undue delay that may be attributable to me and my vigorous defense,” and then apologized to any remaining friends of Ms. Jordan.
“You have my word, your honor, that I will stay out of trouble, and I will not engage in any criminal misconduct.”
Mr. McCullough said that he has been humbled by the experience, and that he now works two days a week stocking grocery store shelves.
Assistant district attorney John Fitzgerald said he did not believe Mr. McCullough has been humbled, and instead noted that he saw him high-five his defense attorney during one witness’ testimony at trial.
“He’s saying this here, now, convicted,” Mr. Fitzgerald said, calling Mr. McCullough’s words “arrogant” and “self-serving.”
“He’s asking for consideration he does not deserve.”
Although Mr. Pollock does not think the change in judges at sentencing is an issue for appeal on its own, he wondered whether Judge Cashman read the 2,500 pages of transcripts from proceedings that stretched over eight years relative to the case.
“It took me three to four weeks to digest and get up to speed. To find out a judge got sick and another judge stepped in and was able to sentence someone without the benefit of being able to review all that — which we don’t know one way or the other — seems difficult to me,” Mr. Pollock said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.