The state Supreme Court late Wednesday denied a request by former Allegheny County councilman Chuck McCullough to take his case.

He will be sentenced this morning on 10 criminal counts related to writing checks as political contributions from the funds of an elderly widow for whom he had power of attorney.

Mr. McCullough had a nonjury trial before Common Pleas Senior Judge Lester G. Nauhaus before being found guilty on 10 of 24 counts filed against him. He was scheduled to be sentenced on Nov. 9, but filed a motion asking Judge Nauhaus to recuse himself. In it, Mr. McCullough alleged that the judge had improper communications with his former defense attorney, Jon Pushinsky, as well as with the court’s own secretary.

Judge Nauhaus referred the matter to President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, who held a hearing on the matter on Nov. 19. However, at that hearing, neither Judge Nauhaus nor Mr. Pushinsky were made to testify. Mr. McCullough refused to take the stand, and Judge Manning denied the request.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCullough filed a request for King’s Bench relief with the state Supreme Court last week, asking that the appellate court take the case to correct what he saw as grievous errors in due process.

The Allegheny County district attorney's office objected, and said that Mr. McCullough ought to be sentenced by Judge Nauhaus.

The state Supreme Court gave no written explanation for denying the petition.