In the minutes before the Armstrong County Jail staff was alerted this summer that inmate Robert E. Crissman Jr. had run away, the corrections officer who was supposed to be monitoring him remotely by camera was dozing in a central control area, according to a consultant’s report released Wednesday.
“You can see his head ‘nod off’ then fairly rapidly rise to a position of being more alert,” according to the 21-page report by Monaca-based CSI Corporate Security and Investigations Inc., which blacked out the names of everyone interviewed at the county’s request.
Authorities say Crissman, 38, a heroin user and petty criminal, slipped away while working as an inmate trusty — someone granted special privileges because of good behavior — and killed Tammy Long, 55, a Rayburn resident who lived near the jail. Crissman was unsupervised and standing outside the jail on July 30 awaiting a van delivering food trays when he left. He was recaptured and charged with murder.
While CSI pointed out that Crissman’s escape could not be attributed solely to the corrections officer, that revelation and others uncovered through interviews and reviews of documents and videos depict the 158-bed facility as one utterly unprepared to handle such an emergency.
ARMSTRONG COUNTY CSI REPORT (PDF)
ARMSTRONG COUNTY CSI REPORT (Text)
Read More
Problems ranged from the jail’s “abysmal” training, to its inability to efficiently deploy teams of corrections officers meant to pursue escapees, to some members not being qualified with their guns on the firing range, to the teams not being able to leave the jail premises — something CSI found to be “inexplicable.”
Crissman’s ability to become a trusty rested on his past behavior at the jail, a lack of training for jail staff to recognize that he was likely going through drug withdrawal, and indications that the warden did not follow policy and personally review Crissman’s file; instead, the report said, the warden “deviated from standard protocol” and delegated the responsibility.
CSI’s report revealed almost darkly comedic moments, such as a chronic inability by jail staff to raise the county sheriff, Bill Rupert, on his cell phone, and an argument between a jail office manager and an unidentified jail employee who could not get out of the prison because the office manager was holding one door open, which prevented the other from opening for the employee in pursuit.
“There’s almost a Keystone Kops element to this where there was such a lack of training and preparedness that when something like this happened they just didn’t know what to do,” said attorney George Kontos, who is preparing a wrongful death suit on behalf of Ms. Long’s children.
CSI was paid $15,000 for its work. The final product — dated Sept. 11 and sent to Armstrong County’s human resources director — was filled with comments from unidentified corrections officers skewering Warden David Hogue. He was suspended without pay shortly after the escape and has informed the county that he will resign as of next month.
Although the Armstrong County Prison Board authorized the report, it did not receive it with open arms. A statement said, “while the report speaks for itself, the Prison Board does not agree with all of the comments or conclusions contained in that report.”
Board solicitor John Bechtol released a statement in which the board absolved corrections officers of responsibility for “Crissman's volitional and unexpected actions” and said the officers complied with jail policies.
ARMSTRONG COUNTY PRISON BOARD PRESS RELEASE (PDF)
ARMSTRONG COUNTY PRISON BOARD PRESS RELEASE (Text)
Louis W. Gentile, CSI’s CEO and founder, agreed with that. But he added, “It’s more an organizational matter. There [are] issues there.... Are the policies and procedures adequate? Is the training adequate?”
While Mr. Gentile acknowledged that the report did not go easy on Mr. Hogue, he said he thought the warden’s ability to run a jail could be salvaged with the proper training and counseling. As well, Mr. Gentile said, while the jail had problems managing Crissman’s escape, that does not mean the whole facility is in trouble.
“I’m not here defending the jail but I wouldn’t go so far as to say the jail is in dire straits. This is just one component of their emergency response. This doesn’t reflect the entire operation of the entire entire jail. This doesn’t mean that everything else is in disarray.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.