PublicSource submitted a right-to-know request for every restaurant inspection conducted by the Allegheny County Health Department from Jan. 1, 2012, to April 30, 2015.

Allegheny County Council voted down the restaurant grading system May 5. PublicSource submitted the request for records May 14 and received the records June 22.

Our analysis was based on restaurants, chain restaurants and banquet halls. There are many other types of places the health department inspects, such as school cafeterias and catering businesses, but those were outside of the scope of this story.

The health department only recently started categorizing each health violation as a high-risk, medium-risk or low-risk violation. This limited our grading analysis to the period of July 1, 2014, to April 30, 2015, as opposed to the full three years of data we received.

Advertise with us

The grading system for an inspection would have started at 100. An A grade would have been a restaurant that scored 90 to 100; B would have been 80 to 89; C would have been 70 to 79. Anything lower than a C would have qualified the restaurant for a potential alert or closure.

A health inspector would have subtracted a maximum of five points for a high-risk violation, a maximum of three points for a medium-risk violation and one point for a low-risk violation

If a restaurant had a high-risk and a medium-risk violation in the same category, only the higher point value violation counted against the establishment, not both.

Not knowing if an inspector would have assigned four or five points to a high-risk violation and two or three points to a medium-risk violation, PublicSource used three points for every medium-risk violation and five points for every high-risk violation.

Out of 20,000 records, there were 473 violations that were not assigned a severity by the health department. PublicSource assigned those violations the lowest point value — one point — because the health department noted a violation had taken place. All but 17 of those violations occurred in general sanitation categories, which could only be one-point, low-risk violations.

Advertise with us

Restaurants get a pass if they have only one or two low-risk violations in nonfood-related categories, such as inadequate lighting. Only when there are three low-risk violations would a one-point deduction be taken for each.

The health department also would have rewarded exceptional food safety practices with a bonus point.