PHILADELPHIA — Chester County Hospital cannot have 1,352 bottles of fine wine set to be destroyed by the state, a judge said Tuesday.
The hospital had hoped to use the wine for fundraising, but state law does not allow for the sale of condemned alcohol, the judge ruled.
It could be the end of the road for the bottles, which have been at the center of a legal battle that began in January 2014, when Chester County attorney Arthur Goldman was charged with buying and reselling high-end wine that wasn’t available for purchase in Pennsylvania.
Mr. Goldman was allowed to keep 1,047 of the 2,447 bottles confiscated.
Of the 1,400 bottles left, 16 will remain in evidence until Mr. Goldman — who was admitted into a two-year accelerated rehabilitative disposition program that could allow his record to be expunged — concludes his case. Thirty-two other bottles have broken, according to the Tuesday opinion.
The remaining wine was to be destroyed, the presiding judge in Chester County, Edward Griffith, ordered in August.
When Chester County Hospital asked Judge Griffith to change his order, the attorney general’s office argued that there was no way for the hospital to use the wine lawfully.
Just less than two weeks after hearing arguments, the judge agreed, ruling in his opinion that, though a provision in state law allows hospitals to take forfeited liquor for their "use," that use does not include sale "in any context, including a wine auction or other fund-raising activities to serve the charitable works of a hospital."
When the provision was first written in 1935, liquor was used medicinally.
“Our legal position in this case was based off an interpretation of the law as it’s written,” said Jeffrey Johnson, a spokesman for the attorney general’s office. “It would be up to the Legislature to change the liquor code.”
The judge also ruled the hospital did not have standing to intervene in the proceedings.
The attorney general’s office was “very pleased with the decision,” Mr. Johnson said. The office’s attorneys asked liquor control enforcement authorities to wait at least 30 days before destroying the wine in case the hospital appeals, he said.
Calls to the hospital and to its attorney were not returned Tuesday afternoon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.