An outgoing Allegheny County councilwoman on Tuesday called the body she has served on since 2012 “superfluous” and detailed suggested changes that would address the “shortcomings” of its structure.

Heather Heidelbaugh, a Republican at-large council member from Mt. Lebanon, asked the group studying how county government works to consider several recommendations, including possibly eliminating the part-time, 15-member council altogether.

Since January 2012, county council members have sponsored only 36 ordinances, Ms. Heidelbaugh wrote in a 15-page report, and county Executive Rich Fitzgerald “dominates the legislative activities of the legislative branch” as the primary sponsor of 85 ordinances in that period. She is not running for re-election.

“Because county council doesn’t do anything, doesn’t legislate, it’s superfluous,” Ms. Heidelbaugh told the nine-member Government Review Commission on Tuesday. “We shuffle a lot of paper, and we don’t get anything done.”

Advertise with us

She further recommended that the county home rule charter be amended to require legislative authorization for all contracts and that the commission stress that council should follow the rule requiring it to take a final vote on a bill within 90 days. The restaurant-grading proposal voted down by council in May had first stalled in committee past that time, requiring it to be reintroduced to full council and resubmitted to the committee.

That bill, she continued, was the only ordinance or resolution sponsored by a chief executive that as of June 1 “has ever failed before council and not later been approved in substantially similar form” since council replaced the three-commissioner system of government in 2000.

No ordinance or resolution sponsored by Mr. Fitzgerald failed a council vote in 2012 through 2014, she said.

“If that’s true, that means the majority of the people have agreed with what was put in,” said council President John DeFazio, D-Shaler. “That isn’t being a rubber stamp.”

County spokeswoman Amie Downs declined to comment on the report.

Advertise with us

Jim Roddey, former county executive and chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, agreed with the recommendations related to contracts and bill aging but said “the elimination of the council for all practical purposes would make home rule a shell.”

The Government Review Commission, which includes two former county councilmen, must conduct a yearlong review of how government is working every 10 years. It is expected to produce a report next year with recommendations.

Jim Nowalk, commission member and head of the committee specifically studying the form of county government, said his group will meet in August to examine the county council structure. On Tuesday it discussed the county manager’s role and this month will meet to review that of the county executive.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.