The Democratic candidates for county controller exchanged familiar critiques Tuesday night in what was expected to be their last face-to-face meeting before next week's primary election.

Chelsa Wagner, the incumbent, portrayed herself as an independent voice who could be counted on to provide checks and balances in a county government dominated by her political rival, Executive Rich Fitzgerald. Mark Patrick Flaherty, her predecessor, contended that Ms. Wagner has presided over an increasingly politicized office that has suffered an erosion of professionalism in the four years since he relinquished the post.

Mr. Flaherty said the number of certified public accountants and auditors on the staff has declined since he left office. Ms. Wagner challenged his accounting, but the Mr. Flaherty stood by the assertion.

Much of the one-hour argument focused on the two candidates’ very different relationships with Mr. Fitzgerald.

Advertise with us

Mr. Flaherty, who is supported by the executive, who is unopposed in his own re-election, said he would work with him cooperatively in a way that would enhance solutions to problems in county government.

Ms. Wagner rejected his repeated charge that she was responsible for the political estrangement between the two offices. She contended that Mr. Fitzgerald was the source of the courthouse tensions because of the “overreach”' that characterizes his dominance of a weak council. Pointing to Mr. Fitzgerald’s backing of Mr. Flaherty, she said that if the executive could effectively choose the controller the office might as well be appointive rather than elected.

Despite their conflicting attitudes toward Mr. Fitzgerald, both candidates came down on the same side of a running argument between the executive and the current controller. Mr. Fitzgerald has challenged Ms. Wagner’s efforts to audit county authorities, contending that she was attempting to exceed her legal powers. Mr. Flaherty said the office should audit such entities and argued that the fact that, during his tenure, he was able to do so without overt controversy reflected a more professional and cooperative approach to the office.

Mr. Flaherty echoed the criticism he levels in recent television commercial over the fact that Ms. Wagner accepted a salary one-third higher than the one he received in the office by accepting accumulated cost-of living increases that he had not taken. Ms. Wagner pointed out that Mr. Flaherty had said that if elected, he would take the same salary she now receives. And she maintained that her compensation remains a bargain for the taxpayers in that she does not take advantage of county health insurance or use a county car.

The forum, moderated by KDKA’s Jon Delano, was sponsored by the League of Women Voters of Greater Pittsburgh. No Republican has filed for the office, meaning that the winner of the Democratic nomination next week is all but certain to win the office in November.

Politics editor James P. O’Toole: jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.