There appears to be no debate that an elderly widow spoke with a former Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter in 2007 and expressed anger that her attorney had donated thousands of her dollars to politicians without her permission.
But whether the words that Shirley Jordan said to the reporter should be allowed in court is still in question.
Charles P. McCullough, a former Allegheny County councilman, is being tried on charges that he improperly used nearly $200,000 of Ms. Jordan’s money when he held power of attorney for her and was co-trustee of her trust fund.
The investigation began after former Post-Gazette reporter Dennis Roddy wrote in a story published April 13, 2007, that $40,000 had been donated in Ms. Jordan’s name to four Republican candidates.
Prosecutors trying Mr. McCullough in a nonjury trial before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Lester G. Nauhaus called Mr. Roddy to testify Thursday.
But defense attorney Jon Pushinsky told the judge he believes Ms. Jordan’s comments were hearsay and therefore should not be permitted at the trial.
Read More
Assistant district attorney John Fitzgerald contends the comments of Ms. Jordan, who died in 2010, should fall under the “excited utterance” exception to the hearsay rule.
Hearsay — testimony from a witness in court repeating what someone else said outside of court — is generally disallowed, David A. Harris, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said when contacted later in the day.
“We prefer to have the speaker of those words in court, rather than someone repeating them,” Mr. Harris said.
He said the idea behind the excited utterance exception is that the speaker is in such an excited state that the words are spontaneous.
“They don’t have the time to lie,” he said. “They’re just going to pop out with something.”
Judge Nauhaus allowed Mr. Roddy to testify about the conversation but told both sides to file briefs on the issue by today so he can determine whether to consider the testimony in reaching a verdict.
Mr. Roddy said he visited Ms. Jordan on April 10, 2007, at a senior living facility to discuss a $10,000 contribution that had been made to then-Superior Court candidate Cheryl Allen.
Ms. Jordan told him that her lawyer, Mr. McCullough, had made the donation.
“ ‘He wants to be important in politics,’ ” Mr. Roddy recounted the woman saying.
She said she had learned of the donation in a phone call thanking her.
“She said, ‘How much did I contribute?’ ” Mr. Roddy recalled. “I said, ‘Ten thousand.’ ”
“She was startled,” Mr. Roddy said. “People, generally, don't gasp — actual physical reaction. This is one of the rare moments when I saw it.
“She resumed speaking and said she would never give such a donation,” he said. “Her anger was exclusively aimed at Mr. McCullough.”
On cross-examination by Mr. Pushinsky — counter to the prosecution’s contention of an excited utterance — Mr. Roddy characterized Ms. Jordan’s tone at the time as conversational.
“Normal tone of voice?” the defense attorney asked.
“I believe so, yes,” Mr. Roddy said.
Mr. Pushinsky will argue that Ms. Jordan’s words do not fit the excited utterance exception to the hearsay rule and that because she has died, allowing the testimony to come through Mr. Roddy violates his client’s right to confront his accuser.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.