Now that Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald has made the board studying the framework of county government a more diverse group, one question remains: Will it make more lasting recommendations for changes than the last one?

Mr. Fitzgerald this week named his four appointees — all women, including two minorities — to the Government Review Commission, adding to the five members approved by county council in an 8-6 vote last week.

The unpaid, nine-member panel, which last met 10 years ago to evaluate the county’s home rule charter and make suggestions about how to improve county government, does not have the power to make any changes — only recommendations, which would need voter approval. In 2006, the first such commission completed its review, and found the structure to be “a tremendous improvement over the three-commissioner form of government,” chairman Don Linzer said then.

Mike Crossey, a member of the original commission, recalled an overall conclusion that taxpayers had made a good decision to go to the county executive-county council form of government “but that at the same time, power was very much concentrated in the county executive and that county council was very limited, one, in its resources, and two, in its ability to either challenge or push much of an agenda,” he said recently.

Advertise with us

Another member, Charles McCullough, recalled the experience as one that involved a great deal of time and effort for more than a year and resulted in a “very good” report.

“We worked very, very hard on it, and I think we came up with some very good ideas, particularly in the form of property assessment” that if adopted, would have prevented the “assessment mess” that came later, he said recently.

Among the commission’s recommendations in 2006 were that the charter be amended to allow council members to stay in their seats when they run for other offices and that a full-time board of directors oversee the county’s property assessment office, separate from the Property Assessment Appeals & Review Board.

Mr. McCullough said he doesn’t remember then-county Executive Dan Onorato acting on its suggestions. Mr. Onorato could not immediately be reached.

This time around Mr. Fitzgerald tapped attorney Andrea Geraghty; Tracey McCants Lewis, Duquesne University School of Law professor; Betsy Magley, major gifts manager for the Pittsburgh Promise​; and Aradhna Oliphant, president and CEO of Leadership Pittsburgh Inc. ​​All four are Pittsburgh residents. ​

Council appointed former Swissvale Mayor Mark Foerster; Hampton attorney Jay Hagerman, Whitehall Mayor Jim Nowalk; and former county councilmen Doug Price, from Collier, and Rick Schwartz from Harmar.