Amid the rugged terrain of wilderness American West, Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, or the Allegheny National Forest, Mother Nature still might display a balancing act perfected over millennia. Predators at the top of the food chain help keep the populations of deer in check, reducing if not eliminating overbrowsing and malnutrition.

In some urban and suburban settings, where the apex predators of another era have long since been removed and landscaping practices present a near perfect environment, deer numbers have exploded.

Communities around Pittsburgh — most recently Mt. Lebanon where a deer cull was called off last week — and urban and suburban areas around Toledo, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati and many other metropolitan areas, have a serious issue with intensifying deer-human conflicts.

“It’s not just the loss of predators [causing the conflicts] because the biggest predator for deer has been human. And in many of these areas there are severe hunting restrictions,” said Tom Fazi, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Game Commission’s Pittsburgh region. “So, with less and less human predation, plus the fact that in places like Mt. Lebanon, we’re creating the perfect habitat for deer with the manicured lawns and flowers that everyone loves, the deer population grows. It’s deer nirvana.”

Advertise with us

Jeff Sailer, executive director of the Toledo Zoo, said conventional suburban landscaping often lays out a scrumptious smorgasbord for deer, with ornamental fruit trees and other deer favorites such as tulips, Arbor Vitae, white pine, azaleas, rhododendrons, hostas and day lilies. “You are setting out a food basket — a food basket that is easy to process and that is high nutrient.”

While no plant is 100 percent deer resistant, deer generally avoid some ornamental grasses, and certain landscaping plants and trees have been found to be less pleasing to the whitetails’ palate.

The Penn State Cooperative Extension recommends incorporating plants that deer often avoid into landscaping plans, such as lavender, daffodil, foxglove, snapdragon and dahlia, along with basil, chives, dill and rosemary. St. Johnswort, aloe, scented geraniums, mountain laurel and goldenrod are not deer favorites, along with Colorado blue spruce, Norway spruce, catulpa and American holly.

With deer predators diminished and ideal sanctuaries built in suburbia, Mr. Sailer said, Americans should not be shocked that their communities are full of white-tailed deer.

In the South Hills near Pittsburgh, with few areas that freely allow deer hunting, collisions with vehicles is one of the biggest checks on the deer population, though not a strategy anyone wants to encourage.

Advertise with us

In the 12-township area that Mt. Lebanon is part of for animal control, the number of deer that have died in vehicle collisions has grown steadily over the last five years. Mt. Lebanon animal control Officer Don Cooley said — 316 deer died in road accidents in 2014, up from 266 deer in 2010.

One-third of last year’s incidents — 106 — occurred in Mt. Lebanon. It was the highest number in the 12-township region.

“I don’t think anybody wants to win in that category,” Mr. Cooley said. “But right now, vehicles are the most deadly thing for deer in our area.”

But the clock cannot be easily turned back, Mr. Sailer said, by trying to restore the balance by reintroducing the predators such as mountain lions, black bears, bobcats and wolves. Humans occupy much of their range now — and the public opinion would not embrace a higher population of lethal animals.

“If you reintroduced predators, you would reduce those deer numbers significantly. But you would probably have a couple of human deaths a year attributed to those animals, and you would lose a lot of pets and livestock, as well,” Mr. Sailer said.

Advertise with us

“Do you want the much more sensational newspaper story that a mountain lion dragged off a child, or do you want 15 news stories about people hitting a deer on the highway?” I think the animal dragging someone off and eating them is always going to trump the deer going through the front of a minivan.”

Mr. Fazi of the Pennsylvania Game Commission agreed.

“Artificially introducing predators to an urban/suburban area is never something we would do, or would be found acceptable by public,” he said. “It’s just not practical. You couldn’t introduce a cougar because it could potentially be a predator to a human.”

Predators long gone

Mountain lions, or cougars, disappeared from Ohio and Pennsylvania about 150 years ago, victims of unregulated hunting, bounty hunts related to claims of livestock depredation, and the loss of habitat. But as the current established populations of predators in the Dakotas, Plains States and elsewhere continue to disperse, Mr. Sailer said we should expect to have sightings of these nomadic and far-ranging animals in this area before long.

Advertise with us

In 2010, a mountain lion showed up on a trail camera near Bloomington, Ind. In 2011, a nature reserve near Canton, Ohio, had to be closed temporarily due to numerous reports of a mountain lion in the area.

DNA tests on a mountain lion that was struck and killed on a highway in Connecticut in summer 2011 confirmed that the animal came from North Dakota, more than 1,500 miles away. “It most likely passed through or near northwest Ohio,” Mr. Sailer said.

Black bears, which are also predators to deer, continue to live in Pennsylvania, and are found in Allegheny County, but not enough to help bring down the deer census. Black bears and bobcats, gone from Ohio by about 1850, both have returned to the state in limited numbers over the past four decades. Most black bear sightings occur in the northeast corner of Ohio, and there have been conflict issues with bears in the Cleveland suburbs. Research in Colorado indicates that black bear densities are increasing in the suburbs around Denver as deer numbers in those same areas rise.

Ohio’s bobcat population is centered in the hilly, southeastern part of the state, located primarily away from population centers. Around Pittsburgh, bobcats occasionally are found in suburban areas, including, most recently, in Upper St. Clair, said Mr. Cooley, the Mt. Lebanon animal control officer. But, like black bear, the numbers of bobcat are not high enough to impact the deer population.

Deer appear to be more comfortable living close to us, since we provide for their needs. Mr. Sailer recounted his time in south Florida where the Key deer, a small subspecies of the whitetail, is provided with a large, protected natural habitat on Big Pine Key, but deer are rarely seen in that sanctuary. Instead, they frequent the lush golf courses and neatly landscaped yards in nearby developments.

Advertise with us

“It is the same thing here in the Toledo area and in many other places around the country,” Mr. Sailer said. “They are going to choose the best places to go, and if we continue to provide all of these opportunities for deer, we will continue to have issues with them.”

And the issues are many, and the possible remedies are complex, often expensive, need to be repeated regularly, and are never pleasing to all parties involved /////// Meanwhile, the possible remedies to high deer populations are often expensive, need to be repeated regularly, and are never pleasing to all parties involved.

A deer culling plan in Mt. Lebanon, which has been accompanied by a firestorm of debate, was called off on Thursday when the owner of a company that had been contracted to remove 150 deer from the community by the end of March let municipal leaders know he would not complete the job.

The plan used by Wildlife Specialists of Tioga County involved baiting and trapping deer in corrals, and then shooting them from elevated stands with rifles equipped with noise suppressors. Mt. Lebanon officials had agreed to pay Wildlife Specialists and owner Merlin Benner $500 per culled deer, to a maximum of $75,000 a year, in the hope that a significant reduction in deer-car collisions would result.

Mr. Benner cited weather, protests against the cull, and a delay in receiving his permit for the culling operation as the primary reasons his efforts had resulted in just six deer being culled from the area. Estimates have put the Mt. Lebanon deer population at 400-500 animals.

Advertise with us

Mt. Lebanon does already have the most common deer predator — next to hunters and cars — present in the community: coyotes.

“Yes, there are increasingly coyotes here,” Mr. Cooley said. “In my first 15 years here, coyotes were something you never saw. But these last 10 years, you start to see them more and more.”

Despite that, he said, Mt. Lebanon has never found any cases where a coyote has killed a family dog or cat.

That was a concern this last week among some residents in Ross in the North Hills, where a small pack of coyotes apparently has taken up residence not far from the Ross Park Mall and begun preying on the large number of deer there.

Coyotes are too small to take down adult deer, generally, and focus on deer fawns, said Peter Cappa, for 20 years the owner of Cappa Wildlife Control Services in Murrysville, which helps with wild animal issues in the Pittsburgh area.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Cooley said the main food source that probably has drawn coyotes to Mt. Lebanon and other suburban areas is not deer, but groundhogs and other small, slower varmints.

Even with the rise in coyotes in the region, they could never been enough to make up for the loss of hunting, said Mr. Fazi.

“Even out West, where you have all these bigger predators — mountain lions and wolves — man is still the biggest predator for white tail deer,” he said.

‘You are likely wasting money’

Mike Tonkovich, a Ph.D. who is the deer program administrator for the Ohio Division of Wildlife, said a 150-pound whitetail will consume 10-12 pounds of forage per day, or close to two tons each year. Unchecked, a suburban deer herd could double in size every two years.

Advertise with us

Mr. Tonkovich said he is working on a deer management plan with a park district in Hamilton County, Ohio, where a proposal to expand a very successful archery hunt met with resistance. A costly tranquilize and sterilization program is being pitched by some as an alternative, but like all of the options in the suburban deer management toolbox, it is not without flaws.

“Free-ranging deer present a mountain of problems, because they are not on an island, and you can’t contracept all of them,” he said.

Mr. Tonkovich said some does will not be captured and sterilized, while more deer will come into the area and produce fawns. “So at a thousand dollars a pop for sterilizations, you are likely wasting money.”

Mr. Sailer also has reservations about capture/sterilize/release programs that he sees as very short-term, stop-gap exercises.

“You won’t get them all, and by removing certain individuals as breeders, you have created your own selection that way. The deer that are warier are less likely to get tranquilized, so they are the ones that reproduce, and you end up with warier deer herd overall,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Tonkovich said sterilizing programs put does right back in the ecosystem, and these animals will live 15-20 years, still foraging on landscaping, and still presenting a hazard for automobiles.

“I would support a project that would reduce the population, and then contracept, but I just don’t see any value in contracepting a bunch of does and releasing them, even if you have the money,” he said. “It’s a feel-good operation.”

Other options include using chemical contraceptives such as PZP, a vaccine that works with the immune system in a doe to prevent her eggs from being fertilized. Mr. Sailer said such programs, which require state approval most places, have significant cost and reliability issues.

“Contraceptives are incredibly expensive, both in time and resources, and there’s no guarantee,” he said. “At zoos, we work with chemical contraceptives in a lot of animals, and it is a very fine science – certain drugs don’t work the same from animal to animal.”

Removal concerns

Advertise with us

Several methods of culling or removing animals from the system are being utilized in areas with significant deer-human conflicts. Controlled archery hunts use citizen hunters to remove a certain number of deer from heavily impacted areas. In other cases, sharpshooters are hired to cull deer with rifles, shooting from elevated platforms, sometimes with night vision equipment. The deer culled by professionals are usually processed and donated to area food pantries.

The Metroparks of the Toledo Area has used a managed archery hunt the past two years in an effort to protect the fragile ecosystem of the Oak Openings region from extensive damage done by a burgeoning deer herd. The hunts have taken place in remote areas of the park system where public access is minimal.

Steve Madewell, executive director of Metroparks, said that as a “cost-effective” means of reducing the deer herd, a lottery has been used to select volunteer archers who are proficiency-screened. Despite objections from some park supporters who opposed the hunt, and complaints from adjacent property owners who also opposed it, Mr. Madewell said he hopes most people understand that the destructive browsing of too many deer could not go on unchecked.

“We’re not reinventing the wheel here. These are uncomfortable decisions, but they are decisions made with a great deal of thought,” he said. “People may not like the specific action, but they realize that something needs to be done. We have the responsibility to manage and protect our resources, in a holistic way.”

Long-term commitment

Advertise with us

Anthony DeNicola is president of White Buffalo, Inc., a nonprofit organization dedicated to the conservation of native species and ecosystems. Mr. DeNicola, who holds a master’s from the Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies and a Ph.D. from Purdue in wildlife ecology, specializes in wildlife management in non-traditional settings, and has advised numerous communities on dealing with expanding deer herds.

“Your options are very site-specific, and often depend on the size of the area and the local politics,” Mr. DeNicola said by telephone from Guam, where he is working on a wildlife conservation project. He sees a cull/control/habitat modification plan as a viable option in some cases.

“If you combine methods, you may have a better outcome,” he said, “but everything has a cost, and once you start down the road of taking action, you can’t stop.”

Mr. Sailer stressed the same point: None of the methods for addressing deer issues in suburban settings involves any magical elixir, all carry a price tag which is often significant, and none is a one-time operation.

“All these things have costs that would be ongoing for any community that wanted to manage their deer,” he said. “In the end, if you don’t have the predators there taking care of it for you, or you don’t have the predators in conjunction with habitat management, it doesn’t matter if it is sharp-shooting or contraceptives, you are going to spend money, and you are going to do it over and over and over again.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Tonkovich said that by removing the predators and fashioning the landscape of suburbia in the prevalent manner, we have created an artificial ecosystem that encourages deer to proliferate.

“You hear the argument we should just let Mother Nature take her course, but we have completely disrupted what Mother Nature set up,” he said. “Mother Nature left a long time ago.”

That has left almost every urban or suburban community to deal with the problem, said Mr. Fazi of the Pennsylvania Game Commission said “Mt. Lebanon has been taking it on the chin here recently. But just about every other municipality in Allegheny County has had to deal with this, or will deal with this, based on the number of complaints about deer we get,” he said.

“But introducing predators? That’s certainly not going to be the answer,” he said. “It’s going to take a long time and a multifaceted approach to deal with this problem.”

The Block News Alliance consists of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and The Blade of Toledo, Ohio. Matt Markey:  mmarkey@theblade.com or 419-724-6068. Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579.