County Councilman Bill Robinson’s election petitions may feature some famous-looking names, but a legal challenge filed Tuesday alleges the petitions are so flawed that his own name should be removed from the Democratic primary ballot.
Mr. Robinson is seeking re-election in County Council District 10, which represents eastern Pittsburgh and adjoining suburbs. But a challenge filed by three district voters contests 343 of the 358 signatures on his petitions.
The bulk of the challenge involves 337 signatures on pages whose circulator is identified as Mr. Robinson himself. “[B]ased on the uniformity of handwriting for all purported signatures” on eight of those pages, the challenge alleges, “Bill Robinson did not actually circulate these petitions.”
“I’ll stand behind what I submitted,” said Mr. Robinson, who largely declined to comment directly on the challenge’s allegations. “I haven’t seen any material,” he said. “I’m just talking to you based on what you’re sharing with me.”
The legal filing includes copies of Mr. Robinson’s nominating papers, and the names of several signatories appear similar to those of noted celebrities. Among them are Jerome Bettis, Naomi Watts and “Russel Crowe.” The petition asserts that no one with those names, or many others on the petitions, could be found in county voter records.
The challenge is being financed by Better Jobs Better Future, a political action committee supporting another District 10 candidate, DeWitt Walton, along with other county office seekers.
Mike Mikus, the committee’s chairman, called Mr. Robinson’s petitions “the most egregious attempt at subverting the process I’ve ever seen.”
Mr. Robinson declined to respond: “I don’t know the gentleman,” he said of Mr. Mikus.
The Better Jobs committee also is financing challenges against Mr. Walton’s other rival in District 10, Eric Smith, as well as Richard Bradford, who is challenging John DeFazio for county council’s Democratic at-large seat.
Mr. Smith, the endorsed Democrat in District 10, bristled at the challenge’s objections to 393 of his 412 signatures.
“If you can’t win the endorsement and you don’t have a message people want, I guess this is what you do,” he said. “I went door to door getting signatures, and I’ve got nothing to hide.”
Mr. Bradford, who faces challenges to 69 of 512 signatures he filed, said that campaign workers might have made mistakes but that “I’m pretty optimistic” about his chances for remaining on the ballot. “It’s time we have a change of the guard.”
The county council challenges were among about 50 that Mark Wolosik, the county’s elections division manager, said had been filed on Tuesday. Petition challenges will be heard by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James on March 25 and 26.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.