It may take a judge to determine whether the Allegheny County controller has the legal right to audit county-appointed authorities that handle millions of dollars.

Controller Chelsa Wagner said the Allegheny County Airport Authority, Port Authority of Allegheny County, Allegheny County Sanitary Authority and the Pittsburgh-Allegheny County Sports and Exhibition Authority each has challenged her ability to audit them.

She announced Wednesday that if she does not receive a response from each by Monday indicating cooperation with her office, she will seek legal action, likely in the form of a declaratory judgment.

The county controller’s office wants to see how the airport authority, Alcosan and the Port Authority award contracts, and how the SEA, which owns the city’s three big sports venues, distributes tickets to sporting and entertainment events. Three have questioned her office’s authority to audit them, Ms. Wagner said.

Advertise with us

“The opposition … begs the ultimate question and really throws up the red flag. What are they hiding?” she said at a news conference.

Ms. Wagner said the Port Authority claimed it isn’t required to comply with her request because it isn’t a county agency. Port Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said that after Ms. Wagner first sent a letter to officials informing them of her intent, the authority asked for more detail and whether her office “has the legal authority to conduct such a broad audit of a state agency.”

Alcosan sought a delay, Ms. Wagner said, but then failed to provide the requested data that she said would be acceptable to postpone the start date. Jeanne K. Clark, Alcosan spokeswoman, said the authority is currently undergoing a required independent audit that can’t coincide with another.

“We have not denied her access to anything, nor have we promised anything,” Ms. Clark said.

The airport authority has vendors that generate county tax revenue, such as rental car companies and the Airmall at Pittsburgh International Airport, entities it permits the county controller to audit. Authority solicitor Mike Wojcik — also a former solicitor to a county controller — said it had not complied with her latest request to review contracting processes because such a broad request is not within her purview under the law.

Advertise with us

“I’ve compared this to telling your accountant that you spend so much on milk and eggs each month, but you’re not going to tell them you have a new Porsche in your garage. It’s absurd,” Ms. Wagner said.

Mr. Wojcik said her office audited the airport authority’s contract with its trash collector in 2013 because the authority invited her to do so.

An attorney representing the state-formed SEA said it gave Ms. Wagner information under the Right-to-Know law. She has said that as the county’s fiscal officer, she shouldn’t have to make requests in that manner.

Controllers in neighboring counties say they believe they have the legal right to audit county-appointed authorities, but they say the issue hasn’t come up much. They say they believe they have strong enough relationships with their county commissioners that they would receive permission if they wanted to audit an authority.

Ms. Wagner also asked Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto to urge the authorities to open their books. County spokeswoman Amie Downs and mayoral spokesman Timothy McNulty said the issue was between the authorities and the controller’s office.