SHENANGO, Pa. — To Dee Hosler, a matter-of-fact, 88-year-old resident of this Lawrence County municipality, it was nothing more than a regular, innocuous exchange with the secretary/​treasurer at town meetings.

“I would go up to him and ask him, ‘How’s our money?’ He would say, ‘We’re OK.’ ”

She paused. “And we weren’t.”

In this close-knit township of 7,500 people about 50 miles northwest of Pittsburgh, everybody knows everybody, and everybody knows Brian Tanner — the man charged with stealing nearly $800,000 from taxpayers across several years. His arrest last week was the culmination of a probe that began in early 2014 and resulted in his firing in July.

Advertise with us

For a time, the 49-year-old husband and father of two teenagers was an assistant coach for the high school basketball team, announced varsity football games and served as athletic director, said the township’s new secretary/​treasurer Al Burick III. In the township where Mr. Tanner had worked for 20 years, the officials trusted him. His father-in-law had been a township supervisor.

Even Mr. Burick, 32, who assumed the position of secretary/​treasurer after Mr. Tanner, has a connection: The two attended the same church, St. Michael in New Castle, and their mothers were friends.

At some point, he said, at least a few people sensed that something might be amiss.

“I would say 99 percent of people in Shenango Township trusted him,” Mr. Burick said. “And the other 1 percent had questions.”

Mr. Tanner, who surrendered to authorities Wednesday on 500 counts of forgery or theft-related charges, did not answer the door Thursday at his home. His attorney, David Acker, said he’s been cooperating with authorities, was released after posting $10,000 bond and plans to enter an initial not guilty plea at a preliminary hearing this week.

Advertise with us

Mr. Tanner was fired from his $57,000-a-year position after state auditors found he’d written hundreds of checks to himself and to the accountant he is accused of conspiring with, said Joshua Lamancusa, Lawrence County district attorney. The accountant, who also was fired, has not been charged.

At least one person had a hard time reconciling the character of a man he’s known for 20 years with one accused of stealing, across six years, what amounts to nearly half of the township’s 2015 budget.

Sitting among a group of men who gather daily at the McDonald’s on Ellwood Road, John Paolone, 71, of Shenango, said Thursday that his daughter’s brother-in-law “is innocent until proven guilty.”

“He’s always had a good reputation. It’s kind of a shock to hear all these accusations.”

But in charging documents, investigators from the district attorney’s office said co-workers described a culture in which only Mr. Tanner had access to Shenango’s fiscal affairs.

Advertise with us

He “created an environment within the township that he had a total control over township finances, bill paying, and control of other employees/​supervisors’ access to and knowledge of township financial records,” Detective Vincent Martwinski wrote in the complaint.

Inspectors from the state auditor general’s office were conducting a regular review of the township’s pension account in February when they noticed some questionable general fund account information in with the pension records, Mr. Lamancusa said.

The volume of checks Mr. Tanner had written to himself or the accountant — most in even amounts with zeros in the cents column — caught the auditors’ attention, he said.

When they saw “irregularities,” they shared the information with the district attorney’s office.

A few months later, detectives obtained search warrants for township bank records from the past six years and initially found $1.2 million in questionable payouts, then pared that down to a little more than $1 million after determining that some were legitimate, Mr. Lamancusa said. (Banks have an obligation to hold records for only seven years, he said.)

Advertise with us

After subtracting about $250,000 — the sum the township was contracted to pay its accountant across six years — investigators were left with between $750,000 and $800,000 of illegal payouts.

In all, prosecutors said, Mr. Tanner overpaid himself by about $450,000 and the accountant by $200,000, placed nearly $100,000 in a retirement account and also illegally used a township credit card.

According to the criminal complaint, Mr. Tanner forged the checks by using a stamp with a township supervisor’s signature. After the state audit in February, Shenango stopped using a stamp and now requires the signature of two supervisors.

Mr. Tanner and the accountant received more than $20,000 in one month, which prosecutors said was not approved by the supervisors, the complaint continued.

“Tanner acknowledged during the interview that what he did constituted the crime of theft,” the detective wrote.

Advertise with us

“This is a big loss,” Mr. Burick said. “The money could have gone a long way.”

Mr. Burick said the police department could have updated its fleet of cars. New road projects could have started. An aging salt truck could have been replaced. Instead, prosecutors allege, Mr. Tanner spent it on items including hard-to-get concert and sporting event tickets, airfare, hotels, a Dyson vacuum and a robotic pool cleaner. The township doesn’t have a pool.

Officials will get some of the money back. The township is insured for up to $400,000, Mr. Burick said, and Mr. Lamancusa said his office hopes to cover the rest by seeking asset forfeitures from Mr. Tanner.

For the township, the next step is to restore trust.

“This is taxpayer money,” Mr. Burick said. “It should be accounted for.”

Advertise with us

That’s a reason Mr. Lamancusa said he’s seeking prison time for the former township official, even though Mr. Tanner has no criminal record.

“There was a breach of trust, and those individuals have to be held accountable.”

Mr. Lamancusa said at least one other person could be facing charges in the coming week. A preliminary hearing for Mr. Tanner is set for Wednesday.

Molly Born: mborn@ post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944, Twitter @molly_born.