People hear the word “speakeasy” and think secret passwords and hidden doorways, but often it’s no more mysterious or illicit than a couple of fraternity brothers charging admission for a keg party.
“A speakeasy is simply this: anyone selling alcohol without a license,” said state police Sgt. William Baker, commander of the Pittsburgh district office for Liquor Control Enforcement. Though illegal speakeasies are sometimes conflated with bottle clubs or after-hours clubs, the hours of operation are irrelevant; a person, group or establishment selling drinks at 3:30 p.m. might be just as guilty as the ones selling drinks at 3:30 a.m.
In Clairton, police responded to a report of a shooting about 3:30 a.m. Friday. Six were wounded, and police said the location of the shooting, 648 Miller Ave., might have been operating as a speakeasy.
Sgt. Baker said speakeasies can come in many forms, and in the Pittsburgh region — Allegheny, Beaver, Fayette, Greene, Washington and Westmoreland counties — his agents shut down or break up 20 to 30 speakeasies a year.
Some, such as the suspected speakeasy in Clairton, operate out of physical storefronts as would any other bar, except that these establishments don’t have the proper licensing from the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board.
On March 1, state and local police raided a property in Aliquippa, seizing liquor, drugs, cash and weapons. The Main Street establishment had been designated as an “eating and drinking place,” but it was not licensed to sell alcohol at the time of the raid.
In August, also in Aliquippa, police shut down a bar operating illegally at 706 Davis St., known as Jessie’s Cafe and Beasley’s Bar. It, too, violated the state’s speakeasy laws.
Speakeasies aren’t confined to urban areas. Last year in Fayette County, state police raided the Lemont Furnace Sportsman’s Club, near Uniontown, seizing hundreds of gallons of beer, 50 gallons of liquor and more than $10,000 in cash.
Just as common as the illegal bars are parties that collect cover charges in exchange for beer and liquor: frat parties, football tailgate parties, even private social gatherings at rental halls, such as one that was broken up last year at the Irish Centre of Pittsburgh, in Squirrel Hill, Sgt. Baker said.
Often, the organizers of these private parties don’t realize they are breaking the law, Sgt. Baker said. In such cases, agents help the organizers comply with the law, if that’s possible. “We try to educate,” he said. He gave the example of a charitable fundraiser advertising all you can eat and drink for $25. If that same fundraiser charges $25 for food but allows people to drink without paying, they’d be complying with state law.
“It has to be free,” he said.
At the site of the Clairton shooting, posted on the front door was a sign that said “members only, 21 or older, donations only.” Those knowingly operating in violation of PLCB rules will often try to skirt the law by claiming they are collecting donations, or cover charges, not charging for drinks.
These types of late-night speakeasies are often known as “bottle clubs” and used to be more common in Pittsburgh before a 2002 change in city law prohibited such clubs and increased the penalties for those operating them. However, there is no PLCB regulation that prohibits an individual from bringing his own legally-procured alcohol to an establishment, so a true BYOB bottle club could be legal, so long as the establishment does not sell any booze and otherwise complies with local ordinances.
Other establishments try the well-known scalper trick, selling a meaningless trinket (such as a shot glass) in lieu of a cover charge then giving away the drinks for “free,” in the same way that online scalpers, prior to a 2007 change in law, might have tried selling a $500 Terrible Towel with two free playoff tickets thrown in.
The myriad licensing laws can be confusing: Holding a party at a rental hall and charging admission to drink might be illegal, but if that hall has a catering license, or if you hire licensed bartenders who are permitted to serve liquor off-site, you might be in the clear. Organizations that hold “club licenses,” such as fraternal organizations, can serve drinks until 3 a.m. and must close by 3:30 a.m., said state police liquor enforcement Officer Benjamin Brallier.
Though the term “speakeasy,” perhaps apocryphally, is said to have originated in McKeesport in the late 1880s, Sgt. Baker said they are not necessarily a Western Pennsylvania phenomenon. South of the Mason-Dixon line, they are more likely to be called “nip joints” or “shot houses.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.