UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — The latest recommendation from Penn State’s board of trustees was either a compromise or more petty dysfunction, depending on whom you ask.

Either way, after two-plus years of discussion and scrutiny, the board on Thursday recommended a plan for restructuring its composition.

The Committee on Governance and Long Range Planning recommended a reorganization of the board that will give representation to students, faculty and the alumni association. The proposal would add six new board members, three of whom would be at-large members, giving the board six new voting members.

But it also would eliminate the voting privileges of three other trustees, who sit on the board in their positions as the Pennsylvania secretaries of agriculture, education and conservation and natural resources. Those three secretaries would remain on the board as non-voting members.

Advertise with us

As part of the recommendation, the number of business/​industry, gubernatorial and agricultural trustees would remain at six and the number of alumni trustees would remain at nine.

The student trustee would be nominated by a student selection group, the academic trustee nominated by the Faculty Senate and the alumni association trustee would be the immediate past president of the alumni association.

The recommendation was approved by the eight-person Committee on Governance and Long Range Planning after a three-hour meeting. The lone member to vote against the proposal was alumni trustee Anthony Lubrano.

“It’s a compromise,” said business/​industry trustee Richard Dandrea, who had originally made a motion for a proposal that would have reduced the number of alumni trustees from nine to six. “And it allows us to move forward in a less divisive manner.”

The trustees have been considering restructuring the board since the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal broke and after accusations of conflicts of interest and being a “rubber stamp” for the university president. In 2013, the governor and university president were removed as voting members, and since then, further changes had been suggested by the state Legislature and the board, which hired an outside governance consultant to assist it this year.

Advertise with us

The proposal, known as Proposal A-plus, was put forth by board chairman Keith Masser on Thursday. Last month, the committee had been deciding among four proposals as well as a bill from state Sen. John Yudichak, D-Luzerne.

Two proposals called for a reduction in alumni trustees but not of the other groups. Another reduced from all groups except the alumni trustees. Mr. Yudichak wanted a reduction of one trustee of all four types of current trustees that would bring the board’s voting total to 23.

Thursday afternoon, Mr. Yudichak said the board violated state law in its recommendation, referring to the changes made to the government secretaries on the board. Although he said he favored making those secretaries non-voting members, he said the commonwealth must revise the law to make that happen.

He called the decision to reach Proposal A-plus one brought on by “a heavy-handed threat” to remove the alumni trustees and said the commonwealth would continue exploring legislative options.

The meeting became contentious at one point, particularly between Mr. Lubrano and Mr. Dandrea. Mr. Dandrea said reducing the number of alumni trustees made sense, given a study the trustees commissioned that found 33 of 36 boards had no alumni-elected representation.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lubrano said he voted against the proposal that was recommended by the committee because he didn’t think the past president of the alumni association should get an automatic seat. But he said he was pleased that no alumni trustees would be removed.

The recommendation will be put in front of the entire board in November.