Fred Goempel of West Homestead was 18 when he died in combat on the border of Luxembourg and Germany in February 1945, another casualty of a world war that claimed millions of young men just like him.
An Army private, he was killed Feb. 9 during the 5th Infantry Division’s attempt to cross the swollen Sauer River into Germany.
But 70 years later, no one knows for sure what happened to him. Did he drown? Did he step on a land mine? Where are his remains? Was he buried as an unknown?
Barbara Geisler, whose husband, Marty, is Pvt. Goempel’s nephew, has been trying for more than a decade to find out and bring his remains home to Pennsylvania. She has uncovered reports, witness accounts and maps, and even traveled to the site in 2010 and 2012 with Marty, recording it on a website dedicated to Pvt. Goempel.
“It’s a personal issue at this point,” she said. “It really bothered me that no one in the family knows for sure where he is.”
Thousands of other families across the U.S. share that sentiment.
Read More
Of the estimated 405,000 U.S. servicemen lost in World War II, at least 73,000 are still listed as missing or unaccounted for. They were airmen killed in crashes, soldiers buried as unknowns in far-flung cemeteries, sailors lost at sea.
Seventy years later, the Defense Department continues to search for these men, excavating sites around the world and updating their relatives at regular meetings.
The next one is Saturday at the DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Pittsburgh in Green Tree, where military representatives will gather with some 150 families, Ms. Geisler among them.
The Defense POW/Missing Personnel Office, or DPMO, which runs the meetings, refers to the recovery effort as “keeping the promise.”
“It is the nation’s promise to the families of those who fought America’s wars to account for and return their loved ones,” said Lt. Col. Melinda Morgan, public affairs officer with DPMO.
“Families want to know what happened to their loved ones and want them returned for proper burial — not left out in a field or isolated grave where homage cannot be paid by the family,” said Lisa Phillips, president of World War II Families for the Return of the Missing, based in Maine. “These men and woman sacrificed all for our freedoms.”
The mission to account for America’s missing war veterans began in the 1970s after the Vietnam War, but Congress later expanded it to include Korea and, since 2010, World War II.
The total number of unaccounted-for service members from all wars is 83,000, which includes 1,600 from Vietnam and 8,000 from Korea. Of those, about 35,000 are considered recoverable.
Congress in recent years has tried to speed up identifications, mandating that the Pentagon be able to identify 200 individuals a year by 2015 instead of the 70 it had been averaging.
America spends more than $100 million a year on this work, and it’s a daunting task because of the sheer numbers, especially from World War II.
Following the war, the Army’s American Graves Registration Service combed battlefields for isolated graves and disinterred temporary cemeteries across Europe, Asia and the Pacific. The remains of some 280,000 servicemen were identified and buried according to the wishes of their families.
But many others were never recovered.
In later years the Army’s mortuary system identified more service members based on reports from other countries. From 1976 to 2003, the task fell to the Army’s Central Identification Laboratory. In 2003, the lab merged with the Joint Task Force-Full Accounting to create the Joint POW/MIA Accounting Command, or JPAC, which has identified 300 service members to date.
JPAC and DPMO work together, but their performance has been marred by controversy.
Last year, two government reports lambasted JPAC as inefficient and mismanaged. Congress also accused the agencies of using outdated identification methods and unreliable databases, ignoring help from private groups and allowing bureaucratic infighting to hamper recovery.
As a result, Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel in March ordered that the offices be combined into a new agency. Some private researchers aren’t convinced it will help.
“They are not going to be any better,” said Ted Darcy, who runs WFI Research Group in Massachusetts and works to find MIAs on his own. “Worldwide, their reputation is ruined. It’s 70 years later and they still haven’t resolved the problem.”
While some families are satisfied with the Pentagon’s efforts, others are disgruntled, saying they’ve had trouble getting information or persuading the military to act on information they provide.
“They always tell you, ‘We never leave anyone behind.’ But they did,” said Ms. Geisler. “It seems like they don’t like change. It’s the bureaucracy that’s the problem.”
Yet she’ll attend Saturday’s meeting in anticipation of learning something new. “I hope they have a big packet of information waiting for me,” she said.
DPMO says it understands some of the frustration. “This is an emotional issue for these families,” said Col. Morgan.
The agencies do make progress, however.
Recently the Army returned the remains of Cpl. Alva Clifford Groves, a Korean War POW who died in 1951, to his family’s home in Shinnston, W.Va., after matching his DNA to that of his sister, Lillian Anderson.
The Army last month flew the remains in a flag-draped coffin to Pittsburgh, where a hearse drove it to West Virginia. Ms. Anderson had waited 63 year for her brother’s return. “I’m just glad that the government didn’t give up,” she said.
What happened to Fred?
Barbara Geisler’s search for Fred Goempel began in 2001 at the request of her mother-in-law, Fred’s younger sister.
She was 12 when he left for war in 1944.
“She told me that every time she heard the outside gate, she thought he was home,” said Ms. Geisler, who lives in Sinking Springs, Berks County.
Armed mainly with persistence, she compiled a record on Pvt. Goempel from various sources, such as his Individual Deceased Personnel File.
Every soldier killed in the war has a file describing the circumstances of his death. Some are detailed, but this one proved disappointing. Fred was a replacement soldier, having served in his platoon for only four days, and no one seemed to know him.
She reviewed records from the American Battlefields Monument Commission, other documents such as After Action reports, and contacted men with whom Fred served.
She has not found a definitive explanation of how he died or where his remains are.
“Although I can present a scenario that will explain the circumstances surrounding Pvt. Goempel’s disappearance, 10 years later, I am still plagued with the question, ‘What ever happened to Private Frederick W. Goempel?’ ” her website says.
Pvt. Goempel was born in East Liberty and his family later moved to West Homestead, where he grew up on a farm as the oldest of nine. After graduating from Central Catholic, he was drafted in 1944 and served with Company F, 11th Infantry Regiment, 5th Infantry Division.
During the crossing of the Sauer, a deadly affair that saw many GIs die, he was seen entering an assault boat. It’s not clear if he made it across. The river was raging and many men drowned. But a witness recalled that a replacement soldier stepped on a land mine on the other side of the river and was killed.
Ms. Geisler’s research indicates that all replacement soldiers who joined the unit on Feb. 5 have been accounted for except Fred. What’s more, the other Company F soldiers who perished died of shrapnel wounds, not drowning.
She feels certain that Fred Goempel died in the minefield. “He could still be there,” she said. “I think he’s lying in that field.”
Searching for Sam
One day 40 years ago, when Jim Minear was 10, he was playing at his grandparents’ house in Stowe when he spotted a model of a World War II bomber on the mantel.
He took it down and started playing with it.
“My grandmother started screaming at me,” he recalls. “She started crying. Then she told me the story.”
The plane had been a gift from her younger brother, Sam Williams, before he shipped off for England with the 8th Air Force.
His plane, a B-17 called the Towering Titan, was lost over Germany in April 1945, just a week before the war ended.
Sam’s wife, parents and sisters never knew his fate.
“I promised her then that I would find out,” said Mr. Minear, now 50 and living in Stowe.
His grandmother, Sarah, died in 2001 before he could. But Mr. Minear kept his promise. Today he finally has some answers and is hoping to get more when he attends Saturday’s meeting.
His great-uncle Sam was a ball turret gunner aboard the Towering Titan, which was a victim of one of Germany’s wonder weapons during a bombing run against the rail yards in Dresden.
On April 17, 1945, a swarm of Messerschmitt 262s, the world’s first jet fighter, descended on the B-17s heading to Dresden. During the fighting, one of the jets rammed into the Titan, sending it plunging to earth.
The radio operator, Sgt. Walter McClellan, 19, managed to parachute out. Sam and the others went down with the plane, which crashed into a quarry near Babisnau, south of Dresden.
Mr. Minear knows the story, thanks to help from several German citizens who researched the wreck, but for years he knew nothing despite sending letters to the Pentagon trying to find out. “I never got a response,” he said.
It wasn’t until 2003 when Mr. Minear’s mother saw a letter to the editor in the local community newspaper from a German citizen inquiring about Sam Williams.
Matthias Schildbach, who lives near Dresden, had researched the crash after another local historian, Horst Giegling, located the wreckage of a B-17 in 1999. Mr. Giegling had found a police document from 1947 in the Dresden archives that discussed the crash of a bomber in Babisnau on April 17, 1945. After locating the site, he contacted the U.S. Army, which he said visited the site and recovered parts of the plane and bone fragments.
Although two other B-17s reportedly went down in that area on the same day, Mr. Schildbach believed this one was the Towering Titan and began trying to find families of the crew.
He found some, but not the family of Sgt. Williams. Jim Minear didn’t have much information to provide, but began emailing back and forth with Mr. Schildbach. He also traveled to DPMO meetings in Chicago, St. Louis and Boston, in the hopes of persuading JPAC to visit Germany and look for remains based on Mr. Schildbach’s information.
He said he was rebuffed at one meeting, with an official dismissing people in Germany such as Mr. Schildbach as “glory-seekers and relic-hunters.”
JPAC did travel to the area to recover the remains of Sgt. McClellan, however.
Following the war, according to DPMO, U.S. teams tried to locate the Towering Titan but couldn’t gain access because the area was under Soviet control.
But two reports from German citizens in 1956 and 2007 indicated that the remains of one airman were buried as an “unknown” in a church cemetery in Burkhardswalde.
Church records showed the grave held the remains of a flyer who parachuted from his plane over Biensdorf. He had been captured and executed by the SS near Burkhardswalde, then buried in a sports field. Local townspeople later exhumed the body and reburied it next to the church.
In 2008, JPAC exhumed the grave and, using dental records, identified the remains of Sgt. McClellan. In 2010, they were repatriated to his hometown of Pensacola, Fla.
But what about the rest of the crew? Jim Minear said his great-uncle deserves to be brought home, too.
Sgt. Williams — “Sammy” to his family — grew up on Banksville Avenue in Banksville and became a plumber’s apprentice after high school. In 1943, at age 20, he volunteered for the war effort and served with the 305th Bomb Group.
At 5-foot-2, he was a perfect fit for the cramped compartment of the ball turret, which hung from the underside of a B-17. He was so small that the Army had trouble finding shoes for him.
On April 17, 1945, he took off aboard the Towering Titan, one of 1,000 bombers heading to Dresden.
As flak filled the sky and the first planes dropped their bombs on the rail depot, 30 Me-262 jet fighters attacked. American P-51 Mustangs engaged the faster jets as best they could.
According to the 2006 book “Journey to Sunset” by Michael Alan Todd, which tells the story of co-pilot Earl Holly Boyd, a jet rammed the Titan and ripped off one of its wings. The ship crashed into the quarry and exploded.
A 15-year-old German boy, Eberhard Preusser, saw the crash. Later he and other villagers retrieved the remains of the crew and buried them nearby in an unmarked grave.
Jim Minear believes the remains are still there.
A crew member on another plane later sent Sam’s personal items home to his parents in Banksville, but Mr. Minear said Sam’s family never knew what happened to him. His wife, Josephine, and their young son moved to Alabama after the war, and she remarried.
For many years, the family held out hope that he was a POW. Sarah, his sister, believed he was held captive by the Soviets, because Kreischa was part of East Germany after the war.
The site of the unmarked grave is on private property today. Mr. Minear has been told by Mr. Schildbach that the landowner will not give permission to let anyone dig there.
DPMO said last week that it is in communication with local officials about how best to proceed.
Should JPAC excavate the site, Mr. Minear would like Sam’s remains buried at Mt. Lebanon Cemetery.
Where is Stan Pittman?
In June 1946, with the war over and her son Stanley still missing, Gertrude Pittman of rural O’Hara sent an anguished letter to the wife of another missing man.
Both were aboard a C-47 transport that disappeared in Burma in August 1944, one of some 600 planes that crashed or went missing while flying the famous “Hump” over the Himalayas from India into China.
“I cannot think that my son is really gone, if I only knew what happened, but maybe it is better we don’t know,” she said. Gertrude died in 1985 without discovering Stan’s fate.
But now a distant relative and her husband are taking up the cause to bring his remains home.
“It just tore me apart that his mother died never knowing what happened to him,” said Colleen Dionisi, 52, a nurse in Blairsville.
Stan’s mother was a sister of Colleen’s grandmother.
She and her husband, Russ, 55, know little about Stan but plan to attend the DPMO meeting hoping to find out more.
In 2011, out of the blue, an Army genealogist called Colleen to ask her for a DNA sample. Until then, she and Russ had heard about Stan only in passing at family functions.
In 2003, a Burmese villager had discovered the wreck of a C-47 and material correlated to two crew members of the seven that were aboard. JPAC investigated in 2004 and recovered remains, wreckage and cargo.
JPAC and the Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory identified one of the men as Oneal Rush, an Army Corps of Engineers technician from South Carolina, by matching his mitochondrial DNA to that of his niece.
His remains were returned to his hometown last year.
The plane departed Shingbwiyang, Burma, on its way to Myitkyina, hauling jeeps and other supplies, but it never arrived. One witness reported seeing one of its engines on fire.
Soon after the war, according to DPMO, the Army searched for the wreckage but couldn’t find it. A military review board in 1945 declared the crew members presumed dead and non-recoverable.
The six other crew members remain unidentified, but one of them is certainly Stan Pittman.
Russ Dionisi said he’s been stymied in trying to find information from the military. He said he asked for Stan’s Individual Deceased Personnel File through a Freedom of Information request but hasn’t received an answer. When he asked for other records, he was told they were lost in a fire at the National Personnel Records Center in St. Louis in the 1970s.
But the Post-Gazette was able to supply the IDPF within a few days, courtesy of Ted Darcy’s private research group.
The file sheds little light on Stan, and not much is known about him. Born in 1921 in O’Hara, he graduated from high school and entered the Army Air Forces in 1942, serving as a ground-based radio operator in India for 18 months before transferring to Burma to become a radio operator on transports.
He was a slight man at 5-foot-6 and 142 pounds, and in her 1946 letter, his mother included a snapshot of him in uniform and lamented that he looked “so little and thin.”
Records indicate he flew 25 missions and received the Purple Heart and the Distinguished Flying Cross.
DPMO said last week that the Pittman case is on its master excavation list but that the government does not currently have access to the site from the host nation.
If Stan’s remains are returned, Russ Dionisi said he would like them to be buried at the National Cemetery of the Alleghenies in Cecil.
“Somebody needs to do right by him,” he said. “He has no one else who remembers him.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.