Common sense triumphed in his informal assessment hearing, property owner Ed Elliott said on Tuesday.

Mr. Elliott and his business partner, Jeff Basch, were in the first group of 4,600 Allegheny County property owners to learn the results of their initial challenges to new valuations. About 57 percent of property owners received reductions as a result of their informal appeals, according to an analysis of figures by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

"It's good news," Mr. Elliott said of the county's decision to reduce the assessment on the large apartment building he and Mr. Basch own.

A hearing officer recommended and the independent Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review confirmed reducing the value on Penn Commons from $7.65 million to $3.65 million. Penn Commons, located in the 500 block of Penn Avenue, Downtown, serves as private student housing.

Advertise with us

The partners acquired the structure in January 2010 for $3.55 million so the revised assessment now closely tracks their purchase price.

The county's Office of Property Assessment mailed out decisions to 4,633 property owners late last week.

Of the total mailed out, 1,851, or 40 percent, saw no change.

There were 140, or 3 percent, who saw their assessments go up. The remaining 2,642, or 57 percent, ended up with lower property values following their hearings.

The average decrease in assessed value among all the 4,080 residential properties was 7 percent. The pre-hearing average value of $120,707 dropped to $111,786 in that group.

Advertise with us

The average decrease among the 473 commercial properties was a heftier 24 percent, dropping from an average of $821,923 to $626,939.

The average decrease among 80 properties classified as agricultural, governmental or industrial was nearly 17 percent, dropping from an average of $474,600 to $396,079.

The average decrease among all properties after informal hearings was 15 percent.

The United Steelworkers, which has its headquarters at Stanwix Street and Boulevard of the Allies, saw the new assessment on its building decline from $25.5 million to $18.05 million following its informal appeal.

The USW, however, has filed a formal appeal and intends to continue its efforts to get the taxable value of its property reduced further, a spokesman for the union said.

Advertise with us

Assessments on nearby buildings vary greatly. The PNC Center, at Stanwix and Fort Pitt Boulevard, is valued at $52 million, while the former Verizon building, across the street from the USW headquarters, is assessed at $7.5 million.

Residential property owners who saw significant decreases in their assessed values via informal appeals were reluctant to comment on their new valuations, saying they did not want to jeopardize their upcoming formal appeals.

Edward Friedman said he was pleased with the 23 percent assessment reduction that resulted from his informal appeal. But at $984,200, the revised value for his Squirrel Hill home remained above that of similar properties in his neighborhood, he said.

He still plans to pursue a formal appeal, basing his case for further reduction on 2011 comparable sales.

The new property values, resulting from the court-ordered reassessment, will not take effect until 2013 to allow opportunities for many of the appeals to be heard.

Advertise with us

While the deadline for requesting informal hearings has passed, property owners have until Monday to file a formal challenge to their new assessments.

More than 10,000 informal hearings have been held thus far with as many as 48,000 to go.

About 21,000 property owners have requested formal appeals, but some of those may be dropped if owners are satisfied with the results of their informal hearings.

Approval of changes in real estate values by the appeals board was needed because the new values already had been formally approved by the county's Office of Property Assessment.

The more traditional procedure is for informal hearings to take place before new values are certified, so they can serve as a final check on the accuracy of the reassessment results.

After the county fell far behind on the timetable for completing the property revaluation, the judge overseeing the project ordered that certified values be sent out before the informal hearings.