Despite an expenditure of $11 million, many of Allegheny County's property assessments still seem out of whack.

Final countywide numbers released Monday show overall that property increased in value about 35 percent, from $64.2 billion to $86.9 billion. But the court-ordered project didn't seem to accomplish its goal of eliminating the disparity of stable or rising property values in poor communities and values rising more slowly in richer communities.

Details for northern and western suburbs released Monday continued that trend.

Aggregate values in wealthier communities, such as Fox Chapel and Glen Osborne, have risen less than the county average, while some less affluent municipalities, such as Sharpsburg and Leetsdale, have outpaced the county increase.

Advertise with us

The assessed values of properties in Fox Chapel rose 22 percent; in Glen Osborne, 24 percent; in Sharpsburg, 41 percent; and in Leetsdale, 42 percent. Both Fox Chapel and Sharpsburg are part of the Fox Chapel Area School District, while students from Glen Osborne and Leetsdale attend Quaker Valley schools.

County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, a longtime foe of reassessment, called the data on north and west property values "more of the same -- and maybe even worse."

"We've already spent all this taxpayer money on reassessment and improved nothing," he said. "Now we will spend more taxpayer money hearing appeals, and taxpayers will have to spend their own money on lawyers and getting appraisals."

Attorney Donald Driscoll, who filed one of the lawsuits that led to the reassessment, said he questioned results that show that property values in Fox Chapel appear to have dropped since 2005. The county had reassessed properties that year, but then-county Executive Dan Onorato rejected those results.

The 2005 numbers showed Fox Chapel's aggregate residential property value had jumped 26 percent since 2002, Mr. Driscoll said. The current assessment, covering from 2002 to 2011, put the increase for residential property at 21 percent, meaning that values would have declined in more recent years.

Advertise with us

Mr. Driscoll said comparison of the 2005 and 2012 numbers found many similar unlikely reversals in value.

Such disproportionate increases in assessments in some communities raises questions about the accuracy of the revaluation project, said Mr. Driscoll. After asking weeks ago, he has finally received a dozen different kinds of assessment information to allow an outside consultant to do a preliminary analysis of the results.

That independent review should be completed in days rather than weeks, he said.

Should that review turn up systematic problems affecting streets or entire neighborhoods, Mr. Driscoll said he hoped county officials would make changes to improve the fairness of the reassessment without waiting for a court order. The state Supreme Court has assigned Common Pleas Court Senior Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. to oversee reassessment, and he has been meeting regularly with county officials for updates on the project.

The overall numbers show the value of property in the city of Pittsburgh rose 56 percent, from $13.6 billion to $21.2 billion, compared to 35 percent for the county as a whole.

Advertise with us

All those numbers are guaranteed to change after as many as 100,000 property owners challenge their new values. New assessment numbers will not be used until 2013, allowing time for both informal and formal appeals to be heard.

County council and Mr. Fitzgerald's office have been sponsoring town hall sessions around the county to answer questions about reassessment.

"We are getting hundreds of people coming to each of these meetings, and they are upset and stressed," he said.

Since Mr. Fitzgerald and his predecessor have been unsuccessful in stopping the reassessment, he is trying to persuade the state Legislature to set statewide standards for assessment. There has been little action at the state level.

The county hired an outside firm, Cole Layer Trumbell, to carry out the reassessment. The consultant, a unit of Tyler Technologies, used two dozen algorithms, or mathematical formulas, to set property values.

Advertise with us

Dominic Gambino, a former manager of the county's Office of Property Assessment, speculated that extremely low real estate values in some poorer communities had thrown off the models. Mr. Gambino is president of a consulting firm called Diversified Municipal Services.

Some algorithms were designed to reject all sales under $10,000, a move that could result in over-assessment in lower-income municipalities where such prices were possible but may never have been considered, he said.