BERGHOLZ, Ohio -- This village, 30 miles northwest of Steubenville, has a population of about 700, one traffic light and no cell phone service.

Signs at either end of town welcome visitors to the village of "Wooded Hills, Warm Hearts," founded in 1883.

The town has a few shops, a funeral home, a restaurant and a post office.

This bucolic place has something else, too: It's the home of Sam Mullet, 66, a man described by some locals as a cult leader of a splinter sect of Amish whose feuds with other Amish have required the intervention of law enforcement and focused the glare of national media on this quiet farm country.

Advertise with us

Ohio authorities have charged five men, all believed to be acting on the orders of Mr. Mullet, in a beard-cutting attack on an Amish man in Holmes County.

Charged are Eli M. Miller, 32; Daniel S. Mullet, 37; Johnny Mullet, 38; Lester Mullet, 26; and Levi Miller, 53. Johnny and Lester are Sam Mullet's sons.

All are free after Sam Mullet posted their bond Wednesday.

On Oct. 4, authorities said, they broke into the home of a 74-year-old Amish man and tied him to a chair, cutting his beard with scissors and clippers. In the Amish world, cutting a man's beard is more than an assault -- it's a symbolic degradation.

Jefferson County Sheriff Fred Abdalla and his counterparts in at least two other Ohio counties are investigating whether the group was involved in a series of similar attacks on Amish that have taken place since the beginning of September.

Advertise with us

Mr. Mullet has not been charged, but the sheriff and other authorities believe he orchestrated the attacks in retaliation against Amish leaders who have excommunicated him over the way he runs his church.

Some in the community were not surprised to hear Mr. Mullet being criticized as a patriarchal ringleader.

"It obviously was a scare tactic," said one Bergholz native, who asked that his name not be used, on a recent afternoon. "Everyone says he's pretty controlling. He pretty much does what he wants to do. You hear stories that if someone doesn't do what he wants, they end up out in the shed, tied up."

Another man added: "A lot of Amish down here don't consider them [Amish] and don't deal with them."

Just outside of the town limits on County Road 53, about 25 school-age children played softball with teachers in a pasture outside the Amish schoolhouse where members of the Mullet community are educated.

Advertise with us

The children and teachers were clad in traditional Amish garb -- the girls and women in blue or tan dresses and white bonnets, the boys in jeans and suspenders. Two black horses grazed in the outfield.

A sign at the next road announces a "Country Bulk Food and Variety Store" and "Firewood." Up that dirt road there are houses, barns, outbuildings and pastures, all part of the Mullet compound where about 18 families, virtually all of them related, live and work.

Past a barn with horses and a cow is Mr. Mullet's white farmhouse.

Many here are skittish about dealing with the outside world, especially reporters. One young woman walking toward the farmhouse said only that Mr. Mullet isn't home, then continued walking, her head down.

Across from the house is a two-story utility building where horses whinnied in stalls, black buggies awaited hitching and cords of firewood were stacked.

Advertise with us

Just inside, Edward Mast, Mr. Mullet's grandson, slowly stirred gray paint in a can. He said Mr. Mullet would be back but couldn't say when and couldn't say more. He was friendly but guarded.

Twenty black birds circled over the compound as a baby cried from inside the farmhouse. A woman's voice broke into song. The baby's cries ceased.

About three hours later, Mr. Mullet returned home with the person who drove him to Steubenville. Standing in his doorway, he took up nearly the entire frame, his snow-white beard extending about 8 inches from his chin. He didn't want to talk about the attacks.

"Not interested," he said. "No comment."

A day earlier, though, he'd spoken about the incidents. He told The Associated Press he didn't order the hair-cutting, but didn't stop the five men from carrying it out.

Advertise with us

He said the goal was to send a message to Amish leaders in Holmes County that they should be ashamed of themselves for the way they were treating Mr. Mullet and his community.

"They changed the rulings of our church here, and they're trying to force their way down our throat, make us do like they want us to do, and we're not going to do that. We know what we did and why we did it," he said. "We excommunicated some members here because they didn't want to obey the rules of the church."

He said he moved the members of his group about 100 miles from Richland County to their current hilly farm country area in 1995 just to be by themselves. He bristled at the suggestion that he is a cult leader. "We're not a cult," he said. "We're just trying to live a peaceful life."

He said he should be allowed to punish people who break the laws of the church, just as police are allowed to punish people who break the laws of the state.

"You have your laws on the road and the town -- if somebody doesn't obey them, you punish them. But I'm not allowed to punish the church people?" he said. "I just let them run over me? If every family would just do as they pleased, what kind of church would we have?"

Advertise with us

Mr. Mullet also leveled complaints against Sheriff Abdalla. The two men, leaders in their respective communities, have clashed many times over the years.

It was the sheriff who prosecuted Mr. Mullet's son, Crist, in 2006 for having sex with a 13-year-old girl. Crist, who is married and has three children, pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2008 to six months in jail.

And it was Sheriff Abdalla who, enforcing a child-custody order, removed the children of Mr. Mullet's daughter, Wilma, from the Bergholz compound in 2007 with the help of a SWAT team. Sheriff Abdalla says the precaution was necessary because of Sam Mullet's hold on the community.

He said Friday that the current beard-cutting attacks are further evidence of Mr. Mullet's power.

"There is no doubt that this guy is in charge," he said.

Advertise with us

The sheriff said he had long heard rumors of abuses at the Bergholz compound at Sam Mullet's direction and has been frustrated in investigating some of them because followers will not testify.

In one case from 2009, he learned that a man had been imprisoned in a chicken coop in the middle of winter for 15 days.

Sheriff Abdalla said the man told him that Sam Mullet had ordered him held in the coop but he refused to testify, saying he had challenged "the Bishop" in a dispute and so deserved to be punished.

"I couldn't prosecute," the sheriff said.

He also said Mr. Mullet's influence over followers was manifest in the custody dispute between his daughter, Wilma, and her husband, Aden Troyer.

Advertise with us

The pair married in 2004 and separated in 2006 after Wilma complained that Mr. Troyer was forcing her into sex acts and making her his "slave." She also indicated that she'd had a religious "vision" in which Mr. Troyer had been sexually abused by his mother, according to divorce papers.

When she told her father, according to the records, Mr. Mullet refused to allow Mr. Troyer to see his wife and their first daughter, Mattie.

Mr. Troyer said Mr. Mullet then forced him to "confess to sexual contact with his mother in order to see his wife and young child again," according to a summary of the case in an Ohio appellate court. "Aden then wrote a letter to that effect and was taken to publicly confess his actions to the Bishop of the Ulysses, Pa., Amish community" where Mr. Troyer lived.

Mr. Troyer later recanted in court and said he only wrote the confession to "make peace with Samuel Mullet" and be reunited with his family.

Sheriff Abdalla investigated the incest allegations, including testing Mr. Troyer with a polygraph machine, and said he found them to be untrue.

Advertise with us

"I asked him, 'Why the hell would you write a confession like that?' " Sheriff Abdalla said. "He said because Sam told him to."

The custody battle only grew uglier, requiring more involvement from law enforcement. In early May 2007, sheriff's deputies removed Wilma, Mattie and a second daughter, 3-month-old Linda, from the Bergholz compound.

The couple reunited briefly and moved to the state of Indiana for counseling sessions, then to the Amish community in Ulysses in Potter County. While there, Wilma's brother, Eli Mullet, and cousin, Eli Miller, broke into Mr. Troyer's parents' home in an attempt to find Wilma, according to court papers, and Eli Mullet also assaulted Mr. Troyer's father. Sheriff's deputies in Potter County arrested both men.

Wilma Mullet's sisters convinced her to return to Bergholz with the children, and she asked Mr. Troyer to come with her. Sam Mullet told Mr. Troyer, "You know we ain't going to take you down there and throw you in a manure pit," according to court records.

Mr. Troyer took that as a threat and stayed in Ulysses, but he later filed a motion to take custody of the children. A judge granted him custody, and on Sept. 14, 2007, Sheriff Abdalla returned to Bergholz with the SWAT team. The sheriff served the order on Wilma while she was teaching in the one-room schoolhouse and took her children away.

That action triggered two lawsuits brought by the Mullets, one in Jefferson County and one in federal court in Columbus.