Getting an appraisal on your house is no sure ticket to a lower assessment, an Allegheny County judge ruled Thursday.
Striking down a class action lawsuit before it got off the ground, Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. ruled last week the county doesn't have to accept a homeowner's appraisal that it doesn't trust, even if it's the only document admitted in an assessment appeals hearing.
"The property owner looks to the hearing officer, a person with residential valuation expertise, for an unbiased evaluation of the homeowner's testimony and submissions," he wrote. "The law does not support the contention that a hearing officer must accept the appraiser's value when this is the only value offered."
The ruling deep-sixes the suit filed by 11 Allegheny County property owners, who said they gave legitimate appraisals to an assessment hearing officer, only to see their assessments stay the same.
They said their appraisals weren't contested by any taxing body -- be it their town, the school district or the county -- who often didn't even send a lawyer to the hearing.
The suit had the promise of an unlikely Cinderella story -- a group of taxpayers left behind by the system, only to prevail in the courts.
If Judge Wettick had ruled in their favor, it's possible every property owner who filed an uncontested appraisal, even those who didn't file suit, would have seen their taxes drop.
But the plaintiffs based their appeal on faulty legal logic, citing a similar case in 2001 that held up in lower court but was upended by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, Judge Wettick ruled.
If a hearing officer doesn't find an appraisal credible, he doesn't have to accept it, he said.
Indeed, if approved, the suit would mean government agencies could surreptitiously file appraisals without notifying the taxpayers -- and receiving an automatic increased assessment in return, the judge wrote.
"Property owners should not be so severely disadvantaged because they have not hired an expert to rebut the appraisal of the taxing body," he wrote.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs could not be reached for comment. County solicitor Andrew Szefi said the property owners could still appeal the decision, although their chance to appeal their assessment has long since passed.
"We've already extended the period a year," he said. "So I think at this point, there's no further point to extend it out further."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.