As many as 300,000 Allegheny County property owners could see new, lower real estate values if the judge overseeing reassessment agrees that the original results continue to discriminate against people in poorer neighborhoods.

The new assessed values, which have resulted in more than 100,000 appeals, show mathematical bias against lower-valued properties, attorney Don Driscoll told Common Pleas Court Senior Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. today. Properties in wealthier communities like Churchill remain relatively undervalued for tax purposes, while real estate in places like Braddock is assessed at a much higher rate, Mr. Driscoll said after the court hearing.

Revised lower assessments should be sent out to as many as half of property owners to reduce the "regressivity" in the original numbers, he urged. New numbers could be prepared and sent out within a week, he estimated.

County solicitor Andrew Szefi disagreed. He told the judge that the county had done everything the state Supreme Court had asked in carrying out the reassessment. New property values met International Association of Assessing Officers fairness requirements for the county as a whole, he said.

Advertise with us

Judge Wettick said he would consider Mr. Driscoll's proposal and rule later but set no date for announcing his decision. Judge Wettick has been overseeing reassessment since the state Supreme Court ordered Allegheny County to revalue all real estate.

The county is facing a Dec. 17 deadline for calculating the new aggregate value for real estate in school districts and municipalities. Taxing bodies need to know those values in order to set their millage rates for 2013, when the new numbers are to take effect.

Mr. Driscoll represented some of the original property owners who sued the county, successfully arguing that the 2002 base-year numbers used for assessment discriminated against people living in poorer neighborhoods.