Informal appeals of new property assessments -- which resulted in changes in about half the cases heard -- worked the way they were supposed to, a top Allegheny County administrator says.
Deputy county manager Steve Pilarski said the informal process allowed property owners to modify incorrect information in descriptions of their real estate. They also were able to present evidence indicating that the certified assessments assigned to their properties were too high, he said. Those would include such things as a certified appraisal or recent sales of similar properties nearby.
Dominick Gambino, a former manager of the county's property assessment office, said the 50 percent rate for changes following informal appeals sounded about right. "The in-house assessors are experienced and good, and they understand the area," he said.
The county this week sent out the results from the last of the informal appeals. Slightly fewer than half of the 59,000 residential property owners who challenged their new assessments won a reduction. Owners of commercial properties did better, with 70 percent of the 5,357 who appealed getting a reduction from the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review.
Property owners who were not satisfied with the results of their informal hearings had 30 days from the time they received their decisions to make formal appeals.
The overall effect of informal appeals has been to reduce the assessed value of all property in the county by $1.6 billion. That number represents less than 2 percent of the $86.9 billion aggregate value assigned to all taxable real estate as a result of reassessment.
The effect of what could be more than 100,000 formal appeals, however, is yet to be known. The results of those challenges are to be approved by the appeals board by Dec. 17.
A higher assessment does not automatically translate into higher property taxes. Once the new assessments are certified, the county, municipalities and school districts will be required under state law to recalculate their millage rates for next year to avoid any windfall gains from higher property values.
Taxing bodies, however, still will have the option of taking separate votes to raise millages, within limits, to cover higher costs for 2013.
Traditionally, informal appeals are made before new real-estate values are certified by the county's Office of Property Assessments. Those appeals are designed to catch errors missed by the mass-appraisal process, Mr. Pilarski said.
Reassessment crews were supposed to walk or drive by every one of the almost 600,000 properties in the county but would be able to spend only about three to five minutes at each address, county officials estimated. They were to compare what they saw on those visits to the information property owners provided on questionnaires the county mailed to their homes.
"We didn't get inside every property," Mr. Pilarski said. "So if our data is wrong about a home having a fireplace or the number of bedrooms or bathrooms, that information can be corrected [via the informal appeals]."
Daniel Bonenberger, who lives in Greenfield, was among the last people to find out the results of his informal appeals on two properties. The new value on one house was lowered while the appeals board left the assessment on the other unchanged.
"What's interesting is I got letters from two different lawyers offering to represent me [in formal appeals] before I got the results from the county," he said. "It's like the lawyers knew the results before I did."
Some law firms did make right-to-know requests asking for the names of property owners who had challenged their new values, Mr. Pilarski said. With the appeals board meeting only once every two weeks to certify batches of assessment changes, attorneys sometimes were able to get out their letters offering help before the county sent results, he said.
Common Pleas Senior Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr., who is overseeing reassessment under the direction of the state Supreme Court, has given the county until Dec. 17 to provide a final and revised roll of property values. They will replace 2002 base-year numbers in calculating 2013 property taxes.
Mr. Pilarski said the county is on schedule to complete formal appeals and have all numbers certified to make that deadline. David Montgomery, solicitor for the appeals board, said he, too, believed the judge's deadline for resolving assessment challenges would be met.
Now that so many homeowners have gotten their new assessments reduced through informal challenges, Mr. Gambino predicted that as many as 30 percent would withdraw their formal appeals or simply fail to show up. He based his estimate in part on the county's experience in 2002 when about 25 percent of the 100,000 appeals were dropped.
Mr. Gambino, who runs a consulting firm called Diversified Municipal Services Inc., has represented friends and relatives in informal appeals this time. He said he was impressed by the professionalism and neighborhood knowledge of the county's in-house hearing officers. "They know the differences between Rankin and Forest Hills," he said.
Property owners who decide not to pursue formal challenges should send a withdrawal letter to the appeals board, Mr. Montgomery said. They also can use a withdrawal form available on the "property appeals forms" page of the county website, alleghenycounty.us/opa/.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.