An independent analysis of Allegheny County's $11 million reassessment has found that numbers for Pittsburgh and two other school districts do not meet international property valuation standards.

Assessment expert Robert C. Denne reached that conclusion in a report he prepared for one of the lawyers who sued the county to force real estate revaluation.

Attorney Don Driscoll, one of the attorneys who filed the case that led to reassessments, said problems the consultant identified in Pittsburgh, Clairton and Duquesne indicate there should be adjustments across the county. Today he asked the judge overseeing reassessment to order the county to correct the problems by adjusting assessed values downward for as many as two-thirds of residential property owners.

Mr. Driscoll filed his motion on behalf of his original clients, two property owners who believed their homes in less affluent communities had become relatively overvalued over time.

Advertise with us

"We have preliminary indications that the results of the reassessment disfavor lower-value communities," he said today. The certified values scheduled to go into effect in 2013 failed to eliminate the "regressivity" that had residents in poorer communities paying a disproportionate share of property taxes.

The problem could be corrected before the Dec. 17 deadline for the county to provide a "final and revised roll" of assessment numbers to be used to calculate 2013 property taxes, his motion said.