The fears and frustrations of a community under fire ran headlong into the good intentions of Pittsburgh’s new police chief during Tuesday night’s public safety committee meeting in Hazelwood, as questions and conversation at times turned to shouts and accusations.

Chief Cameron McLay, acting chief since Sept. 11, told community members concerned about recent shootings including one on Monday in broad daylight that left 22-year-old Marcus Critten dead and raised questions about how quickly emergency crews responded that the police needed the public’s help to solve crimes, curb problems and make the neighborhood safer.

How are you going to protect people who speak out? Because people die when they speak out, stated one of the written questions submitted from an audience member to the eight-person panel of city officials in the auditorium of the former Burgwin Elementary School on Glenwood Avenue.

“Pittsburgh has a model witness protection program,” Mr. McLay said, as several women in the back of the room began protesting, “No they don’t, no they don’t, it’s terrible.”

Advertise with us

The chief continued, “There has never been anyone who has availed themselves of the witness protection program that has been harmed.”

“You’re delusional, delusional!” said Rhonda Barry of Hazelwood.

All due respect, but she had known a young woman who had died just like that, said the Rev. Rena Fuller, pastor of Morningstar Baptist Church in West Mifflin and a leader of the Hazelwood safety committee.

“The same day she testified, the next night she was dead,” Ms. Fuller said.

Emotions are running high in a neighborhood that has seen a recent uptick in shootings, drug activity and property damage, although Mr. Critten’s killing was the only homicide in the past two years for Zone 4, which includes Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, North and South Point Breeze, Swisshelm Park, Hazelwood and Glenwood.

Advertise with us

Worries that Mr. Critten waited unusually long for an ambulance to get to the scene of his shooting in Glen Hazel near Johnston Avenue inflamed those concerns. City officials confirmed Tuesday that it took some emergency responders longer than average to arrive.

It remained unclear, however, whether a quicker response from Pittsburgh's Emergency Medical Services bureau would have saved Mr. Critten’s life. He was shot in the trunk multiple times. Allegheny County medical examiner Karl Williams said he did not have the specifics of Mr. Critten’s injuries on Tuesday night and thus declined comment.

Bureau statistics show that on average it takes 7 minutes for an ambulance to arrive at a high-priority call such as a shooting, Pittsburgh public safety spokeswoman Sonya Toler said.

On Monday, 12 minutes elapsed between the time the first ambulance was dispatched to the shooting near Johnston Avenue and Roselle Street and the time the first ambulance arrived, according to information Ms. Toler provided at the request of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

The response time was longer than typical, Ms. Toler said, because the closest available medic units were far away, one at UPMC Mercy and the other in Homewood’s western section.

Advertise with us

She said dispatchers sent the closest possible units and that call volume at that time was normal, although she did not have a specific number of calls.

For some who knew Mr. Critten and his friend who was injured, it felt much longer, and it was a delay that was too long.

“Marcus lay there, still alive, and the ambulance took so long to get here, and that’s not uncommon in places like this,” said Azia Lindsay, the mother of Mr. Critten’s 5-year-old daughter, late Monday.

Ms. Lindsay wondered whether other factors, such as race, might have affected the paramedic response. Mr. Critten was African-American.

“If it was somebody in a high-rise, somebody older having an asthma attack, they would have been there in five minutes,” she said. “I don’t want to be racist or nothing, but if that was somebody white, they would have been there. They look at [it] like, ‘OK, they’re out here killing each other. We’ll get there when we get there.’ And that’s the reality of how they’re looking at it.”

Advertise with us

The president of the Pittsburgh paramedics union did not respond to a call Tuesday night.

Pittsburgh police continued Tuesday to search for two masked men who were seen getting out of a car Monday morning on Johnston Avenue and shooting Mr. Critten and his friend.

New details emerged Tuesday about the victim’s previous arrests. Mr. Critten was sentenced in January 2013 to three months of probation after a 2011 incident in which police said he twisted his sister’s arm and hit her in the face with a TV remote.

He was charged in August 2012 with assault and other crimes after police said he hit his then-girlfriend, pushed her to the floor and then threw a brick through the window of the house she was inside. Court records indicate those charges were withdrawn after the victim did not appear in court on three separate hearing dates.

Mr. Critten was charged the next year with kidnapping after police found him in a car with a man whose relative had received a text message indicating the man had been kidnapped, according to a criminal complaint. The victim in that case told police he texted with Mr. Critten that night about hanging out, and Mr. Critten sent him a location where they should meet and where two men jumped him. One had held a gun to his chest. Court records indicate a judge dismissed those charges after Mr. Critten’s defense attorney objected to a continuance in the case.

Advertise with us

Some people, however, remembered Mr. Critten as a loving father who was trying to recruit others for a program aimed at reducing violence in Glen Hazel and whom they described as trying to make up for past mistakes.

Efforts such as those and city initiatives to move more police officers to patrol the streets on foot so they can develop relationships and sources in the community, additional security cameras to catch criminals in the act and additional enforcement of laws that speed the process of evicting drug-dealing tenants and force nuisance properties to clean up or close can help Hazelwood and Glen Hazel fulfill their great potential, said Councilman Corey O’Connor.

Hazelwood has heard too many empty promises for too many years, and it’s time now to act, he said.

“You are the eyes and ears, and we are going to do a better job of protecting you, from the police department on down,” Mr. O’Connor said, to applause. “No more promises, we are getting there, and I want that to be the mentality of everyone before they leave this room.”

Staff writer Dan Majors contributed. Amy Schaarsmith: aschaarsmith@post-gazette.com. Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com.

Correction, posted Oct. 15, 2014: In an earlier version of this story, Councilman Corey O’Connor’s last name was misspelled.