John Adams, the second president of the newly formed United States of America, would have been proud of Pittsburgh’s celebration of Independence Day.

After signing the Declaration of Independence, Adams wrote to his wife Abigail that the day should be celebrated with “pomp and parade,” guns, bells, bonfires and illuminations “from one end of this Continent to the other, from this Time forward forever more.”

But that sentiment took a while to catch on.

The founding fathers officially agreed upon the Declaration of Independence on July 2, 1776, when it was approved by 12 of the 13 colonies. It wasn’t officially signed until a month later, on Aug. 2, but it was adopted and printed on July 4, the date that became the official holiday.

Advertise with us

As the news slowly traveled through the rest of the colonies, it was met with mixed reactions – patriots celebrated with toasts, cheers and cannons, while everyone else largely ignored the news.

In short, Mr. Adams was disappointed.

“The celebration of Independence Day began very slowly in fits and starts,” said Paul Douglas Newman, a professor of history at University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown. “The Fourth of July was a muted event in places that had seen a lot of division.”

In 1776 and ‘77, a few colonies celebrated the anniversary of the Declaration of Independence with bells and bonfires. In 1778, George Washington and his troops marked the occasion with some extra rum on the battlefield. In 1781, Massachusetts became the first colony to declare the day a holiday.

“When the war ended [in 1783] you had these people who had really been at each other’s throats for seven or eight years, and those feelings did not die quickly,” Mr. Douglas Newman said. “It took until that generation began to pass before the holiday really gained traction.”

Advertise with us

At the same time, Mr. Douglas Newman said, the victory of the War of 1812 – a war with Britain over trade and territory – also bolstered the holiday because it created a sense of patriotism. This new generation felt they had “secured the revolution.”

As the new country began to take shape, and political parties began to form, the celebration of Independence Day became more monumental – and more divisive.

Historian Eric Greisinger, who teaches at Salem University, Allegheny County Community College and Westmoreland Community College, said each new party would claim they “knew best what the original intent of the founders was and what the Declaration meant.”

To make those claims, they started printing and distributing the actual document, which spurred a “review of what it originally was and how we should celebrate it.”

Those celebrations quickly took the shape of what we are used to seeing today – parades, picnics and fireworks – with some things we’re not quite as used to – bonfires, cannons, pig roasts, fife and drums and lots and lots of political toasts.

Advertise with us

The holiday didn’t lose it’s political undertones quickly, according to Andrew Simpson, a history professor at Duquesne University. From the outset, he said, it was a holiday that brought up questions of identity and citizenship.

“There’s always a political edge to the celebrations of the Fourth of July,” he said. “It becomes an issue of what the Declaration of Independence means for various people and who gets to participate in that.”

That question continued to resurface throughout American history, he said, particularly after the Civil War as people are questioning what citizenship means for freed slaves, and again as the first waves of immigrants begin to arrive.

“Over the course of the 20th century, we have less of a discussion about the Declaration of Independence itself,” Mr. Simpson said. “It’s evolved into a holiday that looks a lot different than it did at the turn of the century.”

Though the politics and discussions have changed, the celebratory tone has not.

Advertise with us

The celebrations today mirror more of what Mr. Adams, the founding fathers and the Patriots had in mind – though the illuminations are probably bigger than they ever imagined.

Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com., 412-263-1565.