A majority of North Allegheny school board members opted to raise taxes rather than cut music classes, increase class sizes and raid the fund balance to an extent that would hurt the district’s bond rating.
The school board on June 26 approved a $175.9 million budget that raises taxes by 0.6851 mills.
The new millage rate is 19.1408, which is the sixth-lowest among the 42 suburban districts in Allegheny County. North Allegheny has the largest enrollment – 8,493 – and the 14th-lowest cost-per-student in the suburbs, according to data released with the budget.
“Our spending per student is about $3,000 below the average for the districts in Allegheny County,” said board member Kevin Mahler. “We are not a middle-of-the-road school district, but we spend like one.”
The increase will cost the owner of an average home valued at $239,000 approximately $163 per year.
School directors Christopher Finley and Libby Blackburn voted no on the budget.
Mr. Finley, who has missed several meetings where the budget was discussed, asked if the millage rate could be lower. This prompted a lengthy, contentious debate where other board members asked budget opponents for alternatives.
“Explaining why you are voting 'no’ is not the same as presenting an alternative budget plan. This budget should not be as politicized as I fear it has become,” said board member Allyson Minton.
The budget includes increased debt for the $66 million bond issue to fund the expansion of Franklin Elementary, renovation of McKnight Elementary, adding turf to one field at the intermediate high school and adding restrooms to the baseball/softball field at the senior high school.
Board member Andrew Chomos, chair of the budget committee, said the district’s continued growth and safety initiatives, including adding school resource officers to the high schools, also contributed to the budget increase.
“The expansion of Franklin was very necessary. The numbers suggest enrollments that are going to near 9,000 before they dip back down again,” he said.
Also contributing are mandated increases to the state’s retirement system and increases in special education costs due to increased enrollment.
Board member Scott Russell said administrators gave the board 12 scenarios on the budget. The scenarios included eliminating orchestra lessons in third grade, raising class sizes in violation of district policy and eliminating the school resource officers.
Eliminating third-grade orchestra would result in “significant savings, but nobody on the board wanted to look at that,” Mr. Russell said. A proposal to do so two years ago resulted in significant opposition from parents and students.
Another option was raiding the district’s $21 million fund balance. The approved budget takes $2.5 million from the fund balance, and taking any more would hurt the district’s bond rating, said Mr. Mahler.
Bond rating agencies want to see a fund balance that is at least 11 percent of the budget, which would be approximately $19 million. The district’s bond rating did drop twice in the last 19 years, when the fund balance dipped below 11 percent of the budget. Roger Sechler, director of business operations, said bond agencies prefer a fund balance that is 20 percent of the budget.
Board members noted that they rejected several proposals for more spending over the last year, including adding turf to all the fields at the intermediate high school, which would have cost $8.8 million, changing high school start times, eliminating a “maker space” during the intermediate high school renovation and cut back on the number of additional counselors and nurses requested by administrators.
The entire budget can be found on the meeting agenda, which can be accessed through the school board tab on the district’s Website.
Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.