An envelope from Port Orchard, Wash., arrived at the Post-Gazette in early July containing a copy of a marriage license and a 1967 article about a local decorated Vietnam War pilot shot down over China. The sender, Robert Imani, requested a correction to the 51-year-old article.

“This information will help confirm that Mrs. Ann Marie Scott is the rightful wife of Dain V. Scott,” an attached letter read.

Mr. Imani last saw Lt. Cmdr. Scott, his cousin from West Deer, take off in his A-6A aircraft from the USS Constellation in August 1967. Mr. Imani was a seaman assigned to the same ship. The Navy pilot was headed for a bombing mission in North Vietnam when his plane was shot down over China. His remains were never recovered.

The Navy posthumously awarded Cmdr. Scott, who was a lieutenant junior grade at the time, the Distinguished Flying Cross and also promoted him.

Advertise with us

While researching his cousin, Mr. Imani, 70, found that the Post-Gazette identified Cmdr. Scott’s wife as “Gloria” in its coverage of his attack. The Pittsburgh Press listed her as “Shirley.”

Mr. Imani wanted the record to be set straight.

The details on Cmdr. Scott’s 25 years are scarce, but a paper trail of marriage licenses, Navy records and newspaper articles reveals an ambitious military career and a confusing personal life.

In 1957, Navy Chief Petty Officer Benjamin Alexander hosted a group of Boy Scouts in Washington, D.C., for the summer. That’s where his then 8-year-old daughter Ann Marie Alexander met 15-year-old Dain Vanderlin Scott.

“I was disabled, and he got Scout points for helping out my father with me,” said Mrs. Scott, now 69, who was born with a birth defect that affected her walking ability.

Advertise with us

“But the biggest thing is that he used to teach me. When daddy was busy with the other scouts, he would teach me what daddy was teaching [them].”

Mrs. Scott, who now lives in Port Orchard, Wash., said she fell in love right then, but she lost touch. Her father moved the family to Puerto Rico after he was stationed there. Cmdr. Scott returned to southwestern Pennsylvania, where he graduated from West Deer High School in 1959. He then went off to Illinois for college.

A copy of a framed photo of Ann Marie Scott and Lt. Cmdr. Dain V. Scott from 1967. (Courtesy of Ann Marie Scott)

Mrs. Scott recalls that two met again during a chance encounter at the National Naval Medical Center (now Walter Reed Medical Center) when then 14-year-old Ann returned to Washington, D.C.

“I said ‘you remember me?’ and he thought for a while, and he says ‘ma’am’ and walked away. I was so hurt,” Mrs. Scott said. “Then he turned around and whistled the tune he taught me if I ever got lost. I just ran to him, and he picked me up.”

Mrs. Scott said passionate courting ensued, including a trip to Hershey Park, after which “the roof came off the top of the house” because her mother let her cross state lines with an older boy without her father’s approval.

Advertise with us

Soon after, they were married.

“I witnessed he and Ann Marie getting married on the 17 of August 1962 in Lockport, [New York],” Mr. Imani said. “It was a secret wedding. Her mother gave her permission to marry Dain but did not want her husband to know about it.” Mr. Imani mailed the notarized marriage license to the Post-Gazette.

It was also kept secret because Mrs. Scott is African-American. Cmdr. Scott was white.

“We were interracial, so we knew that would be a problem,” Mrs. Scott said.

After the 1964 Civil Rights Act passed, they held a wedding ceremony in Lenoir, N.C., near Mrs. Scott’s grandmother’s house.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Scott remained a dependent under her parents, while Cmdr. Scott finished college and began his Navy training in Washington state.

“We weren’t going to try to live together until he got out,” Mrs. Scott said. “I went to Seattle several times. That’s how I would see him.”

They had one son, Dain Jr., who Mrs. Scott gave up for adoption.

Cmdr. Scott completed Navy flight training in the spring of 1965. He was honorably discharged on May 20 that year. The date he re-entered the Navy is unclear.

He flew several bombing missions during the summer of 1967 with Attack Squadron 196 from the USS Constellation. In June of that year, he participated in a strike on “strategic” railroad yards in Phu Ly, North Vietnam, and weeks later “flawlessly navigated his aircraft” to the same target area, according to Navy records.

Advertise with us

However, on Aug. 21, 1967, 15 miles from the Duc Noi Railroad Yard just north of Hanoi, Cmdr. Scott and three other bombardiers “came under extremely heavy and accurate anti-aircraft and surface-to-air missile fire which continued at intervals for five minutes.” They were shot down over China.

The Chicago Tribune reported that the pilots’ last radio transmission had warned of pursuing North Vietnamese jet fighters but the Pentagon could not provide further information “concerning their possible inadvertent crossing of the Chinese border.”

Several news outlets reported that the Chinese had taken one prisoner, but did not identify him.

Mrs. Scott’s mother delivered the news to her daughter. “It was hard on me when I was told that he was missing,” she said.

Still young and under the thumb of her parents — and living in the South — Mrs. Scott never saw that on Aug. 23, 1967, The Pittsburgh Press reported that Cmdr. Scott, 25, had left behind “his wife, Shirley, and their two children, Gloria, 2½, and David, 1½.”

Advertise with us

She also didn’t see the Post-Gazette’s Aug. 24 report that the Navy “notified Mr. and Mrs. Dale V. Scott, of Glasgow road, Gibsonia, that their only son was aboard one of the two jet fighters shot down Monday over China. He is Lt. (jg) Dain. V. Scott … who makes his home with his wife, Gloria, and their two young children on Whidby Island, near Seattle, Wash.”

According to Bond County, Ill., records, Cmdr. Scott wed a woman named Shirley Ann Vaughn on Nov. 13, 1963.

She died last August, and according to her obituary published online by a Greenville, Ill., funeral home, she met Cmdr. Scott at Greenville College. The couple is survived by two children, Lori Lynn Scott Friel, of Albany, N.Y., and David Craig Scott, of Las Vegas, Nev. Both declined to comment for this article.

Records from Island County, Ill., show that Shirley Ann Scott was granted a divorce from Cmdr. Scott in Dec. 1970. She remarried to a Larry Beasley and took his last name.

Navy archives show that the military branch declared Cmdr. Scott dead on Jan. 24, 1974 and the type of casualty as “Hostile - Died While Missing.”

Advertise with us

It’s not known whether Mrs. Beasley received Cmdr. Scott’s death benefits.

A marker bearing his name — Grave 174, Section MI — sits in Arlington National Cemetery, a section recognizing armed forces members whose remains were never recovered. His name appears on Panel 25E of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial.

In 2016, Blase Szwaczkowski, a local Army veteran, was reading up on the history of West Deer Township, when he came upon Lt. Cmdr. Scott’s name, one he had never seen before.

Mr. Szwaczkowski, 63, an Army specialist who served from 1973 to 1976, worked with the William Fish American Legion Post 593 to erect a memorial in 2002 containing the names of veterans from West Deer who were killed during World War II, Korea and Vietnam.

“We thought it was a shame that Dain’s name had kind of been forgotten,” said Mr. Szwaczkowski, who has been with the Legion for 42 years. “It’s just sad when these guys fall through the cracks.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Szwaczkowski began posting on online military message boards and trying to reach Cmdr. Scott’s listed family members — Shirley Beasley and the children.

That’s when Mr. Imani contacted him. Mr. Szwaczkowski asked, “How’s Shirley?”

The reply: “Who’s Shirley?”

Mr. Imani said he knew of his cousin’s “troubled ex-relationship” but didn’t realize he had married a second time.

Cmdr. Scott’s Navy documents list him as married, but do not specify to whom.

Advertise with us

Mr. Imani began digging, and that’s when he found the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh Press articles. Then came Shirley Beasley’s obituary listing her previous marriage to Cmdr. Scott.

“I was devastated. I was just really mouth hanging open ‘what, no, it couldn't be,’” Mrs. Scott said, who only learned of this in the past two years.

Mrs. Scott said that she prays about it and “does not wish to disparage Shirley.”

“To this day, we have never been legally separated or divorced. I hold to that because he may come back,” Mrs. Scott said this summer.

Mostly, she said, she is bothered that her husband has not received adequate recognition, especially in his hometown.

Advertise with us

Mr. Szwaczkowski has since gotten Cmdr. Scott’s name added to the West Deer memorial, and Mr. Imani flew in for a memorial ceremony in May 2017 -- and a very “emotional” tour around West Deer, where Mr. Szwaczkowski showed him Cmdr. Scott’s childhood home.

“Between him and Ann, they are totally devoted to Dain and his memory,” Mr. Szwaczkowski said. “I have never encountered anything like this in my life.”

Mrs. Scott and Mr. Imani both live in Port Orchard and talk daily.

Mrs. Scott flew to Pittsburgh in March to deliver remarks at the Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hall and Museum’s induction of Cmdr. Scott to their Hall of Valor. She and Mr. Imani gathered Cmdr. Scott’s citations and applied for his entry into the museum.

Mrs. Scott also has purchased a plot in Lakewood Memorial Gardens in Cheswick, where a granite marker with Cmdr. Scott’s portrait on it will be placed in the veterans section. She purchased burial rights for the land as well, in case his remains ever return.

“He’s going be memorialized in his own hometown,” she said. “They do have a hero in their area.”