Numbers from a U.S. Census Bureau survey suggest a surprisingly sharp drop in household income occurred in recent years among a number of Allegheny County’s relatively well-to-do northern communities.
The managers of those municipalities aren’t so sure about that. They’ve seen slim evidence — if any — to support the survey data showing substantial decline in household income over a five-year span in Pine, Marshall and Bradford Woods. Their drops were surpassed among the county’s municipalities only by Fox Chapel’s, while the adjacent communities of Richland and West Deer experienced more modest income dips, according to the census figures.
While some officials of the northern townships and boroughs acknowledge household income could be affected by some recent shifts — such as a rise in retirements among older residents, or from new multi-family housing developments that attract more middle-income than upper-income earners — for the most part they report their tax revenues and treasuries are doing quite well, thank you.
“I’m startled by that finding,” Marshall manager Neil McFadden said when told the census data showed a $14,180 drop in median household income in the township since a 2011 peak. “We are trending very positively as far as earned income tax collection.”
The income figures come from the American Community Survey, which census officials conduct nationally on an annual basis to obtain wide-ranging information about public trends. More than 2 million different households respond each year.

Because the annual sample size can be statistically shaky for information at the municipal level, the bureau publishes five-year composite data for more reliable information about trends in cities, boroughs and townships. Even when capturing responses from nearly 10 percent of the population in that manner, the bureau acknowledges margins of error still exist.
Median annual household income — the point at which half of households are above and half below a certain figure — is one statistic from the American Community Survey that is often used to gauge trends in economic well-being. When the Post-Gazette compared median household income data across Allegheny County for the most recent-five year composite, from 2012-2016, and compared it with information from the prior five years, 2007-11, some interesting details arose:
• Allegheny County households’ income improved generously between the two periods, rising $4,552 while U.S. households increased by $2,560. The Allegheny County median of $54,357 remained below the nation’s $55,322, but that has historically been the case, and the county moved closer to the national norm than in the past.
• Among 129 municipalities in the county (data for Trafford was not provided), 32 experienced a drop in median income between the two five-year periods.
• While the list of 32 communities trending downward included a few western and southern municipalities, many were working-class communities clustered to the east and northeast, particularly the Route 30/48 corridor (e.g. Braddock Hills, McKeesport, Versailles) and the Route 28 Allegheny Valley area (Brackenridge, Springdale, Tarentum).
• The biggest income drops were concentrated in relatively affluent northern communities that are typically viewed as attractive and thriving. Fox Chapel was the most extreme example, with a median household income drop estimated at $45,666 between the two five-year periods. The three biggest declines behind it were in Pine (-$14,184), Marshall (-$14,180) and Bradford Woods (-$13,906). Richland (-$1,409) and West Deer (-$1,415) also were down.
Despite the reported decline, median household income in those northern communities remained above average and in some cases is among the highest in the county. Fox Chapel’s $148,553 average for 2012-16 is the fourth highest, and Pine’s $131,484 the eighth highest. Part of the reason those communities were leaders in falling income was because they had so much room to fall from a high income starting point in 2007-11.
Making sense of the numbers presents difficulties. It’s all speculation, and municipal officials are sometimes skeptical of data that can be skewed by who gets surveyed among the population and who gets left out. The American Community Survey differs in that sense from the decennial population count, which hits every household.
With a few exceptions, earned income tax collections have been rising annually in the same municipalities that supposedly had a drop in household income. Those exceptions — which included Fox Chapel in 2009, Pine in 2016 and Bradford Woods in 2017 — did nothing to alarm their local officials and cause the municipalities serious harm, in light of positive overall trends that also include population gains.
Fox Chapel manager Gary Koehler speculated that if income truly is dropping, “some of it is due to retirements. The new residents coming in are younger and just don’t have the same earnings at this time of their lives as the people they replaced.”
Pine finance director Jan Kowalski said when officials reviewed potential causes for the 2016 tax collection drop, they came up with several possibilities in addition to retirees: corporate executives whose incomes might have been boosted by taking stock options in prior years but not 2016; layoffs by certain companies that employed a number of high-earning Pine residents; and new mixed-housing developments such as The Village of Pine, whose residents likely earn less on average than those in single-family detached homes.
Mr. McFadden said Marshall’s median income may similarly be affected by the 2015 addition of a 319-unit apartment complex, Ascent Four Thirty. Though upscale by apartment standards, its individual unit dwellers typically would gross less than a family in its own home.
At the same time, he and other officials said the municipalities can be impacted annually by the arrival or departure of a particularly high-tier wage-earner who appreciates the convenience of a North Hills suburb. They include the professional athlete who works on the North Shore (Pirates and Steelers) or who trains in Cranberry (Penguins).
“We’re going to lose Andrew McCutchen,” Mr. McFadden said with a chuckle. “That could make a huge difference.”
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.